Katainaka no Ossan, Kensei ni Naru ~Tada no Inaka no Kenjutsu Shihan Datta noni, Taisei shita Deshi-tachi ga Ore wo Hottekurenai Ken~ - Vol. 7 Ch. 29…

[Vergift]

Wow...the story take a different turn compare to the LN

Spoiler: LN Spoiler

In the LN, Schupple didn't have a tragic backstory. He's just there as a strong bodyguard for that shitty bishop. Myui didn't ask Beryl to teach her swordmanship, but she had more talent in magic and later attend the magic academy. Beryl also didn't talk about Myui's sister to Myui. Beryl choose not to speak about it because he felt bad about it.

But I prefer how the story goes in the manga. It give the other characters more personalities compare to the LN.

 

[equationx]

Wow...the story take a different turn compare to the LN

Spoiler: LN Spoiler

In the LN, Schupple didn't have a tragic backstory. He's just there as a strong bodyguard for that shitty bishop. Myui didn't ask Beryl to teach her swordmanship, but she had more talent in magic and later attend the magic academy. Beryl also didn't talk about Myui's sister to Myui. Beryl choose not to speak about it because he felt bad about it.

But I prefer how the story goes in the manga. It give the other characters more personalities compare to the LN.

you sure it's LN ver.? because if that's true, that would be weird, since manga adaptation usually follow LN closely, and the loose one usually WN ver.

 

[tekkenshu7]

Thanks and looking forward to the next arc!

 

[Resound]

sooooooo… he gets another girl? coz wvery student wants him after all

 

[Solipsist]

I swear to baby buddha if the anime is going to be a mass-produced garbo...
This is a manga primarily focused on action scenes, if they'd have people fight in 5 FPS and do talk-no-jutsu constantly, it'd be pointless even as an ad.

 

[didien]

I don't want Schuppe to die though. Hope his death is a fake out.

As much as i like schupple i cant see his arc ending any other way. And i usually hate death being used to end a character arc.

 

[slyss]

you sure it's LN ver.? because if that's true, that would be weird, since manga adaptation usually follow LN closely, and the loose one usually WN ver.

This manga is known for doing its own thing vastly improving on the source material, which is one of the reasons why there have plenty of Japanese comments expressing concern about the anime adaptation, since it will be adapting the LN, while the manga, which is what put this series in the spotlight and accounts for most of the sales (5 to 1), has been the main attraction.

 

[exxeld]

this would be a good spot for the anime adaptation to end however that was a cool ending to the arc.

 

[zeinzki]

so, when MC get married?

 

[Vergift]

you sure it's LN ver.? because if that's true, that would be weird, since manga adaptation usually follow LN closely, and the loose one usually WN ver.

Yes, it was an LN. The English translated one was published by J-Novel. That's why I'm surprised with the story in the manga were a bit different than in the LN.

 

[Saizken]

Wow...the story take a different turn compare to the LN

Spoiler: LN Spoiler

In the LN, Schupple didn't have a tragic backstory. He's just there as a strong bodyguard for that shitty bishop. Myui didn't ask Beryl to teach her swordmanship, but she had more talent in magic and later attend the magic academy. Beryl also didn't talk about Myui's sister to Myui. Beryl choose not to speak about it because he felt bad about it.

But I prefer how the story goes in the manga. It give the other characters more personalities compare to the LN.

Thank you for reminding me because I thought I went crazy thinking this isn't how I remembered it. Truly better how this one has been done.

 

[Vergift]

This manga is known for doing its own thing vastly improving on the source material, which is one of the reasons why there have plenty of Japanese comments expressing concern about the anime adaptation, since it will be adapting the LN, while the manga, which is what put this series in the spotlight and accounts for most of the sales (5 to 1), has been the main attraction.

Oh shit, please don't adapt the LN version. The early arc is pretty rough. 😭

 

[Karikko]

Mann...Schupple was reaally a good adversary.

 

[lenovoaxioo]

its fine, let the man rest....he's been thru so much already he deserves that kind of ending at least

yeah, we should let go

 

[HaikenEdge]

Didn't somebody say in the forums last chapter that Beryl in the LN was a forever alone sad boy who thinks he's deeper than he really is?

 

[Duainfey]

LN is terribly boring in contrast against this adaption. Just so much more interesting reading this translation.

 

[slyss]

Oh shit, please don't adapt the LN version. The early arc is pretty rough. 😭

You had the same reaction as A LOT of people when the first PV was revealed.
Seriously, when Beryl's design was revealed, people were like, "Wait, this is the novel's design? Not the manga's?!"
And it seems the design got retouched later after people commented on it.

The LN is just... bland. Funny enough, in the first PV, they mention the series' total sales were 5.5M, but what they didn't mention is that the manga alone hit 4.5M copies before the PV dropped. So yeah, the manga outsells the LN by that much, yet the LN is what's being adapted. That's why I'm keeping my expectations low, just in case it ends up being one of the biggest wasted potentials ever.

Frankly, if the studios were smart, they could take all the improvements the manga made to the story and build on that with the LN as the source, making fans happy with a decent adaptation. But seeing the studios in charge... who knows...

 

[jeremymd]

you sure it's LN ver.? because if that's true, that would be weird, since manga adaptation usually follow LN closely, and the loose one usually WN ver.

I've seen too many manga diverging from official LN to know that that's not always the case.

 

[jeremymd]

You had the same reaction as A LOT of people when the first PV was revealed.
Seriously, when Beryl's design was revealed, people were like, "Wait, this is the novel's design? Not the manga's?!"
And it seems the design got retouched later after people commented on it.

The LN is just... bland. Funny enough, in the first PV, they mention the series' total sales were 5.5M, but what they didn't mention is that the manga alone hit 4.5M copies before the PV dropped. So yeah, the manga outsells the LN by that much, yet the LN is what's being adapted. That's why I'm keeping my expectations low, just in case it ends up being one of the biggest wasted potentials ever.

Frankly, if the studios were smart, they could take all the improvements the manga made to the story and build on that with the LN as the source, making fans happy with a decent adaptation. But seeing the studios in charge... who knows...

I don't see why they wouldn't leverage the ideas from both manga and LN versions. I really hope the anime does the action well.

 

[CheesiBoye]

its fine, let the man rest....he's been thru so much already he deserves that kind of ending at least

He's finally back with his beloved