Rice Shoulder - Vol. 10 Ch. 94 - Born In The Worst Town

Contributor
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
624
Do people outside of New Jersey discriminate people from Camden? Is that a thing?
Wouldn't be shocked if there wasn't some minor discrimination that then gets exaggerated by this manga's logic.

(That said lolCamden, North Jersey>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>)
 
Supporter
Joined
Apr 19, 2023
Messages
642
I like the idea of indicating that they're not speaking Japanese with an extra, unbroken outline inside the speech bubble, but I don't remember if I've ever seen it in any other manga... It's it something used in other manga, is it just this author, or is it the translator group?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 17, 2023
Messages
4,835
Do people outside of New Jersey discriminate people from Camden? Is that a thing?
I think it's pretty common for Americans who grew up outside of poor cities to view cities as threatening places. There is a lot of cultural propaganda in the USA meant to make working class people hate each other, so they don't end up working together to overthrow the ruling class. It's a class-based bigotry often wrapped up in racial bigotry.

That said unless you grew up in the Philadelphia metro area, or relatively nearby like Princeton or Newark, you probably don't think about Camden specifically, but if Camden were mentioned you would think "Oh it's one of those terrible cities!" And if you grew up far from those cities, you stop separating them in your mind. Camden's ghetto becomes a symbol for Philadelphia, the Bronx becomes your image of all of New York City, etc.

Why did the Author here pick Camden? Maybe because of the Rocky films.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Apr 13, 2023
Messages
20
I like the idea of indicating that they're not speaking Japanese with an extra, unbroken outline inside the speech bubble, but I don't remember if I've ever seen it in any other manga... It's it something used in other manga, is it just this author, or is it the translator group?
The extra line is added by the mangaka. It's not the most common way to show that a character is speaking in another language, in most cases it's done by making the text horizontal instead of vertical, writing the text in katakana instead of kanji or using a different font.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 18, 2018
Messages
1,327
I think it's pretty common for Americans who grew up outside of poor cities to view cities as threatening places. There is a lot of cultural propaganda in the USA meant to make working class people hate each other, so they don't end up working together to overthrow the ruling class. It's a class-based bigotry often wrapped up in racial bigotry.

That said unless you grew up in the Philadelphia metro area, or relatively nearby like Princeton or Newark, you probably don't think about Camden specifically, but if Camden were mentioned you would think "Oh it's one of those terrible cities!" And if you grew up far from those cities, you stop separating them in your mind. Camden's ghetto becomes a symbol for Philadelphia, the Bronx becomes your image of all of New York City, etc.

Why did the Author here pick Camden? Maybe because of the Rocky films.
Probably a combination of Rocky being from Philly and at the time this was written Camden was one of the most dangerous cities in the US. The author wanted a run down dangerous place and Camden was at the top of the list
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top