Creature Girls: A Hands-On Field Journal in Another World

[Monn12]

I gave this example because... is it closer to what we see in the manga? Maybe polyamory could also be taken as an example.

DIdn't understand what you were implying, after clarification i agree with you 100%. This stone age thinking (complete disregard who to mate with just to produce offspring) is indeed stone age polyamory. A true communism in sense (Even Taishi being the first among communist comrades where everyone should be equal has more rights than others).

All your further examples are excellent, but again they only confirm what I wrote. At this stage, there is a confrontation with nature/other kingdoms/villages in Taishi village.

Yup, we evolved with our biology taking in to account that men die more thus more men are born. Taishi is currently ruling a state where they are in crisis. But his dogma is as if current goblin way of life is everlasting not a temporary measure.
Completely agreed with this.
Also Taishi is indeed a hypocrite, that was when i started to strongly dislike him. Before that i was thinking that it was like ok, he is bad and flawed but stays true to their dogma, now? He basically outwardly lives by their dogma but otherwise lives like a greedy man who wants power and women all to himself.

 

[hidgepidge]

Way more loli than I was hoping for. Let's hope for more MILF and middle-aged encounters.

 

[hidgepidge]

Ch28: good lord, the mangaka needs a name dictionary. Rolled my eyes at the two names at the end.

 

[martinjasper]

https://mangafire.to/manga/creature-girls-a-hands-on-field-journal-in-another-worldd.80pxq

 

[Kikeemu]

My gripes with this thing:
1.- Author switched to use 3D only and hand draws a scarce amount of panels after I think chapter 30 or somewhere around that (Is really off-putting, like that one trashy anime where they tried using 2D for side characters and 3D for the main leads of the show [also with very trash animation])
2.- The whole political and ideological fubar on recent chapters make it feel like reading through a reddit post or 4chan forum.
3.- Taishi could have his own spin off manga to be honest; his chapters became pretty boring after the incident with the noble kid. (Such a shame too, really liked the whole foreshadowing with the demon lord shadow looming over him, it was a cool character design choice).

 

[AnimuVsMango]

We've had Ishuzoku Reviewers this whole time?

 

[kintoki9000]

Damn, I figure this series was gonna lit some fire and this comment section did not disappointed.

I see this series as a litmus test for cultural relativist. Easy to scream all cultures are equal until the you see the orc and goblin culture lol.

Author is autistics with world building. Always accurate? Probably not. But A+ for effort cause holy shit the wall text.

Saw someone said the feminism in here is a straw man. First, feminism is such a fracture concept at this point
Is it a straw man when it actually is real? Also, I hope no one take feminism at face value, right? People can always chant their righteousness, but when their actions doesn't line up with their chants, you should take their actions as the more accurate representation of their intention. Author is in Japan where the feminists are high on the crazy scale. The amount of time they stupidly complain about anime did them no favor.

 

[jetto_neko]

after reading 18 chapters of this, i can only say that this thing is weird but i can't stop myself from reading it. like i know it's bad. average at best, but it was such a unique experience i hadn't really got for quite a while

I agree. The science-like parts are really interesting, and suggest that the author has a deep background in biology. (His grasp of mechanics isn't as good)

The main character is alternately interesting and despicable, which is somewhat interesting and mostly works.

The author makes a few (very few) valid criticisms of modern and historical human society:
"I should treat everyone with respect and kindness." is NOT equal to "I am entitled to have everyone treat me with respect and kindness".
"Rape is bad but it does not justify a massacre."
"Women shouldn't pick a confident loser over a insecure competent mate."

But the whole thing falls apart when the preachy anti-feminist centaur girl shows up. This could be an interesting collision of wildly different cultures with totally different values regarding sex and relationships. But instead the other characters listen with implausible open-jawed amazement to the author's incel Andrew Tate philosophy as if it were coming from the mouth of God himself.

So it's like a ten and zero at the same time, so I'll give it a five.

 

[mrspiffy]

just like to say this is in english up to volume 11 on mangabuddy

Everywhere that hosts it is up to chptr 71 and those are scans of Seven Sea's stuff. Raws are up to 99, as of this posting date.

 

[Junklin0]

If you want to read it, it's on mangafire.to

 

[Monn12]

Saw someone said the feminism in here is a straw man.

Likely it was me.
My point was author was trying to destroy feminism with his faulty arguments while "feminism" in his work is a straw man.
Author doesn't point out real and deep problems that modern feminism has and on the other hand author doesn't do justice to the other side too.

Of course we can praise the author for trying to wrestle with the bull but it seems like author read the wiki and heard some tiktoks or youtube shorts as arguments and decided to wrestle with them.

Also feminism isn't a fracture subject if you think logically and have a normal sit down with both advocacy groups (who are really competent) + Neutral judges who will listen to every argument we might have a normal solid "feminism".

For example i heard that feminism groups oppose female drafting, obligatory DNA testing (in France it is even illegal without judges consent and they the decline most of the time) and male freedom to discard paternity. Not to mention they avoid subjects like income inequality (debunked and now young women earn more before they get pregnant).

It's already not a so called feminism that fights for equality, it's imbecilic movement for female supremacy which will crumble because people sense inequality even without logical reasoning. What those headless chickens don't understand that blowback might bring feminism back to middle ages if they don't stop their supremacy movement.
Quite literally we already have historical facts about matriarchal societies and why and how they were destroyed and we are heading towards that direction but unlike in previous cases (local and isolated cases) we are pulling whole continents with us.
It's an old tale about humanity's inability to maintain equilibrium and pushing the scales in one direction too far.

But i fear not that we might experience "Mouse utopia" rather than a restart. We already have the symptoms all around developed world. We have hungry old males, crazy females and "beautiful" males that do not engage in mating. Restart means humanity will not have a huge collapse, just a downgrade. Mouse utopia means a huge collapse that might take centuries to build up again with unknown rules, laws and variables.

 

[kintoki9000]

My point was author was trying to destroy feminism with his faulty arguments while "feminism" in his work is a straw man.
Author doesn't point out real and deep problems that modern feminism has and on the other hand author doesn't do justice to the other side too.

iirc, the author did included an afterword that directly address the complains about the centaur's culture. That afterword made a pretty good point about an assumption of Feminism that explain while they failing. Despite the slogan of female strength and power, a lot of what they supported were just rule 63 masculinity. They view feminity as weak, and masculinity is the source of power. That why all the "girlboss" displayed behaviors and personality of toxic masculinity, but with tits and cunts. Ultimately they just assholes trying to established their domination using a righteous crusade as shield. Same old human bullshit.

But i fear not that we might experience "Mouse utopia" rather than a restart. We already have the symptoms all around developed world. We have hungry old males, crazy females and "beautiful" males that do not engage in mating. Restart means humanity will not have a huge collapse, just a downgrade. Mouse utopia means a huge collapse that might take centuries to build up again with unknown rules, laws and variables.

"Mouse Utopia" is a proof of concept, but also heavily isolated and lack irl ecological factors. Doesn't mean everything from it is untrue and won't happen. Rather we are operating in a scale far surpass that of the model, and scale changes everything. I could see a few countries collapse like the experiment (looking at you South Korea), but human civ as a whole? We have the number to create a buffer of redundancy that might allow us to see the implosion coming and correct course. Either that or a gigantic population shrink follow by a restructured of the economy and government. Or Elon role out the Tesla sex bot, and we see Futurama prophecy come true. He got the software. He just need to buy Boston Dynamic and acquire the hardware.

 

[Monn12]

Or Elon role out the Tesla sex bot, and we see Futurama prophecy come true. He got the software. He just need to buy Boston Dynamic and acquire the hardware.

In all honesty this one is the one i hope for.
We have some countries (Germany as remember correctly 100%) researching artificial wombs (to artificial humanity).
+ Robo companions. That way we can control our population amount and replace people with robots doing jobs that require labor.
But the one i hope for is not the one i place my bets on.
Far more likely i believe that Islam will overtake Christianity and Sharia will become our new constitution and law book.
Europe, South K., Japan, China and maybe USA will be overshadowed. USA likely will be the last to fall due to influx of illegal and legal immigration which somehow sustains the illusion of growth.