Tsuihou Sareta Tensei Juu Kishi wa Game Chishiki de Musou Suru
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2018
- Messages
- 5,156
The art is top-notch, and the protagonists are appealing. But the story paints-by-numbers, and the butt-hangers are really annoying.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- May 25, 2018
- Messages
- 1,111
The story pattern is:
-Go to new place
-Challenge area above what people of their level would
-Encounter Mobs/Boss way over their level
-Defeat it with newly gained ability/power and Game knowledge strategy
-Repeat
He could spend some time saving up some wealth and leveling to get to be on par with the mobs, but that never happens because reasons.
-Go to new place
-Challenge area above what people of their level would
-Encounter Mobs/Boss way over their level
-Defeat it with newly gained ability/power and Game knowledge strategy
-Repeat
He could spend some time saving up some wealth and leveling to get to be on par with the mobs, but that never happens because reasons.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Sep 25, 2019
- Messages
- 623
Luce is so precious. Must protecc her, but she attacc too.
Not great, a bit worse than standard isekai trash. I like isekai, but story could at least be coherent with itself for the first few chapters. Basic premise of people in this world not knowing how strong a class could be, or a class taking a long time to level up or become usefull... is basicly proven wrong in the first 3 chapters as all the limits they claimed exist and acclaimed slow level raise was just plain false.... Raising levels at same speed as everyone else, at least as strong it seems from the getgo if not stronger.... The only possible excuse this world could have for not knowing the strength of the supposed lower classes is that the world is 1 day old, as thats how long it took for said lower class to prove stronger in the eyes of the common folk than an average person
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2020
- Messages
- 416
The class is considered weak because it has the worst attack power of any combat class regardless of level. (It's unknown if Merchant or other non-combat classes have better attack power or not.) So for any party of competent combatants, there's no reason to ever have a Heavy Knight in their party.
MC is only good because he knows you can add the skill book that basically turns you into a berserker (that most people avoid unless they're suicidal)... and the Heavy Knight class will either mitigate the weaknesses of the Smoldering Fang of Madness, or raise its power to absurd levels.
I'm pretty sure he is well beyond the normal perception of strong by the time he saves the guy from the frogs or whatever which just touch him and die. Yes, is still struggling to keep up with the top 10% of the elite like his sister. But he seems well beyond normal before getting any books. You would think an average adventurer would know all they need is a couple newly awakened heavy knights to sleep by the trees around the parameter to kill off all the "small fries" (that they can't beat themselves) while they pick herbs or whatever
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2020
- Messages
- 734
This is actually a really nice isekai series. It starts out small and really lets you get to know the world and the characters, and then slowly grows in scale.
The MC is kind but not a pushover, competent but not flawless, and he is capable of exceeding expectations only via his information, with no cheat skills required. The battle tactics are also nice and creative.
My only problem is the inconsistency of the stats. Like, the first time we see him check his status, his Iron Armor gives him +5 to defense. Now that he has black steel, it gives his defense +15. But what about the Shield of Madness that should give +25?
The MC is kind but not a pushover, competent but not flawless, and he is capable of exceeding expectations only via his information, with no cheat skills required. The battle tactics are also nice and creative.
My only problem is the inconsistency of the stats. Like, the first time we see him check his status, his Iron Armor gives him +5 to defense. Now that he has black steel, it gives his defense +15. But what about the Shield of Madness that should give +25?
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Dec 16, 2020
- Messages
- 94
The art is surprisingly good, the plot is fine I guess? I don’t really like how the game element is designed and functions, but other wise it has many chapters out and can be a good read if your just browsing and reading for entertainment and not to find a story that will bring you to tears with how good it is.
The art is good and for the genre the plot is decent. The protagonist and his main companion are both likeable and have good designs.
The biggest problem is that about halfway through the author starts introducing absolutely insufferable characters that they are clearly really attached too and keep relevant.
The biggest problem is that about halfway through the author starts introducing absolutely insufferable characters that they are clearly really attached too and keep relevant.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Mar 1, 2020
- Messages
- 636
This one is solid 9/10 at the current chapter.
the art is good,
the author has sufficient experience with MMORPG game which is something even the author of most popular MMORPG story lacking and often turn the story into linear RPG.
the characters are also likable and not one dimensional.
MC is OP ? it not actually a bad thing if done right and how author explain it is "make sense" and even including why the job is actually not that good if not for MC specific build.
the art is good,
the author has sufficient experience with MMORPG game which is something even the author of most popular MMORPG story lacking and often turn the story into linear RPG.
the characters are also likable and not one dimensional.
MC is OP ? it not actually a bad thing if done right and how author explain it is "make sense" and even including why the job is actually not that good if not for MC specific build.
- Joined
- Aug 16, 2023
- Messages
- 1
Anyone have an idea when chapter 63 and onwards will drop? Or what chapters from the LN should I read to find the dungeon exploration arc?
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Mar 30, 2023
- Messages
- 1,174
Remember reading this a year and a half ago and instantly dropped after reading chapter 1 because how it it pained me after finishing it.
The art isn't bad and kind of "so good it's bad" with how goofy the faces can be, but that wasn't the reason for the drop, it was the face palming reason for the plot to happen. Despite the isekai world being from an MMO game, how can a "joke/trash class" (aka heavy knight) still be considered trash if MC somehow knows how to make it the "strongest class" without it still being called the joke/trash class and other people not knowing it as well? In terms of realism that plot point the is the most fiction in this series because other people will find out what makes the heavy knight class so op eventually. Whether it's because people are weridos who like to waste their time min-maxing dumb builds or testers doing it to get info for that games wiki. The power scaling also seems pretty dumb since MC was able to kill a small group of monsters just by standing still, meanwhile a more experienced adventurer was running for his life from said small group of monsters. MC stats aren't even in the double digits and are considered "so low" even in-verse of the isekai world
But because I'm a masochist I'm going read this again to see why this series has a rating higher than 7 (currently 8.08) to see if it actually does get better later on or if this isekai is better trash to read compared to others. Also really hoping for interesting or actually good ways that author will prove why the apparent "joke/trash class" should be considered the "strongest" (but god I hope it doesn't go to the loli naofumi route of throwing BS to say why its op)
The art isn't bad and kind of "so good it's bad" with how goofy the faces can be, but that wasn't the reason for the drop, it was the face palming reason for the plot to happen. Despite the isekai world being from an MMO game, how can a "joke/trash class" (aka heavy knight) still be considered trash if MC somehow knows how to make it the "strongest class" without it still being called the joke/trash class and other people not knowing it as well? In terms of realism that plot point the is the most fiction in this series because other people will find out what makes the heavy knight class so op eventually. Whether it's because people are weridos who like to waste their time min-maxing dumb builds or testers doing it to get info for that games wiki. The power scaling also seems pretty dumb since MC was able to kill a small group of monsters just by standing still, meanwhile a more experienced adventurer was running for his life from said small group of monsters. MC stats aren't even in the double digits and are considered "so low" even in-verse of the isekai world
But because I'm a masochist I'm going read this again to see why this series has a rating higher than 7 (currently 8.08) to see if it actually does get better later on or if this isekai is better trash to read compared to others. Also really hoping for interesting or actually good ways that author will prove why the apparent "joke/trash class" should be considered the "strongest" (but god I hope it doesn't go to the loli naofumi route of throwing BS to say why its op)
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Mar 30, 2023
- Messages
- 1,174
MC isn't op because of his heavy knight class, but because of how heavy his plot armor is (idc if someone said this joke already I will still say it)
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Mar 30, 2023
- Messages
- 1,174
Finished reading volume 2 and man everything up to near the end of second volume most of the writing is just flat out bad and there's even some retconning and reconning the retcons too. But at least near the end of volume 2 some level of danger finally appears
Edit: forgot to mention that the skill descriptions are also so poorly written they're hard to understand unless you see how that are used or if they are flat out explained by the characters themselves, which should've been what the skill descriptions are in the first place. There's also the fact that skills honestly act more like a plot convince in giving what the MC want's now to make things easier for him. Example would be a skill that's like a damage reflection as being the first skill on a skill tree and shield bash being the forth skill after a damage reflection skill, literally shoving someone with a shield as a skill is harder to get than a damage reflection. Not to mention for a class focused on defense the very same skill tree as a 20% attack reduction skill that stacks named disarm (which the effects last for 1 minute but that effect time is super long in terms of actual combat) as it's second skill and a parry that says in it's description forces the enemy to become open to be attacked, meaning MC should literally never struggle against enemies since he can just spam parry and disarm about 10 times and the enemy would literally never hurt him. Mind you, those skills are from a defense-oriented class and MC has been shown to spam them in a fight before the writers started trying to soft retconning it by having MC not spam it. Another terribly written thing about skills and skill trees is that your skill tree is literally locked behind your adventure rank which is super dumb and that when MC was talking about how to get skills he mentions that you can get skills base on your class skill tree and 2 "random" (because you can do that and why the lot makes those skill trees convent for him and his party members) but then later there's as ass pull of skill books existing and you can even combined other class skills to your own which is why MC is apparently the only one who knows you can do it and not like anyone has every tried combining an offensive skill with a defensive class to make the "strongest class", nope only MC and MC alone has tried it. But the worse part about ass pulling skills is that MC also gets another broken skill from an ass pull after beating after beating the boss in a raid (although he didn't exactly beat it, some other guy one shotted the boss, the story literally has everyone saying he beated the boss by himself) and that broken skill just so happens to be a stun skill with works just like Shadow Possessions Jutsu, and it was from the raid boss who never once used any other skills apart from healing from eating corpses and creating minions from corpses and it was never stated it could be possible to gain skills from beating enemies until the plot wanted MC to have a broken stun skill. There's also the retarded level of thinking everyone has in the mangas world, be it pre isekai (aka the "real world") or in the isekai world is that defense-oriented classes are very looked down upon and a girl with a skill to increase luck but 500% is considered worthless, MC even offhandedly mention "oh she has high luck stats" even though there is no other stats than hp and mp shown and in the status windows and it's even shown like 2 chapters later that if your "lucky" enough you can even get duplicates drops, so when MC goes farming for a mob that drops an item worth 17 million gold with a drop rate of 50% and that 500% luck makes it so that they grunted always gets it, but immediately retcons the duplication drops that happened 3 chapters ago. I should also add in the fact that the number stats for hp and mp and levels and such are super terribly written, like an evolved boss monster (which was the raid boss mention earlier) at level 40 only had an hp of 97 and going back to what I said before the guy who was able to one shot this boss was also the same level as the boss, level 40.
Edit: forgot to mention that the skill descriptions are also so poorly written they're hard to understand unless you see how that are used or if they are flat out explained by the characters themselves, which should've been what the skill descriptions are in the first place. There's also the fact that skills honestly act more like a plot convince in giving what the MC want's now to make things easier for him. Example would be a skill that's like a damage reflection as being the first skill on a skill tree and shield bash being the forth skill after a damage reflection skill, literally shoving someone with a shield as a skill is harder to get than a damage reflection. Not to mention for a class focused on defense the very same skill tree as a 20% attack reduction skill that stacks named disarm (which the effects last for 1 minute but that effect time is super long in terms of actual combat) as it's second skill and a parry that says in it's description forces the enemy to become open to be attacked, meaning MC should literally never struggle against enemies since he can just spam parry and disarm about 10 times and the enemy would literally never hurt him. Mind you, those skills are from a defense-oriented class and MC has been shown to spam them in a fight before the writers started trying to soft retconning it by having MC not spam it. Another terribly written thing about skills and skill trees is that your skill tree is literally locked behind your adventure rank which is super dumb and that when MC was talking about how to get skills he mentions that you can get skills base on your class skill tree and 2 "random" (because you can do that and why the lot makes those skill trees convent for him and his party members) but then later there's as ass pull of skill books existing and you can even combined other class skills to your own which is why MC is apparently the only one who knows you can do it and not like anyone has every tried combining an offensive skill with a defensive class to make the "strongest class", nope only MC and MC alone has tried it. But the worse part about ass pulling skills is that MC also gets another broken skill from an ass pull after beating after beating the boss in a raid (although he didn't exactly beat it, some other guy one shotted the boss, the story literally has everyone saying he beated the boss by himself) and that broken skill just so happens to be a stun skill with works just like Shadow Possessions Jutsu, and it was from the raid boss who never once used any other skills apart from healing from eating corpses and creating minions from corpses and it was never stated it could be possible to gain skills from beating enemies until the plot wanted MC to have a broken stun skill. There's also the retarded level of thinking everyone has in the mangas world, be it pre isekai (aka the "real world") or in the isekai world is that defense-oriented classes are very looked down upon and a girl with a skill to increase luck but 500% is considered worthless, MC even offhandedly mention "oh she has high luck stats" even though there is no other stats than hp and mp shown and in the status windows and it's even shown like 2 chapters later that if your "lucky" enough you can even get duplicates drops, so when MC goes farming for a mob that drops an item worth 17 million gold with a drop rate of 50% and that 500% luck makes it so that they grunted always gets it, but immediately retcons the duplication drops that happened 3 chapters ago. I should also add in the fact that the number stats for hp and mp and levels and such are super terribly written, like an evolved boss monster (which was the raid boss mention earlier) at level 40 only had an hp of 97 and going back to what I said before the guy who was able to one shot this boss was also the same level as the boss, level 40.
Last edited:
Similar threads
