Nito no Taidana Isekai Shoukougun ~Saijaku Shoku "Healer" nano ni Saikyou wa Cheat desu ka?~ - Ch. 30.1 - The Day a Country Disappear

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 7, 2023
Messages
196
Honestly i still don't know what it have to do with justice you want to convey to people. Since i never talk nor think what he did was justice in the first place. Just a revenge get delivered.

And Batman moral code is the most easiest example of not killing villain when it's necessary are always ended up with more casualties once said villain manage to break free. So rather than stopping said tragedy to happen again, he just delayed it.

That why i said it's it's great but also flawed at the same time. Since not everyone would turn on a new leaf with a bit of punching and locked up.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 7, 2019
Messages
1,153
I know I waste my time but I write it anyways: please look up the word self-righteous because shallow people like you (and the other people like you among the commenters) making up the jeering crowd around the proverbial gallows are the pots calling the kettle black. The fact that you people use the word justice yet lack the moral framework necessary to understand that word suggest that it is just a pretext so you can get your fix of sadistic violence. Any excuse is good enough, really.
Nobody cares about your clearly religious motivations.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 12, 2023
Messages
547
Violence is the best way, as always.
To those "moral preachers": Heck off to the corner of the universe before wanking with your "moral values".
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 15, 2023
Messages
361
Justice is just civilized version of revenge. It's tit for tat, but carried out by third party, and following clearly defined rules known ahead of time. "You do X, and the punishment for it will be Y." The impartiality, the prior clarity are all there to prevent escalation, while still providing the punishment (and the disincentive to do it in the first place).

Masamune is doing it personally, in response to what was done to him. That's revenge. And he's right to do it.

The question is whether he will go too far. And if his goal is to wipe out his entire class -- that's too far. Punishment must be proportional to the crime and the culpability. And yet... He is right that the rest of the class does bear some degree of culpability for his bullying.

Dragon's Heart is essentially an extrajudicial justice group. I.e. vigilantes. They're not doing it in response to wrongs done to themselves, but rather wrongs done to other people. One can argue that they're going beyond pure justice. However, some of the "innocents" that they're killing are people that knew about the crimes, and could have done something about the crimes, but didn't. Guilt by inaction. However, even that shouldn't apply to children. At best, you can only justify this as an action like war, in which innocents necessarily die.

A complicating factor here is this comes from Japan, which is less driven by morality and more driven by purity. So it this series ends up seeing a problem with Masamune, it's more likely to be associated with his having been "tainted" by the actions that he takes. (E.g. consider Demon Slayer Train Arc where we get a very clear picture of how insanely pure the hero's soul is -- i.e. it's not just that he's nice, but rather that his soul is pure.) Japanese authors usually don't look at "justice" the same way the west does.

I'll note that there's a lot of nuance and variance in this work. E.g. look at Reyd Black in the Reynault kingdom. Masamune directly equates him to Saeki (Masamune's number one bully). Reyd just straight up tries to murder Masamune just because Masamune is an unknown. And this guy is the number two "white knight" of the kingdom. Does he get punished for this? Not at all. So what's that say about the kingdom that employs him? At best they're realists who find bastards like Reyd to be useful.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 14, 2019
Messages
1,860
12vdyjnzlul1uq.gif
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 6, 2019
Messages
740
So, the MC has lowered himself to be the same type of trash as the people that threw him in the pit. He got his petty revenge. What now? The End?
He did not lower himself, the opposite, he has now elevated himself to the pinnacle of JUSTICE.
¿petty?, pffft, it's JUST revenge.
There is no "authority" that would do anything to those two as there isn't anyone above them legally, so someone has to rise to pass divine judgement on the scum Belkas for what they did.

He Judge Dredded that bitch.

¿what now?, he needs to continue going Judge Dredd on the rest of the shitstains
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Jan 21, 2023
Messages
117
Mass-murder garnished with cruelty is the new justice, huh? In a roundabout way it reminds one of that Mark Twain quote.
Said people that where murder literally took over thousands of they own people did a bunch of fucked up shit to them just to get them to the point they can use them all to summon the MC and his class. Miss me with this high horse nonsense and sit down
 
Power Uploader
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
517
He finally had his revenge, but now that that's done, what's left for him to do with this story? Thanks for the chapter.
Revenge on some of his school mates…

honestly I’d be surprised if they don’t jump right into it. That said. Who is there to manipulate them into attacking “Nito”? I’m sure there is someone? I can’t suppose we won’t see at least one complete idiot who was I love with the princess father the others into a suicide attack of sorts?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top