Under the Oak Tree

cnd

Joined
Mar 12, 2019
Messages
327
Oh. So they did have sex before he left. I'm uncomfortable with how he keeps saying that he won't stop even if she says no.
 
Joined
Mar 30, 2019
Messages
218
The woman is basically a slave and she should be happy her husband is kind. Don't you see any problem with this?!
 
Joined
Aug 31, 2019
Messages
82
I’m glad this is actually faithful to the novel. Lucia got Disney’d

Also Riftan is sexy af
 
Joined
Jul 16, 2019
Messages
6
😏Just a passing thought. 💭

Is the ML's name RIFTAN because he's RIPPED and TAN? 🤔 RIPPEDTAN 😉😋🤤

I see what you did there Author. 😏😂
 
Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2019
Messages
42
this is 100% not targeted towards me and i fully accept that. This is mainly targeted to women who like men. But lemme give u some lesbian commentary on this anyways!

-I think i’m here just to see them sort out their misunderstanding and see the grand duke f*cked up. not a big fan of the sex but thats what you’re probably here for so have fun. if anything this probably made me gayer 😆

-Why the hell does she cry every second? This is a thing in so many manhwa/manga but girl cries whenever she gets kissed or hugged or f*cked or anything. If my gf cried whenever i was intimate I’d be more scared and worried than turned on

-Big muscle men scare me. I do like the cussing but the big muscles irl would scare the shit out of me. That reflects more on me and possibly my distaste for men bc I think women with muscles are goddesses. But yeah no irl i’d never wanna be anywhere alone or sit next to a bodybuilder-type muscle guy its scary.

i say 7/10 cause the misunderstanding is kinda dumb. have fun with it if u want!
 
Joined
Apr 12, 2020
Messages
220
@sweaterhoe I'm hetero, but I do agree with you on this (heck I like all forms of romantic relationships as long as there's character development and consent) The only reason why I can accept her whiny nature is
due to her abusive father and the general abuse she endured as a child with a speech defect. Low self-esteem can cause SERIOUS damage to a person's mind, so let's hope she overcomes her complex.
The muscle guy is kinda cute but the dude needs to work on his vocabulary coz "sh*t!" and "f*uck!" are literally in every other sentence. 😂😂😂
I don't mind muscles but I DO MIND the lack of eloquence.
And when you said girls with muscles... I totally imagined the yuri version of this, and holy pasta sauce, I'd take it any day. 👍✨
 
Joined
Oct 30, 2019
Messages
27
As husband and wife, I just hope they both gain confidence in themselves and be more open to communicating. This iz different from the usual I got reincarnated/ Time took me back to change everything sht and I'm loving it.
 
Joined
May 20, 2019
Messages
11
This tagged as smut, but where is it??? I didn't read the novel and i'm sure there is a detailed sex .
This reminds me of Lucia and i was disappointed at the sex scenes ... but the art is good.
 
Joined
Jul 9, 2019
Messages
29
Wth Lucia is good! Stop being horny and go to lezhin if you want actual porn :/
 
Contributor
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
3,632
Got faithfully period-piece stuff going on here (fantasy setting notwithstanding) with a good dose of ye olde morals and accordingly... painful-to-watch relationship bits.

With thankfully a few anachronistic tidbits thrown in (like he does at least sort of seek consent... which doesn't match the tone of some of his other lines and actions at all, but I'll happily take the nod to modern sensibilities there, else this would just be completely unpalatable)

But at least the general trend seems to be meandering uphill in mood, and even if it's painful to read, the relationship dynamics are certainly interesting. I can't accuse it of being badly written at this time.

@sweaterhoe:

Honestly, I find him kind of terrifying regardless... and I'm bi, and have nothing particularly against muscles, even if I'm not a fan as such. I'd assumed he's supposed to be coarse to the point of being alarming (though I suppose that might be a bonus for some people, but the extent to which he's—to put it charitably—not always in touch with his touchy-feely side, has seemed to me to be part of the central conundrum of this low-consent, somewhat dark, medieval-ish romance plot). Like, either way their relationship is completely toxic by today's standards. I mean, she's crying because she's terrified and in pain...? This is really not a good advertisement for straight... nor, any kind of relationships IMO XD (I say as if straight relationships need advertising)
 
Joined
Jul 16, 2020
Messages
2
The story of a horny knight who gets riled up everytime he sees his wife. Of course actually there is more to the story in the later chapters especially the lore about Oak Tree. But at the first few chapters there will be relentless banging (poor max) because riftan is so lonely after being separated in 3 years. Oh, the novel is more hot though, very detailed scenes
 
Joined
Nov 30, 2019
Messages
35
@the_crimson_moon wordexcerpt had the translated novel, but last week they took down all their korean translated novels, because apparently the publishers contacted them and now wordexcerpt is having licensing talks with them. Who knows when the novels will be back
 
Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2019
Messages
42
@Pokari this is the stuff that has me questioning whether or not the straights are ok 😆. theres someone out there this makes happy so i guess the author is hitting their targeted demographic
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top