Wow. For once I can only pat MC on the shoulder and pity him. Juat imagine asking scary girl, with every kind of rumours around her, "Are you realy used goods?" . And now imagine her telling you "No". Will you actualy believe her? Like realy? For all I care she may as well restore hymen through surgery lol.
So much bullshit about "Why don't you ask her first?". Human society does't work like that. Plus he has virgin fetish, it's his clear preference, so he has every right to actualy not being interested in her.