Lowfyie's Fabled and Famous Yuri Rating Thread !!

[Lowfyie]

Shoujo Sect was on-going when I recall stumbling into yuri.

Not my fault ur on your death bed, my consodelences

 

[Manko-sensei]

Not my fault ur on your death bed, my consodelences

No, definitely your fault for being a newborn.

 

[Lowfyie]

Rating 3: 29/09/2025 (20:08 p.m.)

Mai no Mushigurashi

​

Lowfyie's rating: 9/10

Spoiler: Depression scale

Depression scale: 4/5

Spoiler: Yuri scale

Yuri scale: 2/3

Honestly didn't expect it to be this good when I started reading it. The art is awesome, and the bugs are dope. It's a bug manga, if you're a bug nerd you'll love it

I don't know if I would call it a romance manga? It definitely has romance, but its mostly comedy and bug stuff

Its one of those mangas that will make you go "aww" when you finish reading it and then you'll be very depressed because of your lack of a relationship like the one in the manga.

Spoiler

I didn't expect the grandpa to be such a major key-point in the story, but it worked really well, to add some psychological stuff to the manga aswell as somehow develop the two girl's relationship. Very nice

 

[Lowfyie]

Rating 4: 4/10/2025

Shimeji Simulation

​

Lowfie's rating: 10/10

Spoiler: Depression scale

Depression scale: 4/5

Spoiler: Yuri scale

Yuri scale: 2/3

This is a MASTERPIECE!!!!!!!!! By the one and only Tsukumizu! Go read this NOW!!!! I read it all in the span of one day, from morning till midnight. In Tsukumizu's previous work, girl's last tour, they only did "yuri subtexts" blech. Buddy pulled out all the stops with this one, though!

That being said, I wouldn't read it just for the yuri, theres yuri in it, and its a major part of the story, but my GOD if this isn't one of the best mangas I've ever read! And it still would be even without the yuri.

It gets real philosophical though, so put ur thinking cap on

 

[Lowfyie]

Rating 5: 11/10/2025 20:06

Rainbows After Storms

Lowfyie's rating: 10/10

Spoiler: Depression scale

Depression scale: 2/5

Spoiler: Yuri scale

Yuri scale: 2/3

​

Very really good manga, great romance, and I love all the characters too!
Like genuinely, I dont think this manga has one caracter thats just 2D bad, everyone has thei lil personalities and even if they didnt do something good, the more you think about it, the more the reason they did that bad thing falls within the narrative without feeling like the person is just a bad person for being a bad person. And using that, they touch topics you dont see a lot being talked about in yuri manga!

This was another manga I found when I was just starting my yuri career, and the ending was nice too. Its also pretty long, so it'll last you for a while. Totally recommend it!

 

[Lowfyie]

Rating 6: 11/10/2025 20:14

Honey Crush

​

Lowfyie's rating: 8/10

Spoiler: Depression scale

Depression scale: 5/5

Spoiler: Yuri scale

Yuri scale: 2/3

Honestly surprisingly good manga, and kind of upped my expectations for old yuri mangas since this was one of the first ones from before 2010 that I read.
I feel like if I say anything about it I might spoil the story?
Go read it, its short! You'll have fun.

 

[Lowfyie]

I've definitely only been rating good mangas so far... I dont really feel like getting mad about the bad ones here

also I did two today cuz I didn't do any this week, so these are the 2 for it

 

[holicastral]

You guys know me, Im the biggest himejoshi currently alive in the forums (I killed the competition), so who better to make a yuri rating thread than me

The ratings will be done by three parameters:

My overall rating of the manga/manhwa, from 1/10, where 6 is a passing grade, meaning its not specially special but it ain't bad

The depression scale (suggested by @Aluminium_Spaghetti) rated from 1/5, 1 being slapstick and 5 being death despair and everything unfair

The yuri scale, going from 0/3, where 0 is "someone tagged this by mistake they didnt even fucking hold hands" and 3 being "holy shit they are sucking and fucking oh my god".
The in-betweens, 1 and 2, are respectively: "they didnt do much but they did confess" and "kissed and married"

I cant guarantee I will update this everyday, definitely every, like, week, maybe twice a week idk, I rate as I go ykwim

hey what do you think of Suwajiku Hime Monogatari (SHM!), i think its quite tragic cuz the vibes were kinda good and the art nice but oh well (also the few other chaps aint even here, they may be gone even for all i know)
but ey give me your vibe check

 

[Lowfyie]

hey what do you think of Suwajiku Hime Monogatari (SHM!), i think its quite tragic cuz the vibes were kinda good and the art nice but oh well (also the few other chaps aint even here, they may be gone even for all i know)
but ey give me your vibe check

I havent read it and I probably wouldnt if not for your recommendation since its only got one chapter on mangadex but Ill try making an effort since its been so long since Ive done anything in this thread

 

[Lowfyie]

Actually, nevermind... I cant find anything past the 1st chapter anywhere and I dont feel like reading a web novel... If I had to rate the first chapter, Id say it was pretty weird and wacky, but I cant really formulate an opinion on the thing since its just the first chapter

 

[holicastral]

Actually, nevermind... I cant find anything past the 1st chapter anywhere and I dont feel like reading a web novel... If I had to rate the first chapter, Id say it was pretty weird and wacky, but I cant really formulate an opinion on the thing since its just the first chapter

i had the luck of reading other 2 chaps, but its gone its weird..

 

[UnnamedPlayer]

Since someone ressurected this thread, let's recommend some stupid yuri comedy just in case :

• Who Decided That Blues Had to Be Cool!?
• You Are Totally In Love With Me, Aren't You?
• JK-chan and Her Male Classmate's Mom
• Love Flag Girls
• Pink Rush

Most of them are quite short, the first three are quick to read and have a "pixiv short manga" vibe, the last two are old manga fromthe 2000-2010 era.

 

[holicastral]

Let me drop in these!

• (the) heart of thorns
• my dearest nemesis
• sherbet above the sea of fog

next time i will recommend some old golds