Mage girl is definitely best girl, though wolf girl is doing her part in trying to train him. First girl improved a little and 2nd girl is still awful.
I put butt cheeks in S tier I don't know why but it's somehow looks attractive, I put Horny Horn girl in Jail because Horny, I put E(A)dolf as far away from German as possible, and the Dummy Thicc knight in A because she is a good girl.
Mage girl and wolf girl are the best. Here's hoping rapist is about to ask what she's doing wrong and the cliff hanger was just setup for a subversion.