The End of This Fairytale Is One Hell of a Drama - Oneshot
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2020
- Messages
- 107
Is it supposed to sound like a thick Scottish accent...?
Member
- Joined
- Feb 8, 2020
- Messages
- 278
what the fuck lol
- Joined
- May 2, 2020
- Messages
- 102
@blackLuna i learned something new today 
cheers!
cheers!
Contributor
- Joined
- Mar 10, 2019
- Messages
- 289
@herianca You're welcome! I'm glad this passing language nerd could be of use.
To be precise: It's best to be careful with the term "Scottish" when referring to language since it could mean three different things: Scottish English (a set of English dialects), the Scots language (a different register of English, according to most speakers), or Scottish Gaelic. While Scottish English versus Scots is more of an issue for reading than speaking, Scottish Gaelic is another animal altogether (Celtic languages are not Germanic, let alone English: we know that they're both Indo-European languages and that's about it).
Scots is difficult when there are so many dialectal words… and little context to use to interpret it. Which is one reason I don't practice my foreign languages using comics, manga, manhua, manhwa, etc. (That, unfamiliar slang, and laziness… a lot of laziness.)
I wonder just how the language-flag thing works on this site (personally, I couldn't find information on it, anyway) — does anyone know if there's a directory or guide somewhere on this site for that? (I kind of want to practice one of my languages, but…)
To my present understanding, Mangadex has you mark languages by a country's flag (or territory, in the case of Chinese with traditional characters). If you simply mark by country, you're indicating the language most spoken there or the official language, then it generally works, true. However, this isn't a perfect solution (case and point: India and China). Even with the British Isles, there's also Celtic languages (actually, France has one too). Hypothetically, how would Celtic languages be labelled? With the Irish flag?— that would only apply to Irish Gaelic; the other Celtic languages are different enough that using the same flag for them would be completely inappropriate (not to mention the hard feelings people have). While it's true that Celtic languages aren't spoken by very many people (so it presents less of an issue here), Standard Chinese versus Cantonese, Hindi versus Tamil, etc. all are potential issues down the line (if not already).
This release shows how this system has difficulties even with English: a dialect or register with a significantly divergent orthography will not read the same way, even if they are practically mutually intelligible when spoken (unless you are familiar with said variety). With English, Scottish English wouldn't really be an issue, since it uses modern British spelling, which would make any dialectal terminology an all-but-trivial matter (thanks to a good understanding of the context). However, marking a Scots text as English gets to be problematic, since it uses different pronunciation and is spelt the way it sounds now (standard English orthography includes a lot of historical spelling instead); so reading-wise, it can be quite difficult even without the dialectal terms (and this release had a number of them, beginning midway though). This is the second time I've encountered such a release and looking at the comments found utter confusion (although, this one is more difficult). Is there a secondary label for this stuff or something?
To be precise: It's best to be careful with the term "Scottish" when referring to language since it could mean three different things: Scottish English (a set of English dialects), the Scots language (a different register of English, according to most speakers), or Scottish Gaelic. While Scottish English versus Scots is more of an issue for reading than speaking, Scottish Gaelic is another animal altogether (Celtic languages are not Germanic, let alone English: we know that they're both Indo-European languages and that's about it).
Scots is difficult when there are so many dialectal words… and little context to use to interpret it. Which is one reason I don't practice my foreign languages using comics, manga, manhua, manhwa, etc. (That, unfamiliar slang, and laziness… a lot of laziness.)
I wonder just how the language-flag thing works on this site (personally, I couldn't find information on it, anyway) — does anyone know if there's a directory or guide somewhere on this site for that? (I kind of want to practice one of my languages, but…)
To my present understanding, Mangadex has you mark languages by a country's flag (or territory, in the case of Chinese with traditional characters). If you simply mark by country, you're indicating the language most spoken there or the official language, then it generally works, true. However, this isn't a perfect solution (case and point: India and China). Even with the British Isles, there's also Celtic languages (actually, France has one too). Hypothetically, how would Celtic languages be labelled? With the Irish flag?— that would only apply to Irish Gaelic; the other Celtic languages are different enough that using the same flag for them would be completely inappropriate (not to mention the hard feelings people have). While it's true that Celtic languages aren't spoken by very many people (so it presents less of an issue here), Standard Chinese versus Cantonese, Hindi versus Tamil, etc. all are potential issues down the line (if not already).
This release shows how this system has difficulties even with English: a dialect or register with a significantly divergent orthography will not read the same way, even if they are practically mutually intelligible when spoken (unless you are familiar with said variety). With English, Scottish English wouldn't really be an issue, since it uses modern British spelling, which would make any dialectal terminology an all-but-trivial matter (thanks to a good understanding of the context). However, marking a Scots text as English gets to be problematic, since it uses different pronunciation and is spelt the way it sounds now (standard English orthography includes a lot of historical spelling instead); so reading-wise, it can be quite difficult even without the dialectal terms (and this release had a number of them, beginning midway though). This is the second time I've encountered such a release and looking at the comments found utter confusion (although, this one is more difficult). Is there a secondary label for this stuff or something?
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2020
- Messages
- 29
What? Just what was I read-deciphering.... just now...
@blackluna bless the language lesson
I'm glad it ended up being spelt the way it sounds at least. Made it just slightly easier to read... I guess as long as you're English fluent and semi used to accents 😅
I'm glad it ended up being spelt the way it sounds at least. Made it just slightly easier to read... I guess as long as you're English fluent and semi used to accents 😅
