Sipiji Sonyeo - Ch. 50 - Season 1 End

Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2025
Messages
42
So there isn't a Zodiac race, and the main goal of gathering all the spirit hosts is to reincarnate the jade lord or whatever? I wonder what the full story behind this is and what exactly Rabin's role is in all of it.

It also seems like there are two types of hosts: the reincarnated ones, who know something about Nina (the rat's side), and the awakened ones (mc's side), kind of like in jjk.
 
Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2025
Messages
42
So now it will be Harem vs Harem and our mc will always question if the girls love him or if it's the zodia spirits in love with huwang. This is why I hate reincarnation romances.
The girls who love him were already in love with him before the zodiac race, though. And it seems that being a zodiac ≠ having feelings for the mc, since there are hosts who are indifferent to him, like the nurse or the horse.

But ngl, Nina is already pissing me off by trying to project her old crush onto the mc. I hope there isn't any bullshit later where it's choose Nina, or choose Rabin just because they were destined to be together in a previous life, rather than because they genuinely love each other.

If you're going to do romance, then do it properly. Otherwise, just let it stay a harem.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 26, 2023
Messages
4,877
The girls who love him were already in love with him before the zodiac race, though. And it seems that being a zodiac ≠ having feelings for the mc, since there are hosts who are indifferent to him, like the nurse or the horse.

But ngl, Nina is already pissing me off by trying to project her old crush onto the mc. I hope there isn't any bullshit later where it's choose Nina, or choose Rabin just because they were destined to be together in a previous life, rather than because they genuinely love each other.

If you're going to do romance, then do it properly. Otherwise, just let it stay a harem.
Not only is she seeing the guy she loved, he is physically changing into him. So are his thoughts and memories becoming his.

Also, I don't know how much Rabin was really into him before all of this started. She could of been your standard tsundere childhood friend with a hidden crush, or she may not have really had any feelings for him. Guess I'm gonna need to re-read.

That also goes for the other girls. The may have all had a bit of a crush on him, but the Zodic spirits may have amplified it.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Mar 27, 2026
Messages
395
Noo my Rabin, please comeback later quickly
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Sep 19, 2020
Messages
88
Last hidden character should be monkey shown in the prologue chapter 0. Tiger was featured in ch3
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 19, 2021
Messages
3,929
Last hidden character should be monkey shown in the prologue chapter 0. Tiger was featured in ch3
Last hidden ia Ox, i am waiting a girl with ample rack

Then, the MC ia a god, and virgin, he doesnt love nobody and only hurt at Rabin
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 13, 2019
Messages
4,511
Are we sure that dude is a host? The title of this series is clearly the 12 Zodiac Girls. Not the 11 Zodiac Girls and a Dude.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 1, 2019
Messages
769
The plot got messy, not gonna lie. The first half of the volume seemed like your typical harem, but then it suddenly changed direction midway through.

Actually, the very beginning was already confusing, and the premise didn’t feel particularly fluid. For example, there’s the Horse girl, who has little to no connection with Woo-jin. Then there’s the Rat guy and the other hosts, who, as far as I can tell, also have no connection with Woo-jin. That makes me question the earlier claim that only people connected to Woo-jin can be reincarnated as hosts—unless there’s more to it, like Rat somehow hijacking the race or manipulating the reincarnation process.

They also seem to have backpedaled on the whole “there’s no other way to transfer divine energy unless the hosts devour the Judge” thing. Like before getting devoured by snake, woo jin was helpless because he cant transfer energy, but on Sheep arc they can do it via physical contact? Also, what happened to the full transformation Woo-jin underwent against Snake? Wasn’t that supposed to establish something important about how the divine energy works?

Snake also got completely sidelined without making any meaningful contribution to the plot afterward. And the entire Horse arc is just a filler. It doesn’t really contribute to the main story beyond introducing Rat.

I was actually anticipating the Zodiac battle, but I can’t help feeling that this was never the author’s original intention. It feels like the story may have been redirected, possibly with editorial input, toward a Zodiac battle because having twelve girls repeatedly playing some variation of capture-the-flag would eventually become stale, repetitive, and boring. And honestly, I don’t have a problem with that change. I think expanding the premise beyond the original harem formula was probably the right decision.

The problem is the execution. There wasn’t enough foreshadowing or groundwork for the shift, so it feels less like a natural progression of the story and more like the author suddenly changed directions midway through.

And then there’s the title. If Rat and Dragon are actually male Zodiac characters, then we’re no longer talking about twelve Zodiac girls. It’s ten Zodiac girls and two Zodiac dudes. That makes the title feel even more disconnected from what the story has become.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 9, 2023
Messages
685
even dragon is a dude, there has to be something beyond just the title
My theory if the author isn't gonna send this off the rails, is that the dragon can chose their sex and at the moment is choosing to be a guy.. kinda fits with their neutrality position. I'm also convinced the rat is cross-dressing and has the wrong understanding of Hwanung's motives - at least there's more to them being selfishly motivated.

I'll bet it's linked with the mc being probably 'reincarnated' (mentioned in an earlier chapter by the rat), the 'fate' theme mentioned a few times now (considering Rabin is also reincarnated) but also something to do with the mc's innate resistance to showing favour towards any of the girls individually.

What is clear from earlier chapters is Tiger girl & Dog girl have been cleaning up nasty people (Ch31 if you want to enjoy the moment again).. so from their perspective they're the 'good guys'. Only monkey girl has been outright hostile but maybe that fits with their 'mischevious' nature. Begs the question of why they want to stop Hwanung and how the cat fits into all this!

Also agree with some of the other comments - do wish the author would elaborate a bit more on the girls backgrounds and their relationships with the zodiac animals. Also sidelining some of the girls I think is ok for a little while but hopfully they'll be reintroduced and join the club later!
 
Member
Joined
May 4, 2026
Messages
4
My theory if the author isn't gonna send this off the rails, is that the dragon can chose their sex and at the moment is choosing to be a guy.. kinda fits with their neutrality position. I'm also convinced the rat is cross-dressing and has the wrong understanding of Hwanung's motives - at least there's more to them being selfishly motivated.

I'll bet it's linked with the mc being probably 'reincarnated' (mentioned in an earlier chapter by the rat), the 'fate' theme mentioned a few times now (considering Rabin is also reincarnated) but also something to do with the mc's innate resistance to showing favour towards any of the girls individually.

What is clear from earlier chapters is Tiger girl & Dog girl have been cleaning up nasty people (Ch31 if you want to enjoy the moment again).. so from their perspective they're the 'good guys'. Only monkey girl has been outright hostile but maybe that fits with their 'mischevious' nature. Begs the question of why they want to stop Hwanung and how the cat fits into all this!

Also agree with some of the other comments - do wish the author would elaborate a bit more on the girls backgrounds and their relationships with the zodiac animals. Also sidelining some of the girls I think is ok for a little while but hopfully they'll be reintroduced and join the club later!
Thanks for giving my comment a Good button.
I hope you’ll also check out what I posted, since it includes some background from the producer about how Zodiac Girls was developed and produced. I also hope more people can become aware of this background and keep it in mind when discussing the series.
For some context, this is a retrospective written by the former producer of Zodiac Girls. His name stopped appearing in the credits starting from Chapter 37.

-PD's Instagram(translate)

The last project I worked on was Zodiac Girls.
After about a year of serialization, it came to an end with 51 chapters, including the afterword!
I had planned to write this as soon as the author’s afterword was posted, but...
Anyway, this is my somewhat belated retrospective on the completion of Zodiac Girls.

Like <Realization of Justice> and <Kowloon: Soroka>, this was also a difficult project to work on, but Zodiac Girls was especially challenging.
The genre we originally wanted to make was something closer to a realistic romantic comedy with stronger drama elements. However, the company and the platform kept rejecting the proposals, and Zodiac Girls was eventually created after seven different project pitches.

I suppose this kind of thing happens throughout the industry, but there were parts of the process that were difficult to understand.
One of the initial project concepts was based on shamans and spirit possession, but we were told that those were too niche, and that we should avoid making works based on shamanistic themes in the future.

But not long after that, <Exhuma> was released and surpassed 10 million admissions, and dramas based on Korean shamanistic beliefs, such as <Head Over Heels>, were also launched.
<ShaMONEYism>, another series on Naver Webtoon, had also done well, and with ShaMONEYism-related OTT productions, games, and other content already in development and lined up for release, it was honestly very difficult to understand that feedback at the time.
But what could we do? If they told us to change it, we had to change it.

By the fifth or sixth proposal, we had already removed everything we were told to remove and changed everything we were told to change, only for even that project made almost entirely according to their instructions to be rejected. At that point, feeling almost completely defeated, we decided to abandon that direction altogether and switch to a high-concept premise instead. Since we had already lost so much time throughout the process, we put the new proposal together in about a week and submitted it almost out of desperation... and somehow, that one was approved exactly as it was.

Anyway, if I may make a bit of an excuse, if readers felt that the story or some of the setting was lacking, this complicated development process was one of the reasons behind it... haha.

I have a lot of respect for the author, who kept trusting the project and patiently waiting despite all the setbacks along the way. @jiji__man

This was a project that taught me a lot and gave me many new perspectives as a producer. At one point, the author and I also participated in Seoul Comic World together. It was my first time meeting readers in person, and I was surprised by how many of them were elementary and middle school students.

The comments section was mostly filled with somewhat sexual remarks and mischievous comments, but meeting readers in person also made me realize once again that there were many people who genuinely cared about and seriously enjoyed the series.

Because of what you might call adult circumstances behind the scenes, we had to bring Season 1 to a close for the time being and take a break. Still, for the sake of the readers who have followed the series so sincerely, I hope we can somehow create the right conditions to return to it someday, show the story we originally wanted to tell through this work, and bring it to a proper conclusion.
 
Member
Joined
May 4, 2026
Messages
4
My theory if the author isn't gonna send this off the rails, is that the dragon can chose their sex and at the moment is choosing to be a guy.. kinda fits with their neutrality position. I'm also convinced the rat is cross-dressing and has the wrong understanding of Hwanung's motives - at least there's more to them being selfishly motivated.

I'll bet it's linked with the mc being probably 'reincarnated' (mentioned in an earlier chapter by the rat), the 'fate' theme mentioned a few times now (considering Rabin is also reincarnated) but also something to do with the mc's innate resistance to showing favour towards any of the girls individually.

What is clear from earlier chapters is Tiger girl & Dog girl have been cleaning up nasty people (Ch31 if you want to enjoy the moment again).. so from their perspective they're the 'good guys'. Only monkey girl has been outright hostile but maybe that fits with their 'mischevious' nature. Begs the question of why they want to stop Hwanung and how the cat fits into all this!

Also agree with some of the other comments - do wish the author would elaborate a bit more on the girls backgrounds and their relationships with the zodiac animals. Also sidelining some of the girls I think is ok for a little while but hopfully they'll be reintroduced and join the club later!
Hello K-Lye. I posted a comment earlier, but apparently it needs moderator approval, so I’m leaving this message here for now.

What I posted was an English translation of a post the former producer shared on Instagram. Since it’s quite long, it seems the comment won’t be visible to everyone until it gets approved by a moderator.

and thanks for giving my comment a Like button.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 9, 2023
Messages
685
Thanks for giving my comment a Good button.
I hope you’ll also check out what I posted, since it includes some background from the producer about how Zodiac Girls was developed and produced. I also hope more people can become aware of this background and keep it in mind when discussing the series.
For some context, this is a retrospective written by the former producer of Zodiac Girls. His name stopped appearing in the credits starting from Chapter 37.

-PD's Instagram(translate)

The last project I worked on was Zodiac Girls.
After about a year of serialization, it came to an end with 51 chapters, including the afterword!
I had planned to write this as soon as the author’s afterword was posted, but...
Anyway, this is my somewhat belated retrospective on the completion of Zodiac Girls.

Like <Realization of Justice> and <Kowloon: Soroka>, this was also a difficult project to work on, but Zodiac Girls was especially challenging.
The genre we originally wanted to make was something closer to a realistic romantic comedy with stronger drama elements. However, the company and the platform kept rejecting the proposals, and Zodiac Girls was eventually created after seven different project pitches.

I suppose this kind of thing happens throughout the industry, but there were parts of the process that were difficult to understand.
One of the initial project concepts was based on shamans and spirit possession, but we were told that those were too niche, and that we should avoid making works based on shamanistic themes in the future.

But not long after that, <Exhuma> was released and surpassed 10 million admissions, and dramas based on Korean shamanistic beliefs, such as <Head Over Heels>, were also launched.
<ShaMONEYism>, another series on Naver Webtoon, had also done well, and with ShaMONEYism-related OTT productions, games, and other content already in development and lined up for release, it was honestly very difficult to understand that feedback at the time.
But what could we do? If they told us to change it, we had to change it.

By the fifth or sixth proposal, we had already removed everything we were told to remove and changed everything we were told to change, only for even that project made almost entirely according to their instructions to be rejected. At that point, feeling almost completely defeated, we decided to abandon that direction altogether and switch to a high-concept premise instead. Since we had already lost so much time throughout the process, we put the new proposal together in about a week and submitted it almost out of desperation... and somehow, that one was approved exactly as it was.

Anyway, if I may make a bit of an excuse, if readers felt that the story or some of the setting was lacking, this complicated development process was one of the reasons behind it... haha.

I have a lot of respect for the author, who kept trusting the project and patiently waiting despite all the setbacks along the way. @jiji__man

This was a project that taught me a lot and gave me many new perspectives as a producer. At one point, the author and I also participated in Seoul Comic World together. It was my first time meeting readers in person, and I was surprised by how many of them were elementary and middle school students.

The comments section was mostly filled with somewhat sexual remarks and mischievous comments, but meeting readers in person also made me realize once again that there were many people who genuinely cared about and seriously enjoyed the series.

Because of what you might call adult circumstances behind the scenes, we had to bring Season 1 to a close for the time being and take a break. Still, for the sake of the readers who have followed the series so sincerely, I hope we can somehow create the right conditions to return to it someday, show the story we originally wanted to tell through this work, and bring it to a proper conclusion.
Yea well.. I'm all for author freedom to create their own vision but imho too many authors (particularly with manhwa/donghua) are guilty of over-complicating their stories. In this case based on the Afterword I think the Production company was right to reign them in. Hopefully they aren't too disillusioned though and do come back soon for S2 soon!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top