Kimi wa Yotsuba no Clover - Ch. 42 - Deathday

[AnimuVsMango]

Nevermind, vrats coping in comments. (I'm one of them )

So turns out that the red herring middle school "friend" wasn't such a red herring after all, which is a little disappointing. But I will continue to maintain faith that he is a different entity than Yotsuba (Clover).

The flashback to his promise not actually about being a vet, but about not making her cry, man

But seriously though, I know Yotsuha was trying to comfort Uichi, but that was just the dumbest thing to say. It's like if he rolled up to her one day after she got beat up all happy and cheerful, and was like "Oh yeah, that promise that you made to be happy? Lol it's fine, not like it really matters." It would completely obliterate her sense of self and reason for being...which is exactly what it did to Uichi.

Still though, a nice subversion to the whole "I killed Uichi, I can never be forgiven" hook. Unless the author pulls another doozy on us

 

[R3k2y]

Chapter 36, page 15, there's a panel where the middle school bullies tell Rei that Uichi was on their side the whole time.

in chapter 36 page 15 I think you miss interpreted what it said being the Bullies became “Good Friends” part because it starts with Yotsuha thinking back to middle school and says that Uichi tried to stop the bullying towards Rei and when that all happened the bullies changed their target or added Uichi to the list of people to bully.

 

[Wanderer00]

But seriously though, I know Yotsuha was trying to comfort Uichi, but that was just the dumbest thing to say. It's like if he rolled up to her one day after she got beat up all happy and cheerful, and was like "Oh yeah, that promise that you made to be happy? Lol it's fine, not like it really matters." It would completely obliterate her sense of self and reason for being...which is exactly what it did to Uichi.

Dude, how the heck was she supposed to know that it'd cause him to commit suicide?? She had had her hands full with bullies of her own, a psychotic mom, and then enduring extensive physical therapy after she pushed herself for years until she collapsed.

She didn't have any time to check up on him, so of course she couldn't know of his hardships, ghe freakin' clover mastermind, etc, and she was sad and confused when she met him in that state and didn't have the rationale or time to make a logical decision since everything happened so quickly.
Like, she is just a teenager, what do you expect from her?

So as I said, it was really a combination of a series of unfortunate circumastances that resulted in the worst possible outcome.

I feel bad for both of them.

 

[Burin]

Probably not the mastermind, maybe another pawn of the true mastermind like the family were?
Still, if that watch ever works again - she has a new target, make sure his bullying goes the way of the Maria manga.