Himari no Mawari - Vol. 3 Ch. 18 - Kei's Feelings

[sombralord]

As I said in the previous comment, Kei is a character without any sense, maybe she is not even a lesbian, the problem is that they gave her a terrible approach as someone is going to fall in love with a girl he met a few hours ago, because yes and also that forced feeling and ambiguous, and because he treats the brother as if he were an extra subject in his own house, he is supposed to be a childhood friend and sees him as if he were almost like his enemy, please the last author option to attract attention is to create fanservice yuri and his story would be a sub plot and I already think that at this moment he must already be receiving hatred at this moment for the decision he made in this manga

 

[Lilliwyt]

I read almost all of it and what can i say. Seem peoples are just mad it's not your typical romcoms about Onii-chan and her imouto with every girl being inhis harem and fighting for him.Seriously, yeah Kei is a bit rude and violent but how is that different from your typical Tsundere childhood friend ? The main difference is she is a lesbian and prefer the imouto. Onii-chan is not a bad character per se but he is just bland and not very interesting. He is just an asocial neet, and trust me than being one myself, i know that much how bland i am. Also I'm more surprise that nobody talk that much about how Aya is potentially also a lesbian in denial too. But i guess it had to do because most peoples seem to be homophobics as fuck,with all the "yurishit" and such in the comment. Seriously, if you don't like something then stop reading it. There is no point about reading something you hate. See, i don't like Harems romcoms so i don't read it.

 

[Moraza]

-Hits page 24-

Oh, are we not doing Discord shenanigans this time? That's 51% of the reason I read this.....

-Hits page 25-

I'm sorry for doubting you Daxar, one again you guys pull through.




Oh, and I guess the manga was okay..... still rooting for Himari to get both the brother and Kei, even though it's not gonna happen.

 

[justforthelulz]

 

[Exile]

@Lilliwyt, Kei have about every single trait that makes people hate the character. She is also overshadowing the story that is why people are getting annoyed.
Its not about Yuri, its about shitty Yuri drama that would be fine if this was a actual Yuri manga, it kinda reminds me of a series I read ages ago with a trap that it gone down hill the moment the author decided to bring a lesbian and suddenly Yuri drama that sucked all the fun of the series ... wanna write Yuri? fine ... however dont expect me to read it because Yuri stories are either fluffy were no men exist or overblown angst drama.

 

[Lilliwyt]

Its not about Yuri

its about shitty Yuri drama that would be fine if this was a actual Yuri manga,

So it is about Yuri in the end. Like i thought, peoples are just mad there is Yuri when they expected romcom. Yeah sorry, peoples can be gay too, sorry that not all girls will fawn over Male MC even if he is bland and not intersting. For the record i did read all the chapters and honestly ? Yeah Kei can be a bit violent towards Male MC and honestly, i hate the "i'm lesbian so i hate mens" trope, that's the only thing i hate about Kei's character. It give a bad light to lesbians characters. And to be honest, at least Kei give attention to the sister, unlike the brother who doesn't seem to care at all about what she do. Kei have more depth than Male MC, he could be a mob that it would have been the same story. For once i'm grateful that what seem to be a romcom story isn't a romcom story but it seem it's what trigger people. They wanted "Oh no Onii-chan we can't, we're siblings". Just quit it, it's been 18 chapters by now and the focus has been primarily on the yuri side, stop with your complaints and stop reading if you don't like it. Can't believe after 18 chapters of mostly yuri, peoples are still complaining about it in comments, it's just annoying. We get it, you wanted Onii-chan on imouto shenanigans, just search it for a bit, it's not probably that hard to found another.

 

[cor3zone]

Fuck this shit.

 

[sombralord]

Lilliwyt

I think Kei is a very badly structured character that a human being can fall in love with someone just by knowing him for a few hours (chapter 4 for example) and the one who says that this is not a romcom has not read what he says in the Description of the volumes on the author's page is focused on that theme and of course the heroine is Himari, not that he is a yuri, in the case of Kei, to be a childhood friend, he does not approach anything and specifies that he knows the brother Since they were little, an abuser who uses an old friendship as a means of oppression has been more similar to boku no hero kacchan, but the only difference that Kei developed a desire for possession in front of Himari and sees him more as an extra subject, which I detest, you believe that the author does not know that he made a mistake in structuring Kei, with a single poorly designed character he can damage a manga and I assure you that in the next chapters there will only be two options for the author

1. fix Kei and modify the personality, she could be a tsundere (not a misandric) she could have feelings for Himari but as a younger sister not as a lover, and to solve the relationship with her brother she may develop feelings of brotherly love, and the brother should also improve his personality as being more attentive and also have the character to talk to Kei so that he stops being a possessive impulsive

2. This option is to leave things as they are and create an atmosphere where the focus is only on girls' love relationships, but from the start it would not work since it would isolate many characters such as the president and brother, making it become a generic yuri to the At first it attracts attention but in the end it will not last many chapters since that method of forced yuri manga does not work, even the most successful yuri does not exceed 40 chapters and all the work of the other characters will be only air.

I think that the focus should be changed but it only takes two volumes, maybe it will change Kei's feelings, since his thing is seen as jealousy of Himari's brother for not having someone close to him, but rather Kei is more like the affection of an older sister and that is what What Himari sees in her, in case of the good brother, maybe she has feelings for him, she is a childhood friend, and I think he is her only friend (since she has a disgust of personality) and stop seeing him as some kind of stranger.

 

[Lilliwyt]

Just said bluntly you don't like Yuri, it wil be faster.

I think Kei is a very badly structured character that a human being can fall in love with someone just by knowing him for a few hours

Then Touko from Bloom into You is also a badly structured character because she fall in love with Yuu will knowing her for just a few hours. Every romcoms have the same thing of girls falling in love with the MC will barely knowing him. Why does a girl fallling in love with another girl in a non-yuri manga is suddendly bad ? Did peoples suddendly stop knowing what love at first glance is ? Just because it's not a yuri manga doesn't mean there shouldn't be a yuri road. That's a very narrow way of thinking, there is no real problem with Kei beside her hate of mens being the reason she is a lesbian, it's bad writing for making a lesbian. You're literraly just searching a reason for putting Kei out of the way just because she is a girl and fall in love with the sister. Making Kei switching to friendship will be a middle finger to what Kei has been until now. Also you implying that 40 chapters is too short when it's already a lot of a 1st serie of an author, it's almost 6 volumes.

Description of the volumes on the author's page is focused on that theme

Which i fail to have seen so far beside the festival and even at the festival, he let hem Kei and Himari alone. Haruki don't even seem to care about her sister and we are 18 chapters in.

 

[kingaron]

@sombralord edit your comment there are a lot of incidents where you refer to kei with he/him and it makes reading your comment confusing.

 

[sombralord]

Lilliwyt

If you are right but it is not that I hate the yuri but that it does not match, the character at the beginning was fine only in chapter 4 he said "I will tell you one day" in a way of the love of Himari has as if he was quite time to have known her (and it only took a few hours to meet her and they only walked around) (last page of chapter 5) and that doesn't make sense, I don't hate her because she's a lesbian only that that ambiguous feeling developed when she saw her, ( as if it were programmed to see it), I have read yuri but it still does not make sense, and the way to express yourself is that it would take time to meet Himari for years and it only takes a few days at most, and to have the brother, the boy is only there to be filler apparently, please the brother, the childhood friend and Himari is on the cover of the author's twitter account and has more appearances in the manga filler characters, I read all three volumes and only the character Kei has no meaning or not for being a lesbian but for her crude attitude and look for example page 5 of chapter 18 she has a crude attitude to her childhood friend (who only sees Himari as her sister) saying in a petulant way that she likes this "guy "As if he were a perfect stranger (and he calls himself the childhood friend who in the first chapters tries to manipulate him since he was a child) I honestly find him very poorly structured in the case of Kei he lacks work and if they want to develop him they must give him better mature and not attitude of not being so violent, and also develop the co-protagonist more for more than they say that this will become it will not be already they gave this approach to romcom the same author described it like this.

anyway if you feel offended I apologize in advance I just think this does not mean I hate it I just say what I think.

 

[sombralord]

kingaron

sorry is that my english is not very good, and sometimes I confuse the subjects.

 

[Lilliwyt]

As if he were a perfect stranger (and he calls himself the childhood friend who in the first chapters tries to manipulate him since he was a child)

No, she says "this guy" because she know how he is, an asocial neet and also because the author is focus on making Kei hating boy more than anything. I get it Author, she is a lesbian, you can stop remind us she hate boys. She didn't try to "mnaipulate" him at all, she try to make him sociable, which ultimatly fail.

I have read yuri but it still does not make sense

Spoiler, it happen outside of Yuri. People can fall in love with someone even if they just met. I swear i've repeated that at least in every answer in this comment section. It's exhausting.

 

[BaToolo]

@justforthelulz

Ma guy, that made my day, though artwork could be a bit higher imo.

 

[BoneAppaTea]

Up to 45% of lesbian women report being victims of physical abuse by their partner and up to 90% of lesbians report psychological abuse by their partner. Protect Himari from Kei's lesbian battering.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_violence_in_lesbian_relationships

 

[sombralord]

Lilliwyt

What I say and I repeat and excuse me if I am somewhat stubborn what it implies is that Kei expresses the idea of ​​connecting it to Himari a long time (time in years weeks or a very long time in the time spent in manga) in chapter 5 where express, and you only take "hours" to know her is like saying that I love you a long time ago and I only know you today, it does not make sense for that reason (logical time management) and how it is expressed is very bad I can be a lesbian but does not mean that for being my friend I treat him as a stranger for the simple fact of finding someone that I like and is not reciprocated by an immature idea that she mentally process that is toxic in a manga of this type of theme ah me I forgot that forced fanservice that was seen and the last words that he said to Himari's brother remain the same with a question mark, I apologize in advance if I offend with any word that I say.

 

[Lilliwyt]

@BoneAppaTea Why it's even relevant to the manga ? How real life stats could apply to a fictional character ? Try to find a better place to use your stats.

 

[sombralord]

@Lilliwyt

well, it does not apply to anything, these characters are also fictitious, they are not even in any relationship, and I doubt that Kei will do something to him, suddenly hitting the brother, but it is not that they are blows, but also little touches, Himari does nothing to him.

 

[Neyney]

I refuse to drop, but God I'm not sure who is more annoying:
Is it tsundere Kei with her "I love him but I hate him but I love him but I'm afraid to tell him woe is me" act?
Or saccharine sweet Himari, 16 but a total airhead with zero understanding of social interaction. I mean, I know she's a happy go lucky country bumpkin but where was she living exactly? Under a rock? Locked in her mum's cellar maybe?

There's nieve innocence, then there's Himari

 

[Lilliwyt]

Is it tsundere Kei with her "I love him but I hate him but I love him but I'm afraid to tell him woe is me" act?

I suposs you mean her and not him. Kei is interested in the sister, not the brother.