Akuninzura Shita B-kyuu Boukensha - Shujinkou to Sono Osananajimi-tachi no Papa ni Naru

[Speederzdk]

I am sorry but please do clarify which website are you referring to? Which website are you using to read the Novel? There's simply no way, a Japanese author drops into a western website comment section to interact with westerners and listen to their opinion. You are describing science fiction right now. At best authors interact with their fanbases on X and only when fans go out of their way to post stuff in Japanese. Surely you are misinterpreting or misunderstanding something.

I’m a bit unsure how you’re completely missing what that person wrote. He didn’t say anything about western websites nor western opinions. He, in fact, was speaking about specifically JP reactions…? Where are you getting him saying otherwise from?
He mentions a WN site in his first comment, which sure, it’s not the official site of the novel, it is also not the site he said the JP comments he read were from. If anything, the first comment and the reply to your message doesn’t seem overly connected in that way at all. Hence why I’m a bit unsure why you think the JP comments couldn’t be from the official channels.

 

[Iamcheater]

I’m a bit unsure how you’re completely missing what that person wrote. He didn’t say anything about western websites nor western opinions. He, in fact, was speaking about specifically JP reactions…? Where are you getting him saying otherwise from?
He mentions a WN site in his first comment, which sure, it’s not the official site of the novel, it is also not the site he said the JP comments he read were from. If anything, the first comment and the reply to your message doesn’t seem overly connected in that way at all. Hence why I’m a bit unsure why you think the JP comments couldn’t be from the official channels.

Okay 3 things:
A) when somebody posts a website where the material we are discussing are posted and translated and then he proceeds talking about how the comments were not favourable etc, why would you not assume he's talking about the website he originally posted?
B) If he was specifically talking about Japanese comments from the official website for the franchise or X, then why wouldn't he explicitly mention his source?
C) um you do realise this is like a year ago right? The guy didn't bother replying to debunk any of assumptions or answer my questions. Why bother defend him now? Lol,

 

[punkxgeek]

Love it so far, but one thing the story is based off a game in the guys old world, all I'm gonna say is WTF is up with that game scenario damn it's messed up ass game lol

 

[ConstantErasing]

So it's good but...how is this rated over a 9? Compared to the average isekai/LN adaptation trash, maybe, but for the most part it's pretty standard stuff. Guy adopts kids who instantly love him and he turns into an over the top doting parent, a black and white morality where the antagonists are cartoonishly evil so the MC can just kill them in droves while sidestepping any notion of mercy or compassion, generic world, characters that are fine but yet to have any great depth to them, pretty standard plot with nothing notable to write home about.....it's really nothing special. It's too well executed to be written off as generic slop, but as is this doesn't feel like it deserves more than an 8.