@boorishtiger This could be just as bad for her as it would be if she picked any of the wrong choices so far, at any moment when she has free reign over it, though. She barely knows any of these people past having interacted with them a little bit via using a three choice conversation system. At least with the choices, she could fairly easily guess which ones were outright terrible to use. She even reflected on how dumb it was picking one of them before when it was just a game.
Yes, this gives her more freedom to behave in ways that would benefit her... but it also gives her more opportunity to screw up. It's probably meant to be a high risk, high return sort of deal here.