Iroiro Ushinatta TS Ko. - Ch. 31

Joined
Jan 15, 2023
Messages
1
This isn't even yuri; he was a former man so it doesn't count.
Does that mean a transfem person, who’s into women isn’t gay? Or vice versa? No, I don't think it isn’t, plus they aren’t referred to with male pronouns when talking about their current self, so they don’t mind being called "she" or "her".
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 14, 2019
Messages
1,297
Does that mean a transfem person, who’s into women isn’t gay? Or vice versa? No, I don't think it isn’t, plus they aren’t referred to with male pronouns when talking about their current self, so they don’t mind being called "she" or "her".
My opinion and hot take: I never said anything about "Trans" people, she really isn't transgender at all as we literally say a page where she was sweating, getting smaller, and everything in a chapter; I may have said it in a bad way yes but I wouldn't believe it is yuri if they were formally a male and suddenly became a female due to whatever laws of physics they have in their own world.

I already had this discussion about trans people and stuff in a Magical girl Kakeru thread over one opinion and respects theirs, obviously, it's a bit different yes but that person gradually becomes feminine due to a lot of things going around her; this one I think it is just hormones and other brain-related activity that makes her feminine and why she refers to as a she.

Never said anything about trans people or anything, all I said was that in my opinion, it doesn't count as yuri due to other things I've seen. And, I am not having this discussion again about dumb gender bend/GB one-page chapters.

(Edit: Just skimmed/slightly read all pagers again, they never referred to themselves as a she or a male at all, the other characters do and the MC doesn't seem to care at all. If that was one of your points.)
 
Last edited:
Power Uploader
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
579
I'll just make one thing clear, I'm using female pronouns for convenience's sake. The way they refer to Kanade in Japanese is neutral, except in a few instances. And well, Kanade is now a bonafide woman with a cunny and all them maidenly parts.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 14, 2019
Messages
1,297
I'll just make one thing clear, I'm using female pronouns for convenience's sake. The way they refer to Kanade in Japanese is neutral, except in a few instances. And well, Kanade is now a bonafide woman with a cunny and all them maidenly parts.

No wonder why when I read the raws the refer to them is different, I guess learning japanese paid off.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 21, 2023
Messages
4,021
Does that mean a transfem person, who’s into women isn’t gay? Or vice versa? No, I don't think it isn’t, plus they aren’t referred to with male pronouns when talking about their current self, so they don’t mind being called "she" or "her".
It actually always depends on the work, because no one in the world (humans, no clown fish don't count, i'm not even sure if they understand the concept of sexuality) can change gender (or wake up one day to realise that they caught a very cool disease) we need to refer to the work itself. Does the change in their biology lead to them changing their mind? Do they think of themself as the other gender now? Does it even matter in the end, because it's all fiction and so no one cares?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top