Orenchi ni Kita Onna Kishi to Inakagurashi Surukotoninatta Ken - Vol. 3 Ch. 20 - Hospitalization

Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Apr 3, 2018
Messages
363
This is what exactly I’m looking for in an isekai, the government involved, how the slider have to deal with this, any potential battles vs the modern. Very bold of the author to choose this path and not somehow forget the realism parts of the genre like other stories out there.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 13, 2018
Messages
1,930
Jerk, what's wrong with letting her have her third helping?
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Mar 11, 2019
Messages
467
@kn1000a Glad you're enjoying it. This was not what I came here for. I like more fluffy "oh my god, what's this 'TV' thing?" reverse isekai, and the sort of stuff this manga started with, where there were misunderstandings and cultural collisions between the otherworlder and modern society. (Thermae Romae does a great job at this, although its full reverse isekai arc can only be found on other sites...)

I'm not enjoying this arc of "great, you're now a government test subject" (although they foreshadowed it pretty hard).

not somehow forget the realism

If this is being realistic, then shit's about to get really dark. This girl's under unconditional quarantine, regularly subjected to intrusive medical tests, under the mere suspicion that she may be carrying an unknown disease - one they haven't managed to find ANY evidence of after multiple blood tests and other medical examinations.

And, if we're going for realism, being under medical quarantine isn't like being arrested: you still get to use a phone, since germs can't travel through the telecom systems. Now, she doesn't really know about phones. She doesn't have any idea what her legal rights are. She's been separated from everyone she knows who would know about those things - and she hasn't gotten a SINGLE FUCKING CALL from anyone else (main male MC, and the inspector chick) since being quarantined? I'd assume both of them would at least try to contact her.

That's fishy as fuck, and puts a VERY dark spin on this whole scenario.

If the author's doing realism, merely the fact that she hasn't been allowed or offered even phone contact with the other people she knows is damning evidence that the confinement is intended to be permanent, and the main goal here is studying her. (This was also baited by the "they're totally in the same facility you are" line last chapter, which I'm inclined to disbelieve.)

I'm a bit irritated that a nice fluffy story about this strange girl from another world became this, but I'll be absolutely incendiary if the author either finishes this arc with a "then the government let her go back - no problems here! (despite everything they've done)" or a darker ending.

@WillLi Unfortunately, it's not irrational. Considering that she's displayed abilities that defy the laws of thermodynamics and conservation of energy (some of the basic concepts our entire understanding of physics are built around), it's not irrational to think whatever plague she may or may not be carrying completely defies normal understanding as well. Ironically, this means that their quarantine procedures aren't good enough, since they don't have an idea what they're up against - a magical disease could simply spread by people's auras touching or something, and hazmat suits can't do jack about that.

And it means that they can't ever be sure she's not carrying something. They don't even know if she could degrade someone's health in the opposite way she's healing mice.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
737
@EaterOfBooks If they actually were thinking like that then they'd realize all the testing and quarantine are absolutely pointless as well. Because even then they likely couldn't detect it at all. That's why this is 'irrational' not because of we could go to endless lengths to say "well since magic is involved..." but because there is no actual thought from their perspective on what they're doing. From a logical point of view you have someone who posses magic, and they haven't done a single thing to make sure she doesn't go insane form how they're treating her. They're just -asking- to get their place burned down. It's all fear with no rational judgment on their part, no -real- precautions, just listed safety procedures.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 20, 2018
Messages
2,965
"hurr durr I'll report my otherwordly waifu to the government, what could possibly go wrong?"

Nice work, fucktard. Should have kept her secret even if she unleashed a plague that wiped out 99% of humanity.

waifu > the entire world
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Jul 3, 2018
Messages
862
Hmmmm, yup, good thing I read the comments before the chapter. I'd just get pissed at the incompetence of the government here. Guess I'll keep checking the comments as more chapters come out until I see signs it's getting better like I did with Blue Hearts.
 
Joined
Jul 22, 2018
Messages
31
this manga soo flat since early chapter. Sekkaku Cheat have better plot than this manga.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
865
The author just dug a huge hole, there's no way they can go back to being normal without some bullshit reasons about the magic thing.l
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Apr 3, 2018
Messages
363
@EaterOfBooks I don't mind a dark spin on the story. In fact, this manga would be even better if it went that way.

Lots of isekai are about self-fulfillment. Lots of them are about nice fluffy and adventuring fantasy. Lots of them are also edgy as fuck. But there are 0 that do the realistic mindfuck right.

A manga about the absolutely worst case scenario will be a new reach for me. Let her fight the government, let her break out, let the MC helped her uselessly along the way, let her struggle until she somehow can find the way back - maybe a timewarp portal that periodically open because of the time-space disruption. Heck, let her bring him back as well since he is helping an escapee against the JP government. I need more sci-fi, and this story has a high potential for it.

It's unlikely the author can make this series deviated so much more though. It's unexplored territory. So far what the author has pulled have been VERY niche inside the genre. Count how many isekai that actually offer the interaction between real issues (disease outbreak, countermeasures, quarantine). I can think of GATE, which doesn't even do this whole government x fantasy thing right. This manga on the other hand, has started out very typical of reverse isekai but turned out nicely. The realism element makes this isekai closer to science fiction than fantasy, and I love it.

Not to say this is some godtier shit. It definitely doesn't do well trying to switch from light-hearted isekai into this serious mood. There are also some forced turns of event that shouldn't have happen in the first place, simply because it's logically strange for them to happen. I also want more exposition on the background of their characters so their actions matter a lot more. Either way, it's alright despite all my hype for it. Needs better execution.
 
Joined
Oct 31, 2018
Messages
5
Just checked the Web-Novel:
Farmstuff will continue once she gets released from the hospital.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 18, 2018
Messages
3,542
@Antairan: That. Just what you wrote.

And as others stated before. The experiments are necessary, but the unusual cold treatment and psychological isolation, that in itself creates a threatening atmosphere is not helping. The author just needs it for drama and that's too easy to see through. And it will either lead into a very dark situation or end with a stupid asspull, like "Oh, we just let her go to see what happens next."
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top