Akumade Taidana Akuyaku Kizoku

Active member
Joined
Jul 26, 2019
Messages
23
I'll be watching this one, but I have to complain about something: having something move your body around while you're unconscious wouldn't work as exercise. Exercise works to reduce body weight by burning calories via chemical work—however, if you're not moving your body with your muscles you're not doing any chemical work. Similarly, Luke won't get any stronger this way, as strength gains are due to putting strain on your muscle cells, which causes damage to some of them, requiring that they get replaced; continuous cycles of damage and replacement will signal to the body that it needs to reinforce the area to handle the presumed upcoming strain. Because Luke isn't putting strain on his muscles and is instead being moved around by an external force, his muscles won't get any stronger.

Tl;dr it sucks but you can't cheat biomechanics, not even with magic that does the work for you.
 
Joined
Feb 11, 2021
Messages
1
I'll be watching this one, but I have to complain about something: having something move your body around while you're unconscious wouldn't work as exercise. Exercise works to reduce body weight by burning calories via chemical work—however, if you're not moving your body with your muscles you're not doing any chemical work. Similarly, Luke won't get any stronger this way, as strength gains are due to putting strain on your muscle cells, which causes damage to some of them, requiring that they get replaced; continuous cycles of damage and replacement will signal to the body that it needs to reinforce the area to handle the presumed upcoming strain. Because Luke isn't putting strain on his muscles and is instead being moved around by an external force, his muscles won't get any stronger.

Tl;dr it sucks but you can't cheat biomechanics, not even with magic that does the work for you.
You make a good point but it does mention he gets muscle aches which can only happen if the body is put under strain, aside from handwaving it as magic it might be more like the magic uses the CNS to move the body or it flows thru the body like veins do and can have influence over the muscles since it also said it can reinforce muscles to be able to lift more it’s not a stretch to assume it can have its own influence over muscle movement
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 29, 2020
Messages
3,911
I think it was really interesting but it's another Harem+ Polygamy romance. Why can't we have more normal stuff? :angery::angery:
 
Active member
Joined
Jul 26, 2019
Messages
23
(Nevermind, it's not worth engaging thought over this, the author can just handwave anything related to how a guy can sleep while exercising by saying "it's magic, I don't have to explain shit".)
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 13, 2023
Messages
110
The artwork is pretty—I just want to hug the MC. But the reviews for the novel are very off-putting.
 
Active member
Joined
Sep 10, 2024
Messages
19
I like the protag so far. He's not all "oh no, I've been reincarnated as a character who was a piece of shit and died! I better freak out constantly and try to avoid EVERYONE for fear of death!"

Nah, he's just "well if I don't do bad things, I won't be a bad guy". God it's so refreshing.
 
Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2020
Messages
73
The artwork is pretty—I just want to hug the MC. But the reviews for the novel are very off-putting.
I was thinking something bad would happen in the story but it's just the usual shenanigans of this kind of story, like harem, lazy mc, randoms gushing over him, 7 deadly sins....

The most offputing thing tho, maybe? the novel has the incest tag too
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top