Chounin A wa Akuyaku Reijou wo Doushitemo Sukuitai

Joined
Oct 29, 2024
Messages
3
Dropped on chapter 33, the reaction he had to Amy's taunt was robot-like. Author should really put himself in the shoes of the character and ask himself if that was a realistic reaction of someone facing the person who may have killed his lover...
 
Last edited:
Joined
May 15, 2018
Messages
3
More often than not when I read these type of stories instead of enjoying bit for what it is, I come to dislike it for what it isn't. It could have been so much better!

The start, those first few pages when we are told that or protagonist and the country will suffer a bad end because of the game scenario, it suggest a story more gritty than what get, far removed from the usual such fake character powerbuilding.

But instead we are shown that the protagonist liked the villainess... Because of course he did.

I hate that crappy "virtuous villainess" trope.

How many such vilainesses have you actually come across in these supposedly real games/novels? Everyone I've seen the vilainness are rotten to the core. Sure, I hate them getting punished, but that is regardless of whether they are evil or not.

But these crappy villainess stories just flip the script. They do the same to the "heroine" that they claim are done to the villainess. Because the heroine in these stories ARE the vilainness... so how is this good?

In this story while not seeing the people as real, Amy isn't exactly wrong either. What the protagonist is doing is just as selfish as what she is doing. He is screwing her over for his own happiness. Sure some people would die, but in the end the victory of the kingdom was assured in these scenarios.

But the protagonist wants to avoid these scenarios, knowing fully well that this itself won't actually stop the enemy empire.

So he is gambling with everyones lives to save the ones he likes.

Forget about Amy not being the real Amy... If he and the fake Amy had not been there, Amy would have found those things. Think about it this way... You invent something that makes you rich and famous. Someone sees this and goes back into the past and then invents what you created before you can do it.

This is basically what the trash protag here is doing. The only difference here is that the author is the protagonists cheerleader and goes out of his way to vilify Amy's actions even though they aren't necessarily wrong.
 
Joined
May 15, 2018
Messages
3
The WN has, in my opinion, a pretty fucked up ending, which makes the whole thing gross and weird:

The MC and the female lead sell the female antagonist into slavery in a salt mine where she is graphically raped until she dies.
Yeah, because it is trash writing and the protagonist is pure trash.
 
Joined
May 15, 2018
Messages
3
Yes, but
she is the villain of the story, it's expected for her to be evil. What's not expected is for the supposed good guys to commit war crimes out of spite. If they had publically executed her for her crimes, that would have been acceptable, but what they did instead was downright monstrous. I really lost all sympathy I might've had for the main couple after that and it left me with a bitter taste in my mouth after I finished the novel.
Yeah, but this is a fetish. Authors that want to punish, humiliate and ruin the bad guys because it makes them feel good. Even imprisonment or execution is wrong IMHO because it is a forced scenario and because the people really aren't real.

Endings like this make me wish for Amy to get reincarnated again and then completely screw over the trash protagonist. He was selfish trash from the start.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 12, 2024
Messages
234
The WN has, in my opinion, a pretty fucked up ending, which makes the whole thing gross and weird:

The MC and the female lead sell the female antagonist into slavery in a salt mine where she is graphically raped until she dies.
The heroine made it clear to MC that she treats this as how a game would be and simply does not see other characters as human at all. And goes on to prove her point in the kidnapping arc and up to the last moment fighting MC.

As everyone would know by now, MC and Ana thought it might not be that bad for the heroine to have a taste of her own medicine :02:

Junk food? Absolutely. Unhealthy? You sure bet.

But eating junk food once in a while for enjoyment? Sure :02:
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 23, 2023
Messages
2,196
The heroine made it clear to MC that she treats this as how a game would be and simply does not see other characters as human at all. And goes on to prove her point in the kidnapping arc and up to the last moment fighting MC.

As everyone would know by now, MC and Ana thought it might not be that bad for the heroine to have a taste of her own medicine :02:

Junk food? Absolutely. Unhealthy? You sure bet.

But eating junk food once in a while for enjoyment? Sure :02:
It's not that I'm bothered by the writing being bad or morally questionable. I just personally find it disgusting and horrible to read about. I felt physically nauseated by it.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 12, 2024
Messages
234
It's not that I'm bothered by the writing being bad or morally questionable. I just personally find it disgusting and horrible to read about. I felt physically nauseated by it.
I understand. Not everyone has the stomach for it.

I looked up the WN again and would say the heroines fate being described in detail was on readers popular demand because it’s the first side story epilogue. The main story just glossed over with one sentence.
 
Joined
Nov 21, 2020
Messages
6
Yeah, but this is a fetish. Authors that want to punish, humiliate and ruin the bad guys because it makes them feel good. Even imprisonment or execution is wrong IMHO because it is a forced scenario and because the people really aren't real.

Endings like this make me wish for Amy to get reincarnated again and then completely screw over the trash protagonist. He was selfish trash from the start.
this is bs at it's core, she had plenty of opportunities to just stop being a bitch and live her shitty harem fantasy, but instead she persisted in trying to fuck the MC and his lover, i'm pretty satisfied that the author didn't make the cliché of "we forgive u, even tho u rotten", u guys are too comfortable with that shit.
 
Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2024
Messages
104
I always hate how every average Joe that gets isekai'ed always knows how to make a gun. I doubt that it is common knowledge in Japan. Not to mention, he learned swordsmanship only to use guns afterwards? It would be more believable if he learned to be a scout and went full thief class with his sneak skills.

Not only that, what's up with him suddenly being an aeronautical engineer? With how flippantly that fact was revealed, I won't be surprised if he is revealed to be Russian and not Japanese.
the whole being able to know how to make planes is par for the course in Isekais, because of some strange reason they know how to make anything and also have extreme love and knowledge of hot springs and Mayonnaise.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top