Bokura no Kiseki

[Aoixneko]

How I wish to see this to be an anime 💖 but sadly my wish never come true ... I do really love the story to the point every time new chapter I go to re-read it again I memorize it all in this point 😁 so now its this time for the re-read. 👌

 

[nameless_incognito]

edit: sorry wrong thread lol.

that's what I get for playing a tabmaster

 

[Nhadaly]

I tried reading this manga but it just seems like a mess, so many characters with 0 introduction for any of them and suddenly the manga wants me to care about them.

Each time i try and read it i am just unable to, its just messy, it doesnt feel coherent even though the concept of remembering a past life is my favorite with magic in the modern world and such.

I dont know what it is about the manga that just makes me unable to read it or enjoy it, its a jumbled mess? I dont know...

 

[feliciasneck]

this guy has so much chunyibo its not even funny

 

[Noone16mei]

I'm really confused about who is the real villian here?

 

[zabent]

This is a great manga with an interesting concept and good execution, decently written characters, a excellent mystery plot.

One big problem though, all the characters look really similar. Character design is kinda shit, there is a bit too much text, and its hard to distinguish characters except by name.

It becomes easier as chapters go by and the art gets better/you get used to the characters - for me it stopped being an issue around like chapter 20. But still, I think most of the criticism actually stem from this and you might find it annoying as well.

9/10 easily though. Good stuff

 

[Pringless]

This seems like an interesting concept, haven't read it yet will let you know my feedback when finished.

 

[Kuromahi7]

THanks for the update!

 

[osqmu]

pretty unique of the author to make it a mass-past-life-remembering thing lmao

9/10 if you ignore the art i guess

 

[Nm11]

I am wondering.. do we know how far we are in the story? Does the author mention it anywhere?

 

[osqmu]

wait what isn't this a monthly?
well thanks for the update anyways

 

[nanamka]

It is monthly. At last page of each chapter, there's info when new magazine issue is coming out (in Japan of course). It just happened that I decided to wait to read chapter 105 before releasing scanlated chapter 104 (I needed more context to be sure I provide you appropriate translation).
There is no info how long this story will be, but we obviously are getting more close to the end of it.

 

[elletequila]

But I ship Yuu/Glenn. What do you think? What do you expect?

 

[Ariachan7]

I've been following this manga since early chapters, and at some point, about 2 years ago, I kinda forgot about this and busy idolizing Johnny's idols, lol. When I finally back to manga world, I read a lot of recent isekai reincarnated manhwa. And wondering if there's a manga with character that reincarnated to the modern days, and this manga pop up in my head!
I remember the ML being so badass and this is kinda tricky manga that made me think and speculated so much. I don't really remember anyone's name except veronica and glen, haha. I'll re-read this from the start!

 

[O-Takuni]

Guys!! Bokura no Kiseki got nominated once again for Anime Japan's "Manga We Want to See Animated!". If you want to see it happen, be sure to cast a vote in https://www.aniran.jp/formmail/fms/da3726635
Link to the "Manga We Want to See Animated!" page https://www.anime-japan.jp/main/ajranking/
Bokura no Kiseki is number 82.

Voting's only until 28th Feb!
Btw, questions are the same as last time except that it looks different now, so this guide by nanami still works:
https://bokuranofandom.tumblr.com/post/190591604668/manga-we-want-to-see-animated-ranking-2020
or you could wing it with google translate.

 

[owomachine]

the characters looking the same is an issue because there's so many of them

 

[OrionKaelin]

I wasnt expecting much from the synopsis and the genderswap tag is always a gamble and very rarely used well in my experience, but this was much more engaging and enjoyable than I thought it would be!

 

[MangaMonger]

I had high hopes for this one, but it seems like it's just another josei which keeps things constantly up in the air, never resolving anything clearly or giving any protagonist clarity of purpose and corresponding calm. It feels like I'm being thrown into a purgatory where people are not allowed to be emotionally stable.

I've read plenty of emotionally/sentimentally driven stories, that's pretty much all classic shoujo/josei manga after all, but the ones I like best are the ones where things settle down and reached equilibrium periodically, organized into clear arcs. Unfortunately, not all mangaka take that approach.

 

[B10bot]

Unarguably the greatest josei/shoujo of all time (not that there's much competition) and probably top 10 out of all manga.

 

[KajurN]

Unarguably the greatest josei/shoujo of all time (not that there's much competition) and probably top 10 out of all manga.

No way. Taiyou no Ie, Dengeki Daisy, Meteor Metuselah, Cat Street, Ran to Haiiro no sekai, Machida-kun no sekai, even the emotionally charged Life i'd argue are way better overall, and that's just from the shoujo manga i've read which is mostly semi-recent stuff. Nevermind top 10 manga of all time this would struggle to be among the top 10 shoujo manga.