Scary Campus College University - Vol. 8 Ch. 68 - Scary Campus College University

Joined
Apr 14, 2023
Messages
1
Man, this was super unfortunate. Of course there couldn't be a 'satisfying' ending when the author was only given 3 chapters to finish the story. :( This was the first manga I've read since the beginning and also the first I've seen get axed in real time, and damn does it not feel good. Thank you Tanzanite Scans for your hard work, without you I wouldn't have known this gem existed! Even if the ending was sudden I'm still glad I got to read it :')
 
Group Leader
Joined
Mar 18, 2019
Messages
7
I'm sorry, but does Makube have an engagement ring? I will no longer wonder what happened to the rest of the cast, but did Makube get married? And married Iruko? Or is it all a projection of the ghost of the university? This ending is so-soooo confusing...
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 16, 2019
Messages
1,902
Yep, saw this coming. Actually, based on how poorly the manga was doing and how little it was moving the needle, I thought it was going to happen last volume.

The mangaka has been having trouble rebuilding an audience since the entire "Hoshino Me o Tsubutte" fiasco, which killed his fanbase at the time. His next manga then lasted about 20 chapters before meeting the axe. So, in all, this doesn't exactly come as a surprise, especially because, again, this manga has been struggling for the past few volumes now.

That being said, it does feel like he had a bit of momentum going on for a while, so there's a good chance that his next manga will fare better with a new audience behind him now.

I wish him luck.

What happened with that older series of his?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 26, 2020
Messages
77
I'm sorry, but does Makube have an engagement ring? I will no longer wonder what happened to the rest of the cast, but did Makube get married? And married Iruko? Or is it all a projection of the ghost of the university? This ending is so-soooo confusing...
Ohh! I didn't even notice this! That's a great catch. That and his new hairstyle I think means that a lot of time has elapsed in the real world, and Chigarashi is on her x number of loops in her retrying to live out her ideal college life. My last comment has more of what I think is happening. I think Iruko might be the one he's married to based on all the previous dialogue between the two.

This also reminds me how Iruko tried to trap Chigarashi with the other ghosts, and was wondering to Makube why he was treating her special. Maybe in Iruko's eyes, Chigarashi was no different from any of the other spirits that were there. And we now know that Makube was treating her differently because he too hasn't decided on what he wanted to do after college, so he was getting drawn in, staying in limbo trying to fix the past "mistakes" of his college life.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 7, 2019
Messages
101
Well considering how this manga got axed, makes sense we didn't really get a good ending for this story. Such a shame since it had something going for it. Thanks for the scans and good luck to this mangaka's next project!
This author doesn’t deserve slack. He nuked his other manga because it didn’t get an anime adaption. Hope he continues to fail.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 14, 2023
Messages
541
What happened with that older series of his?
What happened with Hoshino Me o Tsubutte, you mean?

Meh, I already spent too much time being angry after it ended, so, putting it shortly, it was a coming-of-age story about a girl with self-esteem issues, using makeup to cover them up, and a guy trying to find a place for himself, with them supporting each other.
It had a good cast of characters and actually decent development/relationships. Managing to build a decent fanbase over its 100+ chapters.

Until the mangaka decided to fuck it up with a pseudo-clean slate ending, with relationships apart, and characters going their own way, including the main couple acting like they don't know each other, for reasons that, while KIND of made sense if you ignore a lot of other factors, spit in the face of the development of the entire manga.

This outright killed the mangaka's fanbase at the time.

To make it better, the ending was retconned by getting the main couple together a few years after in-manga time, in a small omake released one month and a half after the manga, giving it the happy ending that everyone was expecting it to have.
But even that felt half-assed because the scene itself was so short, that only added to the frustration.

Of course, there's talk that the mangaka had already planned to make this omake anyway, so he didn't really "try to damage control," but it doesn't help that during that month and a half period, he got slightly confrontational on Twitter about the manga's ending.

Now, if you ask me, the manga last chapter plus the omake chapter makes the ending go from "outright garbage" to "a badly executed ending," yes, but for people who followed the manga release by release at the time, it was genuinely enraging how everything came to be.

Now, there are many speculations as to why the mangaka chose this ending because it was clear that it was going to upset a lot of people, especially if he already had the omake planned. One popular theory is that his possible anime adaptation was rejected, and he got angry, but this is nothing more than 4chan being 4chan, and nothing was ever confirmed.
Regardless, since then, he hasn't had the best of luck with his manga and has been trying to rebuild his fanbase, with little success so far.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 23, 2023
Messages
216
Alot of unanswered plots were put, but some chapters already hinted them like what happened to her best friend, seems like its true she was part of the Gods ploy and she is a fake, what happened to the Makube's friends too guess they also moved on. Sadly this had potential and its a good Metaphor for how difficult college life is specially the bad sides of it (Frat, Drugs, Prostitution, Gang Rape and more). Man why did this got axed.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 10, 2019
Messages
406
I'll miss you, Chigarashi 😭
Seriously, I love this series. It's so sad they had to axe it :')

Thanks a lot for your translations, Tanzanite!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 14, 2019
Messages
305
Well, I tried to keep my expectations low, but this still managed to be underwhelming. I wasn't expecting something on the level of Delinquent Exorcist (which adjusted the length of the story ahead of time to make it fit the axe schedule) or Goblin is Very Strong (which ended with the author himself detailing how he wanted the rest of the series to go), but this feels half-assed even as far as axed series go.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top