Imasara desu ga, Osananajimi wo Suki ni Natte Shimaimashita - Ch. 25.5 - The Kiss Of Farewell

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 5, 2018
Messages
84
specifically, why Ayami can’t confide in her best friend and why Yuu isn’t honest with his childhood friend.
[Snip]
Overall, this situation feels overwhelmingly tangled, making it challenging to view Ayami and Yuu as sympathetic characters given their actions.

I find both of em sympathetic as lost puppy teenagers and yeah maybe Yu getting a little less lost is what made Hikari interested in him but then the not telling her about the ex at school feels like regressing, ETA but also like the avoidance is understandable :/
Aya maybe just didn't want to ruin Hikari's day but then that fell apart when she actually ran into Yuu.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 13, 2023
Messages
1,778
Lol, maybe I'm one of the few who actually like the plot. When I read the infamous chapter, I actually combed back the entire manga from the beginning and the hints were there. No actual lines explicitely told reader that the Male MC actually loves the Female MC, only that he admired her (even in chapter 24, when the female friend "quoted" that the boy told her when they were in the hotel that he loved his childhood friend, it was before they had relations with each other, so then again after that it could change. Maybe he did love the female lead before the whole thing with the female friend happened). And the Female MC's friend actually did not know that she would befriend the female lead in the future. Everybody gets triggered because of the NTR aspect, I fully understand that, because we view everything from the female lead's perspective. But re read the entire manga again, with the other characters' viewpoints in mind, I actually feel that storyline is quite acceptable, refreshing even. I hope the author continue without minding the complaints too much. Eventually, the story will unfold itself, so just be patient.
Nah, all I'm saying is, the main pairing is gone, there's no way in hell you can root for anything between FMC and the guy, especially since we've now spent ages only being shown how that guy makes out with another girl, after everything we've been shown

The only happy ending here is really just the fmc moving on, but maybe that's just me, though personally i can't view him as ml anymore
 
Active member
Joined
Feb 25, 2019
Messages
42
Huh!? They don’t need to explicitly say they had sex; just acknowledging that they dated is more than sufficient information. The fact that they were in a relationship carries its own weight and implications, and it provides enough context for the situation without delving into the specifics.
It was an incredibly personal thing that happed most likely over a few days it makes sense that they would not tell anyone about it. also up until the kiss there is no reason to being drama into their friendships by telling her about this also yuu does not know that the girl her got with a year and a half ago is the main girls best friend now so why would he tell her.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 13, 2023
Messages
1,778
But the massive problem with this line of thinking which also seems to the the line of thinking that most people hatting on this manga have it that it is completely delusional and based on nothing at all since everything you have said is completely untrue and just does not even happen in the manga.

there is no stealing of yuu from the main girl since at this point in time she does not even like yuu and clearly has made that very clear since yuu tells Ayami that the girl he likes does not see him that way.

also its more like the main girl is trying to steal Ayami's crush since she liked him before the main girl did.

SINCE ALL OF THIS IS HAPPENING BEFORE THE MAIN STORY STARTS
Just the fact that we see him essentially say he likes her and Yami knows it, yet 10mins later he jumps into bed with Yami like some horndog, then fmc at somepoint in time that isn't specified admits her feelings for mc, which Yami knows of, yet she pulls that shit, while they're supposedly aren't dating 😐

Yuu essentially stands up fmc and makes out with Yami in class (There wasn't even a hint of resistance), which she ends up seeing, hence learning of Yami's 'Betrayal', there isn't anything else fmc could perceive that as, since Yami knows of her feelings and fmc is in the dark about everything

So yeah, that's why both characters are fucked in terms of liveability
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Nov 21, 2023
Messages
14
Peak is back! :win:

Lol, maybe I'm one of the few who actually like the plot. When I read the infamous chapter, I actually combed back the entire manga from the beginning and the hints were there. No actual lines explicitely told reader that the Male MC actually loves the Female MC, only that he admired her (even in chapter 24, when the female friend "quoted" that the boy told her when they were in the hotel that he loved his childhood friend, it was before they had relations with each other, so then again after that it could change. Maybe he did love the female lead before the whole thing with the female friend happened). And the Female MC's friend actually did not know that she would befriend the female lead in the future. Everybody gets triggered because of the NTR aspect, I fully understand that, because we view everything from the female lead's perspective. But re read the entire manga again, with the other characters' viewpoints in mind, I actually feel that storyline is quite acceptable, refreshing even. I hope the author continue without minding the complaints too much. Eventually, the story will unfold itself, so just be patient.
Nah, the haters are just a lot more vocal. Take a look at previous discussions.
All the re-read hints you mentioned have been discussed ad nauseam since chapter 21. It's clear that this was all planned from the beginning and that Ayami is the 2nd FL.
Doesn't matter, people won't change their minds. They wanted fluffy romcom, got denied, and now it's raining 1-star ratings.

And now I did. It was ass and I'm actually dropping this this time because it was bearable before reading that but not anymore.

Cheers to those sticking with this. I'm out.
See ya next chapter! :bocchiwave:

Your opinion is wrong.

It’s not about NTR, it’s about a cute manga series with a plucky childhood friend who wants to confess to the boy she likes. It was cute and fluffy the whole time until he decided we needed the current round of shit chapters.

It’s the tasteless whiplash and the pointless edgy factor. So what if he didn’t have any feelings for her, there was plenty of bait that he did like her.

This series is shit, stop being a contrarian.
The audacity to call an opinion 'wrong' just because you don’t agree. Wild.

I think it really depends on how lenient you are when it comes to betrayal. Ayami was fully aware that Hikari liked Yuu, yet she chose not to disclose that she was his ex-girlfriend. To make matters worse, she went ahead and kissed him. Sure, Hikari isn’t in a relationship with Yuu, but neither is Ayami—she's his ex-girlfriend. If Ayami genuinely cared about Hikari, she would have been upfront about her history with Yuu and respected Hikari’s feelings. Instead, she tried to dodge Yuu at school, hoping to avoid any awkward encounters.

Let’s also consider that Yuu shares some blame in this mess. He could have told Hikari why he didn’t want to attend her school, but he opted to keep that information to himself as well. This secrecy isn’t just a minor issue; it fundamentally undermines trust in their relationships. Hikari deserves better than to find herself caught in a web of hidden truths and emotional turmoil.

The author must provide a convincing explanation for the secrecy surrounding this relationship—specifically, why Ayami can’t confide in her best friend and why Yuu isn’t honest with his childhood friend. Overall, this situation feels overwhelmingly tangled, making it challenging to view Ayami and Yuu as sympathetic characters given their actions. This isn’t merely a matter of awkwardness; it represents a profound breach of trust that jeopardizes their friendships.
It's not that deep, bro.

She is Yuu's CF, not his mother. He doesn't have to tell her everything. Their interactions are limited as is, admitting he had a gf might've been embarrassing.
Ayami didn’t initially realize her ex is Hikari's crush. She tried to skirt the issue and avoid the problem, which only made things worse.

Both cases are totally normal teenage behavior.
Sure, if they ‘just talked’ and had ‘open communication,’ blah blah. But in real life, people struggle to communicate openly, and you expect teenagers in manga to do so?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 5, 2019
Messages
780
I mean, if had not been set on main FMC, and this was a story about MC being the healing that this new chick needs. Then I would all for it.

But its... just wrong. I get that it is in the past, but it feels like this chick is just showing up cause FMC is closer to getting MC... Seems scummy.


Maybe if she had been around from the start and we knew they had a past then maybe I would not be so up in arms... but this shit feels so fucking forced.
 
Active member
Joined
Jan 21, 2021
Messages
223
Lol, maybe I'm one of the few who actually like the plot. When I read the infamous chapter, I actually combed back the entire manga from the beginning and the hints were there. No actual lines explicitely told reader that the Male MC actually loves the Female MC, only that he admired her (even in chapter 24, when the female friend "quoted" that the boy told her when they were in the hotel that he loved his childhood friend, it was before they had relations with each other, so then again after that it could change. Maybe he did love the female lead before the whole thing with the female friend happened). And the Female MC's friend actually did not know that she would befriend the female lead in the future. Everybody gets triggered because of the NTR aspect, I fully understand that, because we view everything from the female lead's perspective. But re read the entire manga again, with the other characters' viewpoints in mind, I actually feel that storyline is quite acceptable, refreshing even. I hope the author continue without minding the complaints too much. Eventually, the story will unfold itself, so just be patient.
This, actually. It was purely one-sided since the start and the dude has never explicitly said he likes /ourgirl/.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 8, 2020
Messages
143
for God's sake, just what the fuck is life had done to the men for this mf made this shit
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 15, 2023
Messages
1,702
I find both of em sympathetic as lost puppy teenagers and yeah maybe Yu getting a little less lost is what made Hikari interested in him but then the not telling her about the ex at school feels like regressing, ETA but also like the avoidance is understandable :/
Aya maybe just didn't want to ruin Hikari's day but then that fell apart when she actually ran into Yuu.
That’s fine and reasonable, but getting back to my original point: how do you truly regain lost trust and foster forgiveness? I don’t believe that simply saying, “I’m sorry, I didn’t mean to hurt your feelings,” is enough, especially given the extent of Hikari’s hurt. Wouldn’t it have been far more beneficial for Ayami and Yuu to be honest from the beginning? Their lack of transparency not only complicates matters but also deepens the damage they’ve inflicted. That’s why I maintain that the only acceptable outcome for me is for Hikari to end her friendship with Ayami and move on from Yuu.
 
Active member
Joined
Feb 25, 2019
Messages
42
Just the fact that we see him essentially say he likes her and Yami knows it, yet 10mins later he jumps into bed with Yami like some horndog, then fmc at somepoint in time that isn't specified admits her feelings for mc, which Yami knows of, yet she pulls that shit, while they're supposedly aren't dating 😐

Yuu essentially stands up fmc and makes out with Yami in class (There wasn't even a hint of resistance), which she ends up seeing, hence learning of Yami's 'Betrayal', there isn't anything else fmc could perceive that as, since Yami knows of her feelings and fmc is in the dark about everything

So yeah, that's why both characters are fucked in terms of liveability

Are you some how forgetting that he also knows that she does not like him back and he tells Yami that, he may have loved her deeply but he knows she does not feel the same way why should he be forced to never move on from his one sided love.

Also its not like the fmc is entitled to him she only just released that she likes him he is not hers to own.

Also if anyone has dips on him its the girl who was in love with him longer.

if you truely believe that people should not move on from one-sided loves you are a very twisted person.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 21, 2023
Messages
467
maybe Yu getting a little less lost is what made Hikari interested in him
:lul:Does this mean Hikari start to like Yu romantically because he boned Yami? Probably not but it will be funny if it were.

I dunno if original wn is over yet but if Hikari lose, this gonna be the first time I read a story where childhood friend manage to lose even in childhood friend-focused story.
 
Joined
Aug 24, 2024
Messages
3
Not even mad. To the only man she didn’t despise, this is what she deserves, a true happy route
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 28, 2019
Messages
104
MTL of the novel:

Episode 25.5: Dream or Reality?

Late February.

The warm air from the AC and the thick curtains make it hard to tell, but it's probably past noon.

"Suuh, suuh..." "........."

The place is... a room in a somewhat "questionable" hotel. Fresh out of the shower, I’m wrapped in nothing but a bath towel, reflected in a large full-length mirror.

"Mm, mmm... kuuuu..." "Yuu...?"

At the moment, I had become "the woman who mischievously peers at a man’s sleeping face in bed"—a common enough scene, yet something entirely new for me.

……

……

So, how far back should I go to explain the situation?

Twenty-four hours ago, the guy sleeping in front of me—Yuu—and I were having a consolation dinner at a family restaurant.

Twelve hours ago, we were already in this hotel. But instead of doing anything significant, we were a mess—crying, yelling, exposing our immaturity.

And six hours ago... I would’ve liked to tease the two of us from back then, saying, "All your innocence was totally wasted, huh?" because what followed was utterly inappropriate but undeniably blissful...

"Suuhhh~ Fuuuhhh~" "Pfft."

I burst out laughing. But it wasn’t the kind of laugh that mocked myself or others like before.

It’s just... it was really dumb. Yuu's breathing, Yuu's sleeping face.

He was lying there with his mouth slightly open like a fish, his breathing uneven—sometimes snoring, sometimes completely silent, all over the place. Even his facial expressions kept changing, despite being asleep.

That wasn't ridiculous; it was just goofy. You get the difference in nuance, right?

"Aha, haha, ha... ~~~"

I kept teasing his sleeping face and breath, laughing, messing around...

But then, out of nowhere, I got so embarrassed by my own silliness that I covered my face with both hands.

I went and did it.

With such a childish guy. With such an innocent-looking guy. With such a gentle-looking guy.

With a guy I’ve fallen head over heels for...

Wait, this isn't right. I'm mixing up objectivity and subjectivity. I've really turned into an idiot. I used to get good grades in Japanese until middle school.

"Mmm, fugh..." "Hey, Yuu... let's go home?"

I shouldn't be lost in some lovestruck monologue like a silly kid.

We’ve been together all day yesterday, and now half of today is gone. I mean, I don’t mind at all, but Yuu's family...

He failed his entrance exams, and even though he told them where he was, what kind of parent wouldn’t worry if their kid didn’t come home the next day? ...Well, looking at my family, maybe that’s not always the case.

But after seeing how good-natured and well-raised Yuu is, you can just tell his parents must be kind, responsible, and loving. I don’t want to ruin such a nice family, not like mine...

...Yeah, until yesterday, I never would’ve thought like this.

"Come on, wake up already." "Suuh... suuhhh..."

I kneel beside the bed and lean in closer to peer at his face.

The closer I get, the goofier his sleeping face seems. But the closer I get, the more a feeling races through my mind that’s totally different from what you’d expect to feel when looking at such a silly expression.

"You healthy little brat~" "Fwah."

To hide that warm, wet feeling, I give Yuu a playful poke on the tip of his nose.

He stirs slightly but then quickly resumes his peaceful breathing, making all my (though it doesn't look like it) desperate efforts completely pointless.

Well, to be honest, I was the one who kept him up all night, so it’s no surprise he’s passed out like this.

Still, I’ve learned that just poking him won’t work. I’ll need to give him a stronger stimulus.

"If you keep sleeping so soundly like this..."

I take off the bath towel, climb onto the bed, and straddle Yuu. From right above, I gaze down at his defenseless, goofy face.

Not just my face, but my whole body draws closer to his. Close enough to feel not only Yuu's breath but his warmth too.

"You’ll have no idea what might happen~?"

Slowly, I place my hands on the blanket covering him...

"…Let's go home."

The fool is me.

I’m trying to wake him up so he can go home, so why am I getting all worked up? I want to wake him gently, so why am I getting heated?

How long am I going to drag around this flushed body and heart?

It’s just because today has been the happiest day of my life so far...

……

……

"See you, Yuu." "Mm, suuh..."

I got dressed. Set the alarm to the maximum volume for thirty minutes from now.

Even though I was rummaging around next to the bed, Yuu showed no signs of waking up. ...Will he really wake up when the alarm goes off?

Well, I’m a little worried, but still, I won’t wake him myself. The only thing I can do now is leave and take away the reason for him to stay here.

Because I just realized... ...that when Yuu wakes up in front of me, I don’t have the confidence to calmly say, "Let's go home."

"Next time... then..." "Mmm, mm..."

So for the last time... A little farewell kiss.

Just a tiny little one.

My lips missed Yuu’s and touched his cheek, three centimeters off.

Because, you know, if I kissed his lips, or stopped his breathing, he might wake up, right?

...Come to think of it.

This is the first time we’ve had such a light kiss, huh? The first time we’ve kissed without using our tongues.

And to think, the most innocent kiss we've ever had was done secretly while he was asleep.

And why does it feel so embarrassing...?

My sense of shame is definitely different from normal. What even am I?

"Well, then."

Before leaving, I take one last moment to enjoy the view. That same goofy sleeping face is still so peaceful.

You failed your first-choice school yesterday, right? And yet you’re sleeping so soundly... No, sorry. You were just really tired, huh?

Sorry about this morning’s rough time. I didn’t know how to hold back either.

……

……

Ayami Matsushita. A pretty average high school delinquent. But so what? What does that even matter?
fck the novel is even hotter for some reason
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 17, 2024
Messages
666
NGL, I thought Yuu was putting up a tent there on last page for a hot minute before I noticed his foot.

But boy, why do people so adamant on hating this manga?

I know Hikari is a likeable character, I also like her, but life isn't always going the way you want to. She was slow to realize her feeling and even slower to make a move; she has to accept that fact and grow from it. What matters is who get him at the end. If anything, this is even more setting up Ayami to be the losing heroine here because it'll be difficult to make sense of the story if Ayami wins - which is kinda even sadder for her if you ask me. I see potential for this to develop into something great instead of generic vanilla romcom. If anything, this is just caramel - spicing things up a bit but still very plain and pleasant. It hasn't gone that far dark.

EDIT
Okay, I avoided the comments before but went back and read them anyway. There's a lot more of level-headed discussion there now, unlike previous chapters. That's good to see. I kinda see some of your points but I'll agree to disagree.
 
Last edited:
Active member
Joined
Oct 5, 2023
Messages
14
I could care less about the backstory at this point I just want to know how the story will progress from here
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top