If author pulled the One Piece card and basically suggested that you don't think about the powers too much, I certainly wouldn't.
But he's pulling the smart MC card and is at least capable of making me want to put a little thought into it. The problem then lies in the fact that I may think of some things that the author couldn't or forgot to put in, which ends up being disappointing to me no matter how I look at it.
It's tough to write smart characters since actually considering all the significant details is difficult, but I do like the fact that he is trying/succeeding moderately.