Yeah, I think the level of anguish she's showing here to the point of doing a death march (literally), and not once did she say "i want him to forgive me"? Thats real.
early in my relationship with my wife, i was an absolute jackass. I was selfish, self centered, and even flirted with other women. When i realized what i was doing and how badly i hurt her i was in a very similar mindset to emmy. I was willing to do anything and everything to attone. Those first 6 months have impacted the now 4 years weve been together. Clearly my wife has come to forgive me for who i was now that ive worked on myself and put in the effort. She had every opportunity and right to leave me, but seeing that i was trying to change and be better was enough for her to give me a chance and im grateful every day for it. But the people here would have wanted to hang me from my eye sockets without a second thought.
Kudos on all of your hard work to change, that certainly didn't come easy. Congrats on finding such a catch, and coming to cherish her.
Other people are idiots, and are really shallow. Often sad, lonely, angry, bitter people, who take pleasure in vengeance.
Naruto gets a lot of flak for talk no jutsu, and rightfully so I guess. But that story really does well showing the cycle of hate, and how it takes grace, a willingness to look for the good/redemption in others, not an eye for an eye, to create change and build to a better future.
The worst part about this is, its not even like what this party did to MC was even that bad. They all got recovery magic, and the tank got hurt trying to protect the healer who isn't really needed and "can't really fight"(assumed). So they kick him out so he won't be endangered as they plan to take on more dangerous and leave him a ton of cash. Oooooooo, such horrible people. Gokus probably a worse person by many mutitudes.
(male character is actually kinda scummy(he is a womanizer and wanted MC gone for a better shot with other girls), but having ulterior motives doesn't change the rationale and reasoning used to kick MC out)
Girl in redemption arc objected from the beginning. She continued to feel guilt about MC getting kicked out then decided to quit the party as well. She wandered around feeling like shit for not standing up for him earlier, then decided to help MC no matter what to atone.
If that is something so horrible that she should be permanently unforgivable and probably deserve to die, then I deserve something that makes Dantes Inferno's hells seem like a kiddie park ride.