@Meridis
"oh come on, it's the other way around."
You're being forced to watch the person your character is supposed to love sleep with another guy. You the player are supposed to want to be in a relationship with her, yet they're forcing you to watch her sleep with someone else. You're supposed to enjoy that? I guess so because why else would they include it? That's not "the other way around" that's straight up cucking.
"You aren't losing her, your taking her."
Relate back to my comment on intentionally ruining a relationship. Most people would not be into the idea of intentionally ruining someone's relationship. The game is basically trying to turn you to be that guy who gets the girl to cheat. That's not a good spot to be in by most standards.
"It sounds like it was the first VN where you go and NTR a guy. It was truly ahead of it's time..."
Even Mr. Fantastic couldn't stretch that far.
".but more seriously, that's still the kind of over reaction that the mc is talking about,"
No, it really isn't.
"that weirdness where these guys get offended at the thought that a female has previous experience like they are somehow retroactively cheating on you."
Reminder: The girl I (the character) intend to date is sleeping with her boyfriend in front of me. I'm supposed to just take that on the chin? Also It isn't a hard concept for most people to realize that they do not want to date a person/character that already has a boyfriend, nor do they want to be the direct intentional cause of that relationship being ruined. There's a reason society looks down on people who intentionally cheat worse than normal cheaters, my guy.
That guy in anime that hits on the Female Protagonists when he knows full well that they're into someone else? Those aren't harps being played in the background and that guy usually gets beaten by Karma.
Nobody wants to be that guy except edgy teenagers and people who have the moral standing of a rat.
"That sort of attitude from fans lowers the quality of VN stories"
Haha, if that's what ruins VNs then sign me up as a man of pure ruination.
"that's kinda one of the points of this story."
No, it isn't. Didn't you read the text? The MC is clearly in agreement with the idea of not wanting someone else be taken from you or watching someone you want get taken from you. And I quote directly from the story
"Even I would feel pissed if a character I really liked just got taken away"
The next part about him jumping on forums and crying all night is something you could argue is him exaggerating how some people approach that but the statement is genuine - People, the Main Character included, do not enjoy romance games where the romance is in danger of being destroyed by someone else. All the effort and affection you put into the game is then immediately destroyed. Nobody wants that and nobody wants to be the guy who causes that.