Tsugumomo

Contributor
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
2,103
the primary focus in this title is not sexual content. The Definition on the depiction of genitalia is a bit too far stretched here.
"mature" replaced "pornogrpahic" and thats what you should keep in mind.
the chapters in the regular tsugumomo title are not pornographic.
Doesn't matter if the primary focus of the title isn't sexual content (I'd say one of Tsugumomo's primary focuses is sexual content anyways, but thats a separate convo). I asked and got clarification on discord that if a title has ANY DEPICTION of censored genitalia its rating should be upped to Mature. Doesn't matter if its a single instance or multiple, thats how the guidelines should be enforced according to the mod I asked.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 28, 2019
Messages
313
Doesn't matter if the primary focus of the title isn't sexual content (I'd say one of Tsugumomo's primary focuses is sexual content anyways, but thats a separate convo). I asked and got clarification on discord that if a title has ANY DEPICTION of censored genitalia its rating should be upped to Mature. Doesn't matter if its a single instance or multiple, thats how the guidelines should be enforced according to the mod I asked.
thats why i said that last paragraph needs some review.
i cant remember the depiction of censored genitalia in tsugumomo
where is the difference between not drawing a part, whiting it out or replacing it whith an object like a banana ?



who did you ask on discord, btw?
 
Contributor
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
2,103
i cant remember the depiction of censored genitalia in tsugumomo

who did you ask on discord, btw?
Tsugumomo uses many different ways to censor genitalia. Whiting it out, stickers, leaving it blank, "area effects", etc. Pretty much every spiritual intercourse scene in the series has some variation of it.

Bartolumiu
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 28, 2019
Messages
313
Tsugumomo uses many different ways to censor genitalia. Whiting it out, stickers, leaving it blank, "area effects", etc. Pretty much every spiritual intercourse scene in the series has some variation of it.

Bartolumiu
The Title has been running over 8 years now without anyone having an issue and now suddenly Tsugu and other Titles get "upgraded" .
You have to ask yourself: Is Tsugumomo Porn? Yes or No ?
 
Contributor
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
2,103
The Title has been running over 8 years now without anyone having an issue and now suddenly Tsugu and other Titles get "upgraded" .
You have to ask yourself: Is Tsugumomo Porn? Yes or No ?
What content rating I think a title deserves has no bearing. The only thing that matters is what content rating the MD guidelines say the title falls under. And in this case, and with the current wording of the guidelines, they clearly say the title should have the Mature tag. It would be anarchy if anyone with the powers to edit would just edit according to their personal "vibes".
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 28, 2019
Messages
313
It would be anarchy if anyone with the powers to edit would just edit according to their personal "vibes".
happened before and is likely happening right now.
these guidlines, especially the last paragrphs, should be rephrased and changed.
originally this defintion was for porn. Staff simply changed the word "pronographic" to "mature" witout touching the description.
this is misleading. if the discussion was about: "is Tsugu porn?" we would not be where we are right now.
thats what it used to look like

 
Contributor
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
2,103
happened before and is likely happening right now.
these guidlines, especially the last paragrphs, should be rephrased and changed.
originally this defintion was for porn. Staff simply changed the word "pronographic" to "mature" witout touching the description.
this is misleading. if the discussion was about: "is Tsugu porn?" we would not be where we are right now.
thats what it used to look like
If thats what the description used to look like, all that changes is that Tsugu should have been upped to Pornographic long ago. The content rating descriptions exist for a reason and should be followed.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 28, 2019
Messages
313
the rating is wrong and it had not been applied for years on Tsugu for good measure.
this tag and description was intended for titles that truly are porn.
 
Group Leader
Joined
Dec 17, 2025
Messages
12
the primary focus in this title is not sexual content. The Definition on the depiction of genitalia is a bit too far stretched here.
"mature" replaced "pornogrpahic" and thats what you should keep in mind.
the chapters in the regular tsugumomo title are not pornographic.

if this is the new scale, hundreds of other titles would have to be "upgraded" from erotica to mature too.
@Bartolumiu @Grogzilla Please consider this and revert the rating of this title.
maybe redphrase the last part of the mature definition.
not to mention the countless oneshots and short mangas with some sex scenes and uncencored nipples but are still rated "suggestive"
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 31, 2025
Messages
246
Oh dang it got the mature rating.

I think that fits better for the uncensored version(in related tab) like with doujins/senien manga where sex is visible and shown in detail..or just hentai. Like guy above said there's suggestive manga with nips but it's not labeled as erotica since that isn't main purpose, for tsugumomo the erotic is a main focus but unless you're looking at the uncensored version it never shows sex very detailed in the art. There's also a general plot that can not feature sex(thigh) for multiple chapters. Idk I think the tags are pretty badly enforced on mangadex in general.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top