Considering that one chapter a little bit ago with the Goddess’s dialogue while the hero party was praying at the church, it wouldn’t shock me.Calling it now, Old Man Kaosberg is laying mad pipe to the Goddess and this whole thing is just a huge misunderstanding.
They were usually with other people, both have guested it but Yuri was with her party members and he usually had some of his subordinates.Honestly, I'm surprised it took either of them this long to ask about reincarnation.