Tadano way too smooth and clueless(not dumb) at the same time; the best and the worse kind of trade in a character. You like it alot or you hate it lot. The choice depends on the execution of per say trade.
@GARE Some chapters ago I did leave a message about my thoughts on who would be the ideal V/A for Komi if the series was ever to be adapted into anime, and I, too, mentioned that 早見沙織 is the prefect candidate. Her range can easily cover any Yamato Nadeshiko type of character, meaning her voice as Komi san would be a perfect fit and I wouldn't want it any other way.
For example remember how she did act as Shouko (same name as Komi-san btw) in Silent voice where MFC also had troubles speaking.
wow Komi talking in public and inviting her crush on a "date" that takes courage for a regular person, she must have felt like dying and then the sweet relief when Tadano happily accepted.