Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jul 12, 2019
- Messages
- 2,082
The nerd in me is screaming "Bro what do you mean a spear wouldn't be viable for combat, do really think thousands of years of warfare got it wrong??"
The other nerd in me is thinking of all the Miqote Dragoons I get in Duty Finder in FFXIV, and having to walk that back just a tiny bit.
Might be because they'll be in a labyrinth, AKA an enclosed space, rather than an open field. At least, that's my rationalization for it.
Sherry is already using a spear, so he doesn't have anything against using a spear in the labyrinth.I think he's thinking in terms of their party balance as things currently stand before testing her out in combat.
Miria was talking about her weapon of choice during fishing, so he just wanted to ask again what she used for the labyrinth.
You're correct that he was thinking of harpoon.Nah, they use a spear later on. What comes to mind for me is maybe him thinking "harpoon" (given underwater spear fishing and Miria's job), which isn't really a good melee weapon. And then it's either mistranslated, or he's misunderstanding what she means, or he does understand her but the text is ambiguous.
Good enough for a handwave, anyway.
The line "Isn't that for fishing?" on pg 10 was それは銛では? in the raw, which I would translate as "are you talking about a harpoon?"
Then he clarified the question "I was asking (about your weapon) for the labyrinth, (not for fishing)."