Uketsukejou ni Kokuhaku Shitakute Guild ni Kayoitsumetara Eiyuu ni Natteta - Vol. 7 Ch. 33

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 27, 2020
Messages
776
The whole Dorami's mom arc was useless. It could have been anyone there giving them info on Onyx, and we would have been spared the stupid excuses for abandoning Dorami in some random place (Why then btw? They clearly were fine for years, and she was undiscovered to this day, so couldn't she wait until Dorami was old enough to be independant?), and not reuniting with her even though she could live as a human like she wants, in a country where she wouldn't have to hide.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 12, 2018
Messages
238
That's not true at all... The copyright holder can subpoena Mangadex to reveal information on the user that infringed on the copyright. Which then, the copyright holder can either send the user a cease and desist or take that individual to court depending on their country and copyright laws.

The chances of this are extremely low, especially if you're a small uploader, but not exactly 0. But if the copyright holder is petty enough and has enough $$, anything's possible.
#1 unless dex is actually rolling over for these people (it's doing the bare minimum of removing the chapters it needs to) no they can't not without fighting an uphill battle even if they are "in the right" requests for information like that almost never go through on the user level.

#2 even if it did such information is easily hidden at the user level as another comment mentioned burner Email.


#3 please do basic googling before you try to correct someone.
The whole Dorami's mom arc was useless. It could have been anyone there giving them info on Onyx, and we would have been spared the stupid excuses for abandoning Dorami in some random place (Why then btw? They clearly were fine for years, and she was undiscovered to this day, so couldn't she wait until Dorami was old enough to be independant?), and not reuniting with her even though she could live as a human like she wants, in a country where she wouldn't have to hide.
Dragons are not human. your judging them based off human expectations.

there are plenty of animals that ditch their offspring young (turtles being the big one everyone knows) and the manga pretty clearly shows that no one agrees with her decision even if they respect her wishes.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 17, 2024
Messages
466
Why is a dragon adoptive daughter's dragon form completely abandoned?
Manga itself ended at chapter 40. After defending a friend from a winged bear, a dragon never changed back since then.
Seriously - stop using human form as the way tl get rid of dragon forms.
 
Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2019
Messages
8
#1 unless dex is actually rolling over for these people (it's doing the bare minimum of removing the chapters it needs to) no they can't not without fighting an uphill battle even if they are "in the right" requests for information like that almost never go through on the user level.

#2 even if it did such information is easily hidden at the user level as another comment mentioned burner Email.


#3 please do basic googling before you try to correct someone.

"they can't not without fighting an uphill battle even if they are "in the right" requests for information like that almost never go through on the user level."

Bud just admitted there is the possibility of it actually escalating to that point, which was the point of my original comment by the way, but is telling me to do more research......... But hey, at least you got the point of my original comment, Good job.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 16, 2020
Messages
1,325
"But what if she eventually learns that I knew your identity and withheld that from her, then she comes to resent me for it?"

"...sucks to be you?"

I get the sentiment behind it, but the complete lack of consideration for her feelings is kind of gross.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 12, 2018
Messages
238
"they can't not without fighting an uphill battle even if they are "in the right" requests for information like that almost never go through on the user level."

Bud just admitted there is the possibility of it actually escalating to that point, which was the point of my original comment by the way, but is telling me to do more research......... But hey, at least you got the point of my original comment, Good job.
no an uphill battle as in they have to go through THREE Legal Systems to even start a lawsuit their own (easy) one wherever Mangadex Hosts their shit (medium) and where the user is (Hard)

Such a fucking clown you are grasping at a victory that never existed as if how things work can be changed if you scream "i win" loud enough

Do basic googling it is not hard.
 
Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2019
Messages
8
no an uphill battle as in they have to go through THREE Legal Systems to even start a lawsuit their own (easy) one wherever Mangadex Hosts their shit (medium) and where the user is (Hard)

Such a fucking clown you are grasping at a victory that never existed as if how things work can be changed if you scream "i win" loud enough

Do basic googling it is not hard.

It's exactly why I said "The chances of this are extremely low, especially if you're a small uploader, but not exactly 0. But if the copyright holder is petty enough and has enough $$, anything's possible."

The fundamental argument of my original comment, is that no matter how small, there is the POSSIBILITY of it happening. You've commented twice now that supports that arguement. No matter how many hurdles the copyright holder has to go through, no matter how many legal systems they have to work against. The possibility of facing legal repercussions is not 0, otherwise you wouldn't have stated it's an uphill battle, nor even list out how many legal systems they have to jump through. You'd simply say "It's impossible." Now, if you want to continue this pathetic attempt attempt at having the last word in, I'm all here for clowning you. Or you can just be a good boy and take the L.

Edit: Come on Mods, this was such a good comback, don't ban the comment.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
1,235
I don't think it's a good idea to promise she'll see her father again.

Even if he went to hunt the medusa, even if he got petrified... lots of things can happen in ten years. His statue might be broken.
 
Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2019
Messages
8
no an uphill battle as in they have to go through THREE Legal Systems to even start a lawsuit their own (easy) one wherever Mangadex Hosts their shit (medium) and where the user is (Hard)

Such a fucking clown you are grasping at a victory that never existed as if how things work can be changed if you scream "i win" loud enough

Do basic googling it is not hard.
Since my original comment won't go through, I'll just go with this.

Nice of you to double down on the main argument of my original comment, Good job bud.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top