Onna no Karada ga Iya nano de Mune o Torimashita

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 12, 2024
Messages
336
This is definitely an interesting concept, and I'm actually quite intrigued with the story so far. Everyone probably has some moments of doubt with their own foundation in one gender or another, but I've never seen too many in-depth explanations of the process like this one. It's also just nice overall to get some non-binary representation, since I feel like their voices are often left behind when it comes to talking about gender.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Nov 4, 2024
Messages
545
An ex boyfriend of mine (he was FtM) had already had this done when I was seeing him. Apart from the noticeable scarring it was effective and he was glad that he could go shirtless during the Summer.

I'm glad this mentions about how expensive it is to be Trans, people frequently ignore the financial cost of transitioning. Then of course there are the gatekeepers and peoples reactions you have to deal. Cis people really have no idea how much it sucks to be Trans :(
 
Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2023
Messages
18
I’m sorry to say, but if you think the solution to concerns over your sex is cutting off your genitals/organs, you have a mental illness. You need therapy and counseling.
I’m curious if you think the same about a woman who decides to get breast implants because she feels it will improve her figure. If that’s allowed I don’t see why this shouldn’t be. Especially when you consider the fact that people are far more likely to regret a plastic surgery they got for aesthetic purposes rather than gender affirming purposes. Gender affirming care is not only a want, but a necessity for those that are trans. It’s their body, it doesn’t affect you
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Mar 14, 2024
Messages
92
I’m curious if you think the same about a woman who decides to get breast implants because she feels it will improve her figure. If that’s allowed I don’t see why this shouldn’t be. Especially when you consider the fact that people are far more likely to regret a plastic surgery they got for aesthetic purposes rather than gender affirming purposes. Gender affirming care is not only a want, but a necessity for those that are trans. It’s their body, it doesn’t affect you
Well I don’t advocate for breast implants, so this argument is null. Please don’t sugar coat self-mutilation as “care”, it’s vile. If I see a person attempting to harm themself, I will not be a bystander. If someone is struggling with their gender, they can receive therapy from a medical professional to help overcome their dissonance.
 
Joined
Jun 8, 2025
Messages
2
I’m happy to have read this. As an Asian nonbinary individual with similar transition goals this was highly informative and relatable (like the part about one’s ability to use a hot spring post surgery). I hope others can read this material as purely anecdotal and listen rather than judge the author’s experience(especially since they stated plainly in the epilogue that it wasn’t an endorsement, like come on! How more obvious do they need to be?) and thank you to the scanulation team for their efforts as well. 🙇🏻🙇🏻🙇🏻
 
Joined
Jun 3, 2026
Messages
23
Well I don’t advocate for breast implants, so this argument is null. Please don’t sugar coat self-mutilation as “care”, it’s vile. If I see a person attempting to harm themself, I will not be a bystander. If someone is struggling with their gender, they can receive therapy from a medical professional to help overcome their dissonance.
Genuinely wut? They weren't saying you did, just that you probably don't give a shit about what cis people do to their bodies (and it seems that's true). It's a sign that you don't actually care about people with dysphoria when you only apply your reasoning to them. Do you know how many barriers there are to people receiving gender affirming surgery? They take the choice very seriously and it's typically the last step in a transition, if it even happens at all. Do you seriously think that they don't go to therapists? The idea that you genuinely care about trans and nonbinary people is hard to believe when you use common transphobic talking points and clearly haven't done an ounce of research.

Did you not notice how the person you responded to mentioned the immensely low regret rates. There are higher regret rates for knee surgery for goodness sake. It's almost like they make these major decisions only when they've thought about it long and hard, also after therapy.

You obviously care about people getting surgery that alters sexual characteristics. I wonder if you also vocally fight against the surgery given to intersex infants without their consent to make them conform to a binary. Or do you act as a bystander and not do anything or even talk about it. If you genuinely think you support trans and nonbinary people, I suggest you actually do research and get out of transphobic echo chambers. I doubt you'll respond to this rationally and with an open mind, but hey, maybe you'll do even the slightest research and at least use better arguments next time.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top