Nidome no Natsu, Nidoto Aenai Kimi - Vol. 1 Ch. 2 - Decision

Group Leader
Joined
Oct 9, 2019
Messages
24
@Bladestone These events are narrated by Satoshi. After learning about all of this, probably when bringing her to the hospital, which is why he says that he "had no idea". I don't think it would make sense, neither if talking about the transplant because it's only one of the narrated events, nor about both diseases because in that case, no one else had "any idea" about her current condition.
Satoshi narrated everything up to chapter 3 at least, so I don't see why Rin would have narrated that one part. The flashback background is missing indeed, but I think it's a miss from the author. Rin is also shown to be pretty intense in her desire to go to school again, however it is shown two panels later that she does not have that kind of strength.
She is very weak when Satoshi visits her, presumably the day after the incident : it wouldn't make sense for him to wait a long time before visiting her. However she's been hospitalized for quite some time for her transplant, so if he went to visit her often (assuming the transplant was after their first time meeting), he shouldn't be too surprised to see her so weak.

Literally, it would be something like "Frequenting you would be fun for sure..." (without romantic meaning, at least in her case).

Thank you for your kind words. No problem, these chapters are honestly pretty time consuming but this is fun and very interesting.
I'm also worried I might have translated some things wrong or written things that made no sense, so talking about this might help me fix some mistakes or understand parts of the story better.
 
Active member
Joined
Feb 16, 2018
Messages
280
@Holrik

Sorry, yes Satoshi narrated I got the names mixed up (still haven't got the character names down). That does make my post more confusing...

The time frame is a little unclear, likely because the author wanted to surprise us. Maybe it will be cleared up better later.
 
Group Leader
Joined
Oct 9, 2019
Messages
24
@Bladestone Oh, I see. Recap on the characters : Shimehara Satoshi (MC) and Moriyama Rin (girl). There's also "school prez", which I mistakenly named "class rep" in previous chapters. By the way, these chapters have been fixed, but I will add a note on chapter 3 for clarity.

Also, i just remembered Satoshi mentioning on chapter 2 page 27 that Rin already knows about her condition. He isn't speaking about the heart disease because the transplant would cure her. On chapter 3, Rin knowing about her condition is also hinted at. And we know for sure that the new condition was discovered at the same time she had her transplant. I really do think the transplant happened before Rin going to school.
 
Active member
Joined
Feb 16, 2018
Messages
280
@Holrik

I agree now that the transplant happened before they all met, I just thought the author presented it poorly. There should have been a separate chapter for her past I think.
 
Group Leader
Joined
Oct 9, 2019
Messages
24
@Bladestone Well I think a whole chapter is a bit too much, considering that the manga only has 10 chapters. But as you mentioned, they should at least have put on the black background as they used for other flashbacks.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Oct 5, 2019
Messages
1,160
Meh, Clannad kinda spoiled me rotten with its soul wrenching drama. I hardly feel sad about characters anymore.
 
Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2019
Messages
366
6 months? maybe its not to late to cure her diseases? or for the drama sake they will continue with a "default" route where she will die at the end?😕
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 20, 2023
Messages
4,420
So this time he doesn't want to get involved with her romantically but give her good memories in school, which will make her stop the treatment anyway and die.

Could make her dislike school, given she is such a cheerful and stubborn person, might be a hard thing to do.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top