Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2023
- Messages
- 4,458
Well, mc not being op and actually receiving a near fatal would is refreshing, he just needs to stretch his legs now...
We'll he ain't walking out from that, that's for sure
Grimsargh also has an mc that is lame.Well, mc not being op and actually receiving a near fatal would is refreshing, he just needs to stretch his legs now...
thank you for the spoiler, it helped me decide whether to continue this or notDo you really want to know? Which arc?
Non-spoiler summary is WN is R15+, which you wouldn't get from reading the manga thus far.
People are in for some tonal whiplash.
TL;DR: Series undergoes a lot of "tonal shifts". Like his "Walking" skill becoming irrelevant [JP WN comments/reviews on Kakiyomu point this out]. Manga being fluffy at the start will make that shift worse. I have concerns how they will adapt the WN's basic plot into Manga form without off-putting their original "happy-go-lucky adventure / SoL" audience.
As best as I can recall (it's been months): becomes your standard "Kingdom is actually evil, demons are the good guys". But it was interesting up to and including this point; it was well-executed. Kingdom was involved in a lot of unethical things, that I don't want to type out. Including how they were summoned, and what happens to summoned people. Slavery. Mind control collars. Generational stuff. Eugenics. One of the characters that joins them. And content of some of MC's adventures and who he meets up until then (and what happened to them/missions they are on). Orcs. Absolute slap on wrist (plotwise) for Kingdom involved.
It got a bit gritty. I'm not sure how they are going to adapt it into a PG8 romance-adventure-comedy manga. Let's just say MC here dodged a bullet by being thrown out, and potentially much worse. The slice of life you see here with the two girls is actually mild, and sets a lot of his goals and objectives for later on. (Yes, the girls DO eventually accomplish their objective with MC's help. At least the Kingdom arc was tied off.)
When it got worse: a lot of artificial drama with forced villain of the goddess. Author wasted a lot of text trying to justify it. But it basically boils down to "she ruined the world and made it a living hell (orcs, etc) because she was lonely". Since other gods went down to world, to live with their races. Somehow expected this as justification for her behavior. Something about her power source, megalomaniacal behavior, and sudden (failed) heel-face-turn trying to protect said source.
I stopped reading when it became a "collect the plot tokens in each dungeon across the world to undo the damage she caused". The justifications were too shallow. And the Dungeon chapters (remember: tonal shift) dragged in all arcs, and realized I tended to simply skip them a lot. Even if his Walking skill gets power-scaled out, spending entire chapters about "Dungeon diving" in a "travel the-world-and-see-what's-different adventure novel" was off-putting. And I'm not even sure if there was progress in the romance sub-plot.
I really wished he died back then instead of getting an immense harem and a list of unusable one-time powers.RIP mc. I'll leave this 🥒 for you
I love your optimism, but you should be aware how things are going...Will he and Chris confess their feelings? I sure hope so!
Geez when you said tonal whiplash I didn't think it'd go on a complete 180Do you really want to know? Which arc?
Non-spoiler summary is WN is R15+, which you wouldn't get from reading the manga thus far.
People are in for some tonal whiplash.
SPOILER STUFF
Reminds me of A Rank Party wo Ridatsu Shita Ore wa, Moto Oshiego Tachi to Meikyuu Shinbu wo Mezasu how that shit started offf pretty fluffy and a straight up tone shift to some fucked up shit for no reason.Do you really want to know? Which arc?
Non-spoiler summary is WN is R15+, which you wouldn't get from reading the manga thus far.
People are in for some tonal whiplash.
TL;DR: Series undergoes a lot of "tonal shifts". Like his "Walking" skill becoming irrelevant [JP WN comments/reviews on Kakiyomu point this out]. Manga being fluffy at the start will make that shift worse. I have concerns how they will adapt the WN's basic plot into Manga form without off-putting their original "happy-go-lucky adventure / SoL" audience.
As best as I can recall (it's been months): becomes your standard "Kingdom is actually evil, demons are the good guys". But it was interesting up to and including this point; it was well-executed. Kingdom was involved in a lot of unethical things, that I don't want to type out. Including how they were summoned, and what happens to summoned people. Slavery. Mind control collars. Generational stuff. Eugenics. One of the characters that joins them. And content of some of MC's adventures and who he meets up until then (and what happened to them/missions they are on). Orcs. Absolute slap on wrist (plotwise) for Kingdom involved.
It got a bit gritty. I'm not sure how they are going to adapt it into a PG8 romance-adventure-comedy manga. Let's just say MC here dodged a bullet by being thrown out, and potentially much worse. The slice of life you see here with the two girls is actually mild, and sets a lot of his goals and objectives for later on. (Yes, the girls DO eventually accomplish their objective with MC's help. At least the Kingdom arc was tied off.)
When it got worse: a lot of artificial drama with forced villain of the goddess. Author wasted a lot of text trying to justify it. But it basically boils down to "she ruined the world and made it a living hell (orcs, etc) because she was lonely". Since other gods went down to world, to live with their races. Somehow expected this as justification for her behavior. Something about her power source, megalomaniacal behavior, and sudden (failed) heel-face-turn trying to protect said source.
I stopped reading when it became a "collect the plot tokens in each dungeon across the world to undo the damage she caused". The justifications were too shallow. And the Dungeon chapters (remember: tonal shift) dragged in all arcs, and realized I tended to simply skip them a lot. Even if his Walking skill gets power-scaled out, spending entire chapters about "Dungeon diving" in a "travel the-world-and-see-what's-different adventure novel" was off-putting. And I'm not even sure if there was progress in the romance sub-plot.
I read the WN/LN for that too. That's actually not that bad, since it's "only" one arc.Reminds me of A Rank Party wo Ridatsu Shita Ore wa, Moto Oshiego Tachi to Meikyuu Shinbu wo Mezasu how that shit started offf pretty fluffy and a straight up tone shift to some fucked up shit for no reason.