New comments access for everyone?

Group Leader
Joined
Sep 17, 2018
Messages
1,816
I had access to it since the beginning as an uploader, but even to this day it still lacks essential features to make it useful.
There are not enough reaction icons to express, well, a reaction. Sure the most important ones are there, but there's no reason not to copy the ones used in the forum and replace them with the MD cat.
I admit I haven't checked, but last time the maximum number of characters allowed was too low. It was something like 2000 characters and for comparison, only these two paragraphs are above 500 symbols. You can easily guess that any deeper analysis, like you see in many chapters, would either be impossible or require the "xitter threading" method of doing "1/n" and such.
And this leads to the next point, which is replies. Not like you can reply as it is (the button is disabled), but the narrow sidebar view doesn't really lend itself to anything but a linear view like the forum does. And sure, that is fine, as long as the new commenting system allows backlinks that would highlight/scroll up to the replied to comment, and have a way to quote the comment or part of it. Which brings us to...
These comments have no way to format text, at least not in a documented manner. I don't care about changing colours to single letters (it shouldn't be a user feature anyway, in my opinion), but being unable to emphasize words, either italics or boldface, or explicitly mark something as a quote, or add inline icons, which could be the MD cat, or hide something behind a spoiler mask, or make a word a link to some other place, really makes the whole thing nearly unusable.
By the way, this whole post is almost 1700 symbols (letters, numbers, punctuation) and it isn't even that well written.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 9, 2023
Messages
5,045
Will go in the Notices once it's considered stable enough for the aptly named 'stable' environment (i.e. not canary)

I mean...I suppose being live in production isn't technically stable so don't want to get folks hopes up, I guess? Don't they know that forever-EA is so 2010s?

I actually do see some limited engagement on individual chapters, so let's not write it off just yet. My general impression is that half of the comments are "whoa, plebs can do this now?" and not substantive. See how it's doing on day 30+ once the shiny novelty has worn off and the community has settled into a rhythm.

Unfortunate that you can't see chapter/series posts on your profile, alas.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 15, 2020
Messages
594
can someone explain what this is about?
where is the new forum?
What will happen to this one and all the comments accumulated in mdex throughout the years.
I lost all interest in using this website after they made changes to the comment section and i had to click extra just to go to the actual comments.
kind of out of the loop to any changes after that.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 9, 2024
Messages
465
can someone explain what this is about?
where is the new forum?
What will happen to this one and all the comments accumulated in mdex throughout the years.
I lost all interest in using this website after they made changes to the comment section and i had to click extra just to go to the actual comments.
kind of out of the loop to any changes after that.
i think you can still use forum it just that the comment section on main site is now open for everyone
and i also hate the fact that there another step to access the forum comment :worry:
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 15, 2020
Messages
594
i think you can still use forum it just that the comment section on main site is now open for everyone
and i also hate the fact that there another step to access the forum comment :worry:
I dont understand, wasn't it always open for everyone before?
Or do you mean people without a Mangadex account can NOW comment as well?
After the great purge, the only value this site had was the comment sections and another step is too much for me :haa:
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 9, 2024
Messages
465
I dont understand, wasn't it always open for everyone before?
Or do you mean people without a Mangadex account can NOW comment as well?
After the great purge, the only value this site had was the comment sections and another step is too much for me :haa:
before only supporter/donator or uploader can comment on the chapter i think
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 4, 2018
Messages
692
I dont understand, wasn't it always open for everyone before?
Or do you mean people without a Mangadex account can NOW comment as well?
After the great purge, the only value this site had was the comment sections and another step is too much for me :haa:
Still the same. The real comments were always in forum threads for chapters and still are, you still have that retarded extra step to get to them.
The only difference is the empty supporters only comment screen on the way there is still empty, but you now have the privilege to comment there now that it's open to us plebs! How generous!
For all intents and purposes nothing changed from how it was months ago. Don't worry about it.

Like Hicleric said, we'll have to wait and see how it shakes out, but my impression so far is that despite deliberately making it inconvenient to access the forums to comment, many people still choose to do so.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top