Shino to Ren - Vol. 2 Ch. 19 - Hiding in the Curtains

[MangaDex]

 

[Jackist]

How is this even acceptable as a manga on this site? I’ve seen Porn Game ads have more substance

 

[Asahinaz]

Damnn😵‍💫

 

[Ryuseishun]

It’s not even a manga at this point lol

But that’s not gonna stop me from continuing to read it 😅

 

[outinthegardener]

Those transparent curtains aren't hiding anything. The answer is "get caught flirting in the curtains."

How is this even acceptable as a manga on this site? I’ve seen Porn Game ads have more substance

Inevitable transformation of the medium due to new technology. This would never fly in a published paper magazine, but it could get a lot of clicks on a social media app. There's a broader question of should a manga site be sharing "web comics" or "anime girl ecchi illustrations," and I fall on the not-purist side. Why not? I like all three things so I'm happy to find them on one site.

 

[galaxia9]

I'd imagine their response would be to tell the intruder to go away, they're busy.

 

[LTalon]

I'd certainly say we're barely a manga at this point, but earlier chapters certainly were, so this probably deserves to be grandfathered in at the very least.

Also I'm glad I'm not the only one who was thinking about how those curtains ain't hiding anything.

 

[Shieldon]

How is this even acceptable as a manga on this site?

It started as one, but it derived as Convenient Semifriend and now it will be novelized so from this point on these are just illustrations.

 

[iririuuu]

sad that half of the chapters aren't actually chapters

 

[JJTheWeeb]

Those transparent curtains aren't hiding anything. The answer is "get caught flirting in the curtains."


Inevitable transformation of the medium due to new technology. This would never fly in a published paper magazine, but it could get a lot of clicks on a social media app. There's a broader question of should a manga site be sharing "web comics" or "anime girl ecchi illustrations," and I fall on the not-purist side. Why not? I like all three things so I'm happy to find them on one site.

one thing to note is that this got published as a book which is labeled manga, so yea, the nuance gets funky further since publishers are also a play (the "respect the author/publisher's words" vs "I will be the judge of it" that you see with tags or other aspects are always judged by flip-flop reasoning lol).

I will blame this "image sequences are manga" on tawawa on a monday's original doujin since it's this same format, but more speech bubbles in the full spread images, also the oldest one I know of.

But yea, in this, this manga is published as a manga in the book format of a manga, so I don't see why it wouldn't be here (tho it's probably more because of the comic style segments this gets)