Harapeko Oyako to Motokare Yanushi

[Phelgming]

I can understand where the people who support this is coming from, but that only makes sense if you ignore the elephant in the room. This isn’t really realistic, and it’s not being an incel for criticising.

I’m not even your typical virgin otaku with no irl experience. I’ve had a few relationships already. So when I think about it, “my gf disappears from my life and comes back later with another man’s child,” there’s no way I’d simply leave things unaddressed and not feel betrayed.

It’s disguised as wholesome, masked under, “human decency,” to help someone. Then why aren’t you taking in homeless people?
At most, even if you do help, a more plausible scenario is one where you are distant with her. Setting limits, boundaries, rent, etc.

I will only agree it can be wholesome if the issues are actually addressed instead of making the mc a beta cuck. Based on what the comments are saying.

I don't take homeless people in because I don't know them. (I've still fed them and clothed them and dedicated time to helping them, but maybe I'm just a decent human being.)

If someone I did know and had cared about in the past came to me asking for help, I'd help them. Wanting to help someone doesn't make you a "beta cuck". I also pretty distinctly remember him saying it would be temporary until they found somewhere else to live. God forbid giving shelter to a woman and a child and keeping them off the streets until they can get on their feet.

Is he paying their rent? Is he paying their mortgage? No. He's giving them room he already had available in his house. That's not very far to go.

Again, I didn't keep up with this manga, but I'm pretty sure she didn't murder his family and/or get deliberately and hatefully gangbanged by his archenemies in front of him or anything else that would give him a good reason to hate her or actively deny her shelter.

 

[Dzrian]

I don't take homeless people in because I don't know them. (I've still fed them and clothed them and dedicated time to helping them, but maybe I'm just a decent human being.)

If someone I did know and had cared about in the past came to me asking for help, I'd help them. Wanting to help someone doesn't make you a "beta cuck". I also pretty distinctly remember him saying it would be temporary until they found somewhere else to live. God forbid giving shelter to a woman and a child and keeping them off the streets until they can get on their feet.

Is he paying their rent? Is he paying their mortgage? No. He's giving them room he already had available in his house. That's not very far to go.

Again, I didn't keep up with this manga, but I'm pretty sure she didn't murder his family and/or get deliberately and hatefully gangbanged by his archenemies in front of him or anything else that would give him a good reason to hate her or actively deny her shelter.

If someone I did know and had cared about in the past came to me asking for help, I'd help them. Wanting to help someone doesn't make you a "beta cuck".

Wow, you really had to take out context, did you?
You’re dismissing the fact that his girl ghosted and came back with another person’s child with no explanation other than to be taken in.
She’s as good as a stranger.

As I’ve stated, this manga is disguised under wholesomeness. The elephant in the room is the part that has been omitted, the question, “what happened to her?”

He can take them in for all I care but if he does not want to question it, then he is indeed a beta cuck for simply accepting it.

Not to mention, even actual people with room to spare, may not give it to a relative in need. Depending on country, you’d need some legal things to go through. You add on the electricity and water bills. More things to be maintained and shared. Company that may be unwelcome at times. Etc.
I’m speaking from experience.

Don’t be naive. These types of mangas make it look wholesome, but with enough search, you’d find that in reality, similar situations did not end up in a wholesome manner.

 

[Dark1400]

Wow, you really had to take out context, did you?
You’re dismissing the fact that his girl ghosted and came back with another person’s child with no explanation other than to be taken in.
She’s as good as a stranger.

As I’ve stated, this manga is disguised under wholesomeness. The elephant in the room is the part that has been omitted, the question, “what happened to her?”

He can take them in for all I care but if he does not want to question it, then he is indeed a beta cuck for simply accepting it.

Not to mention, even actual people with room to spare, may not give it to a relative in need. Depending on country, you’d need some legal things to go through. You add on the electricity and water bills. More things to be maintained and shared. Company that may be unwelcome at times. Etc.
I’m speaking from experience.

Don’t be naive. These types of mangas make it look wholesome, but with enough search, you’d find that in reality, similar situations did not end up in a wholesome manner.

he isn't dismissing it, the "fact" is made up, she didn't ghost him, they broke up, there is nothing to suggest that she ghosted him, the lack of contact for 17 years was them growing apart after the break up, not "ghosting", and that is confirmed around chapter 13-15 when they show how they broke up she had to move because of family problems, so she told him she is going to drop college, and that they should break up since she was going to move away because of her family

 

[Dzrian]

he isn't dismissing it, the "fact" is made up, she didn't ghost him, they broke up, there is nothing to suggest that she ghosted him, the lack of contact for 17 years was them growing apart after the break up, not "ghosting", and that is confirmed around chapter 13-15 when they show how they broke up she had to move because of family problems, so she told him she is going to drop college, and that they should break up since she was going to move away because of her family

That’s better. I was expecting or hoping for something like this. I’ve been had. But welp these chapters weren’t here yet at the time of writing

 

[bondejeger]

Store exclusive specials for the first volume release.

 

[bondejeger]

Upscaled the store exclusives and added some.

 

[bondejeger]

 

[frey13]

for any one who think that what happens its ok because you should do as a human been, there's a sadly big amount of mother with child on shelters and on streets close to you, you can pick up all of that and let they stay on your place, then you can say that it's indeed normal

she didn't even has to ask for this, and she didn't even "ask" for pay rent or some bills, she didn't explain nothing, and that the minimum of the minimum that you should do when you ask for help, "she didn't want to talk about that" doesn't matter... she did no put a time no nothing, any person who can act like that it's a person that you should not believe, lest let enter on your house, or worst let stay at night... or worst let stay until she please, the ex gf thing, the child and everything else just make worse but any real adult just need to know how to say "no" to something like this, live it's not easy and you don't want to just make it worst

even if you're a saint and let someone enter on tour house like this, 1 week it's absolute the limit

been a adult it been accountable for your own actions and that goes for the man and for the woman

 

[Mangamoz]

For anyone curious, this is still getting translated in "other" sites I am not allowed to write here cause the mods will get mad, just google it.
In chap 16 they finally revealed That the original father died in an accident soon after the daughter was born, so no ex-husband drama is gonna happen, the MC can woo his ex without any worries.

 

[Rafalga]

For anyone curious, this is still getting translated in "other" sites I am not allowed to write here cause the mods will get mad, just google it.
In chap 16 they finally revealed That the original father died in an accident soon after the daughter was born, so no ex-husband drama is gonna happen, the MC can woo his ex without any worries.

That was such a milktoast reveal that i hope its a lie. What a nothing burger. It most certainly doesn't warrant this degree of "mystery". It's a case of bait and switch with yet another outrageous start of a series.

 

[DATLOLLIPOP]

Be a good beta cuck and take care of the woman that left you for no good reason only to come back 17 years later with a child from another man.

Dont listen to the people calling you a virgin. You should not have to put up with a womans mistake by taking care of another mans child.

I hope this story makes up for this by revealing its his child or something like that.

 

[Serverclosed]

holy trash woman taking advantage of a single man. wtf is the author trying to camouflage this as something wholesome and romantic?

 

[Dulganman]

Jesus christ on a stick.....the lack of humanity in this thread is baffling, then again most of you are angry males.
If I'd have to wager a guess, I'd say american.

Still, the most baffling thing is the fact none of you can disconnect from reality for a second, to read without any form of judgement or prejudice.

Aren't people reading manga to be entertained anymore?

Or is this place a gathering of redditors who's been exiled from their original habitats, sounding their anger to find likeminded sycophants?!

 

[KillerTyphoons]

For anyone curious, this is still getting translated in "other" sites I am not allowed to write here cause the mods will get mad, just google it.
In chap 16 they finally revealed That the original father died in an accident soon after the daughter was born, so no ex-husband drama is gonna happen, the MC can woo his ex without any worries.

Spoiler

Her father's death was actually before she was born, he's not even on the birth certificate.