Theres "lol anime tourists" then theres "hang on, what sense does that make?" Mangaka arent faultless paragons of story telling m'dude. Unless you're one of those weirdos who thinks we arent allowed to critique things.
Of course Authors/Mangaka/Whoever made the plot ain't faultless paragons. There certainly are creators that I have vehement disagreements with personally. For example, MHA's Bakugo su*cide baiting and basically having it white washed later on because of how they wanted the story to go. Or Rental Girlfriend. That series... just icks me even as a girl.
There are also works that I pick up, realize it ain't my cup of tea, and just quietly drop it and look for one that is more my taste/speed.
Are they free to critique them? Of course they are. However, such things are better done through somewhere the creator would have a chance of seeing it. Some discussion board in a manga piracy site ain't such a venue where they'll see it tho.
Also, I am perceiving a sense of disassociation with some of the people who express their stuff here to the medium as a whole.
This is a media where you have ridiculous things exist without fanfare and is to be considered "expected" or "normal". 800 year old vampires who have a child's body, teens that have a better body than adult super models, the denseness of a blackhole when it comes to romantic things being expressed through a MC....
Don't even get me started on Horse Girls, Giant Mechas, Child Detectives, Reincarnating in another world where you acquire cheat-like abilities nilly willy, Cyberpunk dystopias where there is no "black and white" but just shades of grey and trying to keep those close to you safe....
A media where anything and everything is possible... and they are hanged up on how children doesn't look like children.
So I'm in either the mind of people really making a mountain out of a mole hill... or they're tourists.
I guess it doesn't really matter at the end? I could just ignore them. I most likely should just ignore them tbh. I myself most likely are making a mountain out of a mole hill on this thing.
So I'm a hypocrite. I'll work on that.
A lot more than I can say for others, but what can you do?
I should thank you tho. Made me realize that I am being a bit of a hypocrite myself on it. I'll just move on with it.
Thank you!