I'll rate any song posted in this thread*

Group Leader
Joined
Aug 19, 2018
Messages
53
The only things I know about Hibike Euphonium is that it involves music and it has been staying somewhere in my backlog for years. So I pretty much don't know anything about the characters. The art is good, the action is pretty sexy, but I can't connect with the emotional moments because I don't know who they are or what their deal is
 
Mangodex Derailer Wheezer
Group Leader
Joined
Jul 15, 2019
Messages
13,476
The only things I know about Hibike Euphonium is that it involves music and it has been staying somewhere in my backlog for years. So I pretty much don't know anything about the characters. The art is good, the action is pretty sexy, but I can't connect with the emotional moments because I don't know who they are or what their deal is
You should watch the spin off then. Liz and the Blue Bird.

and tbh with you, the novel is much more endearing.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 17, 2025
Messages
197
CMNsYd5.png
CMNsYd5.png

6.8/10, it's charming. and did you say UMAMUSUME?!
YeRC619.png
(out of all three, i think i prefer the cute anime girl one the most)
:wooow:
Anw, I actually want to drop this interesting comparison video while reads your reply but I forgot it due to some IRL things and just remember it now. Enjoy~
 
Knight of Dex
Contributor
Joined
Mar 6, 2019
Messages
6,520
The only things I know about Hibike Euphonium is that it involves music and it has been staying somewhere in my backlog for years. So I pretty much don't know anything about the characters. The art is good, the action is pretty sexy, but I can't connect with the emotional moments because I don't know who they are or what their deal is
Ignore our regulars, the best about Hibike! Euphonium is reading fan manga and checking fan art without context.
Lyy 65.jpg
 
Dex-chan HATER
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Messages
16,852
There is 12 Neuro covers on leaderboard right now, and 2 waiting to be on leaderboard. Even after i complete posting all 32, total will be 48. Neuro songs will at most take %7 percent of entire list
I should have negotiated for more songs, at least for %8 or %9.
bro, 48 songs from the same AI voice model is more than enough. although i did not create any contingencies for a scenario like this when i initially started the thread, i think anyone can reason the same. i do appreciate the opportunity to deal with edge cases like this, however, as it makes it more interesting for myself (and maybe others)

crazy that this is only the second Pillows song to be submitted. though i wouldn't consider it one of my favorites, it's definitely one of their standouts. 8.1/10

oh hey, it's the girl who sang the wonderful OP for City the Animation. i hope she becomes a new mainstay in anime music. 7.2/10
 
Dex-chan HATER
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Messages
16,852
Don't lose, Aru!
dude this shit sucks. 5.6/10

Wa ha HA!
really? this is as 'gimmick ED' as gimmick ED gets. would i be amused if i was watching this anime and this ED suddenly appeared? sure, i guess. but who would ever listen to this as a standalone .mp3. or .flac, for that matter? it lacks basically everything that makes a song a song. (it still is kind of fun tho.) 4.7/10
 
Dex-chan HATER
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Messages
16,852
Been listening to this song a lot ❤️
oh have you? you've been "listening to this song a lot ❤️"? well i'll be the judge of that.

...

...okay, i'll accept it. 8.3/10

and as a side note, i have absolutely no recollection of the initial profile post where i invited you to this thread as i was completely drunk at that time, though i saw the post afterwards.
 
Banana Bred
Contributor
Joined
Nov 18, 2018
Messages
26,307
dude this shit sucks. 5.6/10


really? this is as 'gimmick ED' as gimmick ED gets. would i be amused if i was watching this anime and this ED suddenly appeared? sure, i guess. but who would ever listen to this as a standalone .mp3. or .flac, for that matter? it lacks basically everything that makes a song a song. (it still is kind of fun tho.) 4.7/10
Congratulations, I'm platinum MAD now.
ITSneqa.png

Gugure! Kokkuri-san chapter 46
 
Dex-chan HATER
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Messages
16,852
I was making a character sheet out of your digital footprint in my mind and this random comment hurt my analysis.
Granted turkish song was more of a probe, but i expected more from this Camelia cover.

I'll guess you had a bad day and it affected your rating, or that you just don't like girl breakup songs. Since up to now you seemed to like identifiable melody, memorable vocal line, chord progression and groove.
You generally liked bittersweet melodrama songs, was this not also a bittersweet melodrama song, I guess not. Well girl breakup songs are out of my suggestion list for now. (goodbye Taylor Swift songs)
did you consider that rather than me having a bad day, i was actually having a good day, and the Camelia cover by Neuro made it a bad day? the vocals are flat, the score is underwhelming, and the lyrics are... well, those are actually alright.

also there are actually plenty of Taylor songs which i would rate relatively highly (though i can't speak to any albums beyond Lover as i haven't listened to her newer stuff)

also i'd be interested in seeing that character sheet someday

And unrelated to these suggestions, you also liked songs from before 2000s. Specifically 60s-80s and seemed to rate songs you have heard before higher, and you also listen to albums so while i can fetch songs from same albums of songs you have rated high, unfortunately you don't seem to worship groups or singers so i don't expect this tactic to yield much points. Oh well points are only worth it if they are hard to get, (and i continue being unemployed)
i do in fact generally listen to songs rather than artists. however, the few artists who i've listened to their entire discographies (that i can list off the top of my head):
Hall & Oates
ABBA
U2
The Killers

there are plenty more artists which i've listened to their 'most popular' tracks, but there are only a few who i've gone through their entire discographies just to see if there were more songs that i'd like.
 
Forum Oji-san
Contributor
Joined
Apr 26, 2020
Messages
11,174
We haven't had any Bill Withers in this thread... until now.


Go ahead and time how long he holds that note on the third chorus. We'll wait.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top