Ryuu to Ayumu Nariagari Boukensha-dou ~Youzumi toshite S-Rank Party kara Tsuihou Sareta Kaifuku Majutsushi, Suterareta Saki de Saikyou no Shinryuu o …

Joined
Sep 10, 2023
Messages
1
Bruh i knew they would make a bullshit up to forgive her, sure, let a innocent guy to die making you a accomplice in a crime not blow your cover. what these writers have in their brain?
Not blowing her cover was probably only a small bit of it. It was two combat classes killing one healer. If she tried to step in, it'd be two combat classes killing two healers. The leader was teleported away from the group, so it's not like yelling would have done anything.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 9, 2023
Messages
189
Nah but like, I ship DionxYuki
Dion can double wield, obviously yuki did absolutely nothing wrong so there's no reason to go full "he should stay with eldora" but at this point how do you even choose?

Small, contained and justified harems are fine, once you go collecting like Pokémon is where the trouble starts (unless you're aijou rentarou)
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 7, 2019
Messages
1,442
Holy shit the faces were incredible in this.
And we can already sense some rivalry between the wives.
This chapter was perfection, thanks for the TL!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 7, 2019
Messages
388
His eyes definitely look the same as Eldora’s, which leads me to believe he was possessed by a dragon. Dion gets the same kind of eyes as well when he does the “Dragon Boost” ability.
Ch 16 pg 18-23.

All we know for sure is he was possessed by some shadowy being. Could be a dragon.
 
Group Leader
Joined
Oct 16, 2020
Messages
1,257
I haven't read that part myself directly but I didn't think it was all that bad when I read that spoiler, since it added to the list of things for the other older members to be punished for
Not blowing her cover was probably only a small bit of it. It was two combat classes killing one healer. If she tried to step in, it'd be two combat classes killing two healers. The leader was teleported away from the group, so it's not like yelling would have done anything.
I re-read the beginning and man there is not excusing her, she was aware that they were planning to kill Dion, hell, she was present in the planing!
1740154675627.png
She could have warned Yuki before they followed with it, she could have warned Yuki after they when along with it, she could have smuggled some healing and magic potions for him to use, she could have tried, if it wasn't Dion's luck bro would be dead.
There isn't any excuse in hell that could absolve her, she is as much of murderer than any of the other two, these writers simply cant understand the weight of one actions, i'm tired of terrible actions being justified by the stupidest of reasons.
Telling a person "Hey, two psychos are planning to kill your friend because they want to coup your party" don't blow a persons cover, at max Yuki and others would think, "Oh, this girl has basic morals, nice", but she didn't, so she is a murderer.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 3, 2023
Messages
612
I re-read the beginning and man there is not excusing her, she was aware that they were planning to kill Dion, hell, she was present in the planing!
View attachment 16926
She could have warned Yuki before they followed with it, she could have warned Yuki after they when along with it, she could have smuggled some healing and magic potions for him to use, she could have tried, if it wasn't Dion's luck bro would be dead.
There isn't any excuse in hell that could absolve her, she is as much of murderer than any of the other two, these writers simply cant understand the weight of one actions, i'm tired of terrible actions being justified by the stupidest of reasons.
Telling a person "Hey, two psychos are planning to kill your friend because they want to coup your party" don't blow a persons cover, at max Yuki and others would think, "Oh, this girl has basic morals, nice", but she didn't, so she is a murderer.
If dumb plots like this bother you this much, you must really hate undercover stories, or for that matter irl too, sacrificing a person for the sake of the greater good is the minimum casualty you could expect, ofc none would be better, but sometimes you can't afford it, Criola here is a vice captain of the Holy Knights that joined the party to investigate the guy due to some powerful drug and evil organization he may be linked to, Holy Knights are sort of like the police you can call it (they can pretty much do whatever they want, but goverment still holds a line), she wasn't an adventurer originally, but took her time to rise as one so she could join for around 3 years, she even recognize that she left the guy to die for the sake of her goal, she didn't get redeemed, but she didn't get punished either because it was her job, even if she get kicked out of the guild, it doesn't matter because is secondary, it always been through the work that she been doing her own thing too when they go to town even, so is not something they just pulled off, there always been hints
 
Last edited:
Group Leader
Joined
Oct 16, 2020
Messages
1,257
If dumb plots like this bother you this much, you must really hate undercover stories, or for that matter irl too, sacrificing a person for the sake of the greater good is the minimum casualty you could expect, ofc none would be better, but sometimes you can't afford it, Criola here is a vice captain of the Holy Knights that joined the party to investigate the guy due to some powerful drug and evil organization he may be linked to, Holy Knights are sort of like the police you can call it (they can pretty much do whatever they want, but goverment still holds a line), she wasn't an adventurer originally, but took her time to rise as one so she could join for around 3 years, she even recognize that she left the guy to die for the sake of her goal, she didn't get redeemed, but she didn't get punished either because it was her job, even if she get kicked out of the guild, it doesn't matter because is secondary, it always been through the work that she been doing her own thing too when they go to town even, so is not something they just pulled off, there always been hints

A cop's job or similar occupation is to serve and protect the public first and foremost. Dion is a civilan like any other person, a infiltrated cop or not, if found they were in cahoots with a suspect to kill a civil just to 'do their job' or 'make it easier' would surfer the consequences, simple as that.
Dion execution wasn't a colateral, it was a orchestrated event that she actively participated in, it's just plain dumb. She could've seen it as just doing her job, don't make it less of a crime and certainly makes her just as scummy as the other two.
Her actions were attempted murder, she must and would in any real scenerio be incriminated or atleast removed from duty.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 9, 2023
Messages
189

A cop's job or similar occupation is to serve and protect the public first and foremost. Dion is a civilan like any other person, a infiltrated cop or not, if found they were in cahoots with a suspect to kill a civil just to 'do their job' or 'make it easier' would surfer the consequences, simple as that.
Dion execution wasn't a colateral, it was a orchestrated event that she actively participated in, it's just plain dumb. She could've seen it as just doing her job, don't make it less of a crime and certainly makes her just as scummy as the other two.
Her actions were attempted murder, she must and would in any real scenerio be incriminated or atleast removed from duty.
You forget two things:

-this isn't a world that shares this world's moral or values

-that plot point was probably added after those first few chapters

It's literally like getting mad at the middle ages for not being progressive enough.
 
Joined
Feb 13, 2025
Messages
8

A cop's job or similar occupation is to serve and protect the public first and foremost. Dion is a civilan like any other person, a infiltrated cop or not, if found they were in cahoots with a suspect to kill a civil just to 'do their job' or 'make it easier' would surfer the consequences, simple as that.
Dion execution wasn't a colateral, it was a orchestrated event that she actively participated in, it's just plain dumb. She could've seen it as just doing her job, don't make it less of a crime and certainly makes her just as scummy as the other two.
Her actions were attempted murder, she must and would in any real scenerio be incriminated or atleast removed from duty.
Yeah does seem like a shitty plot point maybe the author added it in later on so he couldn’t quite polish some details before the betrayal. Would have been better to make her unaware of the murder plan until it happens and when It does she realized it would be pointless fighting 2 A Ranks risking death and failure of the investigation and instead vows to bring his murderers to justice later.

Something like that may have made much more sense and would feel better to the reader but that being said I’ve seen worst plot points so Im not going to discredit the author too much for this faux pas.

She was definitely not acting like a cop in this situation even when undercover they have limits. She was more like the CIA, getting their hands dirty and not giving a fuck as long as their mission is completed.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 3, 2023
Messages
612

A cop's job or similar occupation is to serve and protect the public first and foremost. Dion is a civilan like any other person, a infiltrated cop or not, if found they were in cahoots with a suspect to kill a civil just to 'do their job' or 'make it easier' would surfer the consequences, simple as that.
Dion execution wasn't a colateral, it was a orchestrated event that she actively participated in, it's just plain dumb. She could've seen it as just doing her job, don't make it less of a crime and certainly makes her just as scummy as the other two.
Her actions were attempted murder, she must and would in any real scenerio be incriminated or atleast removed from duty.
Yeah, except that this is not a real scenario and this is a fantasy work, fantasy police don't usually follow real life morals or line of thinking, you people need to stop moral policing like this is real life, if you can't make that difference, you shouldn't be reading these works, thats the first part you are failing at to grasp anything, but then again is the same people that moral police, but then go all unhinged on revenge comments, and even so in a real scenario, undercover still won't be judged under normal circumstances if they happen to execute someone, they don't get an scenario like in the movies, where they can save these civilians then kill the whole gang by themselves instead
Yeah does seem like a shitty plot point maybe the author added it in later on so he couldn’t quite polish some details before the betrayal. Would have been better to make her unaware of the murder plan until it happens and when It does she realized it would be pointless fighting 2 A Ranks risking death and failure of the investigation and instead vows to bring his murderers to justice later.

Something like that may have made much more sense and would feel better to the reader but that being said I’ve seen worst plot points so Im not going to discredit the author too much for this faux pas.

She was definitely not acting like a cop in this situation even when undercover they have limits. She was more like the CIA, getting their hands dirty and not giving a fuck as long as their mission is completed.
The plot point and every hint about one the members not being what they were saying, was there from the start, that you all missed this is another thing, they may be like the CIA or whatever but am not from NA so i dunno every branch they have or what they do, i just called it police, but you should know that fantasy cops aren't real cops lmao, they always do whatever they want, and what can you expect when the name is Holy Knights
 
Last edited:
Group Leader
Joined
Oct 16, 2020
Messages
1,257
You forget two things:

-this isn't a world that shares this world's moral or values

-that plot point was probably added after those first few chapters

It's literally like getting mad at the middle ages for not being progressive enough.
Nah, bad writing, and you are underestimating old civilizations law, moral and honor values
 
Group Leader
Joined
Oct 16, 2020
Messages
1,257
Yeah, except that this is not a real scenario and this is a fantasy work, fantasy police don't usually follow real life morals or line of thinking, you people need to stop moral policing like this is real life, if you can't make that difference, you shouldn't be reading these works, thats the first part you are failing at to grasp anything, and even so in a real scenario, undercover still won't be judged under normal circumstances if they happen to execute someone, they don't get an scenario like in the movies, where they can save these civilians then kill the whole gang by themselves instead

The plot point and every hint about one the members not being what they were saying, was there from the start, that you all missed this is another thing, i called it police, but you should know that fantasy cops aren't real cops lmao, they always do whatever they want, and what can you expect when the name is Holy Knights

Why you getting so angry bro? lmao. i said i am over authors trying to excuse shitty behaviours, never in the first post i complained about her actions being unrealistic or not, i complained about and quoting myself:
There isn't any excuse in hell that could absolve her, she is as much of murderer than any of the other two, these writers simply cant understand the weight of one actions, i'm tired of terrible actions being justified by the stupidest of reasons.
Fuck that she is undercover or her morals values, i was pissed about a murderer being redeemed, are you the authors alt to be so angry over this?
Of course the plot points were there from the start you think you are the only one who has eyes? The plot points being there dont change the fact that she tried to kill Dion lmao.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 3, 2023
Messages
612

Why you getting so angry bro? lmao. i said i am over authors trying to excuse shitty behaviours, never in the first post i complained about her actions being unrealistic or not, i complained about and quoting myself:
Sure dude am so angry, but nah, lil bro here forgot what he wrote in his last paragraph on the comment i replied to, that he tried to one up, nice one, but no

Her actions were attempted murder, she must and would in any real scenerio be incriminated or atleast removed from duty.

Fuck that she is undercover or her morals values, i was pissed about a murderer being redeemed, are you the authors alt to be so angry over this?
Of course the plot points were there from the start you think you are the only one who has eyes? The plot points being there dont change the fact that she tried to kill Dion lmao.
And on one the previous replies i especifically said no, she didn't get redeemed, she was fully aware of what she doing to fulfill her duty, she just didn't get punished, that is not a redemption, and even if she get a punishment from the guild, it didn't matter because is not her main job
 
Last edited:
Group Leader
Joined
Oct 16, 2020
Messages
1,257
Sure dude am so angry, but nah, lil bro here forgot what he wrote in his last paragraph on the comment i replied to, that he tried to one up, nice one, but no
Only said it because you brought over the fact of her being a cop/holy knight from nowhere to defend the plot, so you can only blame yourself for the change of topic. Or do you like conversations where people ignore the points you make?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 3, 2023
Messages
612
Only said it because you brought over the fact of her being a cop/holy knight from nowhere to defend the plot, so you can only blame yourself for the change of topic. Or do you like conversations where people ignore the points you make?
Lmao, that isn't even a change of topic, is adding more info about the original point back at the very first comment that isn't even yours, is not my fault that you can't follow something so simple and only glanced at the replies at your convenience
 
Group Leader
Joined
Oct 16, 2020
Messages
1,257
Lmao, that isn't even a change of topic, is adding more info about the original point back at the very first comment that isn't even yours, is not my fault that you can't follow something so simple and only glanced at the replies at your convenience
Bruh you just making things up now, you first talking about her job was literally an answer to me. Sorry about not liking your plot, author, next time we will only praise you! But please take some time to develop your brain, i beg you.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 17, 2023
Messages
684
one of the girls in the party is undercover investigating some shady stuff, the girl that had just joined when the story began, she didn't help dion because it would have blow her cover.
That logic is... blowing my mind.

She's investigating them for "shady stuff", the dude outright betrays and murders his own party member right in front of her, and that's not enough to incriminate him? I feel like anyone doing their fucking job right would've stopped him before somebody had to die to prove him guilty. In my mind, she's no better than he is, 'undercover investigation' be damned.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top