Osananajimi Kanojo no Morahara ga Hidoin de Zetsuen Sengen shite Yatta ~Jibun Rashiku Ikiru Koto ni Shitara, Naze ka Tonari no Seki no Kakure Bishouj…

[UdenEmpati]

That's what's being implied though. People keep saying she needs some sort or karmic backlash, or justice or something, but apparently what's currntly happening to her is too much.
We all usually stick to "an eye for an eye" when it comes to punishment. A crime requires a befitting punishment, right? But all of a sudden her actions having dire consequences is not something she deserves? Think about it, she manipulated this guy into breaking the law for her sake...it's obvious he'd be willing to take that extra step and break the law again, or go even further to get what he wants. She dug her own grave, but I doubt anything serious will come from it. It'd be nice if the author went ahead with it, even if it's off camera, but I doubt it'll happen.

So - usually "justice" would involve some sort of recompense for the person who was wronged or hurt.
What about this happening to Hanabi, provides restitution for Souma? What about her being raped by this delinquent, and then potentially trafficked into prostitution to pay back some exorbitant sum as blackmail, offers a sense of justice to Souma?

That is why this is being condemned, at least in my mind. If Hanabi is going to see consequences for what she did to Souma, then it should be Souma who sets the acts or penalties that he deems appropriate to feel Hanabi has undergone the necessary trials to be forgiven, or at least see the scales balanced for himself.

And the way this story's being written thus far, either Souma now has to get involved because Hanabi didn't go to him herself in the first place, or she actually gets pulled into this black hole of exploitation and suffering that doesn't affect Souma whatsoever, potentially to the point she either dies or is so broken that death might be a mercy.

(being trafficked into prostitution as the delinquent is "suggesting" to Hanabi is horrific, and I'm kinda perplexed as to why you feel like it's being unfairly cited as "too far" here, if you knew what all it actually entailed for the people subjected to it. Souma is still alive and healthy and recovering and doing quite well. Hanabi, if this went through the sort of process and conclusion it does in the real world, would be lucky if she ends up dead.)

And to you last point - it's anyone's guess. Unless someone happens to be wandering through that park at midnight who sees what's going down and stops it, Hanabi's probably getting raped in the next scene, or off-screen if we're jumping to the next day. She better hope Souma gets wind of what's happening before she starts getting set up with Johns, because if it gets going for too long, there won't be a Hanabi for Souma to get justice from.

 

[jojoka]

She got her foot twisted backwards exposed for her bullying and suspended btw and people want more to happen to her lawl and this guy already said she's acting way different now.
Obviously she's had her punishment which is ongoing but y'all fellas just want retribution in reality.

 

[ironhant]

She got her foot twisted backwards exposed for her bullying and suspended btw and people want more to happen to her lawl and this guy already said she's acting way different now.
Obviously she's had her punishment which is ongoing but y'all fellas just want retribution in reality.

I could probably just skipped this part and instead have some legal ramifications without that mercy BS and done a minor timeskip where they finish school and enter college have some new people he could help get out of their situation instead

 

[DaBlackMamba]

“He touched my thigh! This is TORTURE compared to destroying an innocent friends life for an unrecognized sadistic fetish! Woe is me!”

You....you think that's what people are talking about? No way you're that sense

 

[DaBlackMamba]

That's what's being implied though. People keep saying she needs some sort or karmic backlash, or justice or something, but apparently what's currntly happening to her is too much.
We all usually stick to "an eye for an eye" when it comes to punishment. A crime requires a befitting punishment, right? But all of a sudden her actions having dire consequences is not something she deserves? Think about it, she manipulated this guy into breaking the law for her sake...it's obvious he'd be willing to take that extra step and break the law again, or go even further to get what he wants. She dug her own grave, but I doubt anything serious will come from it. It'd be nice if the author went ahead with it, even if it's off camera, but I doubt it'll happen.

Hey buddy, idk how to tell you this, but NO she doesn't deserve to be raped or sex trafficked. I feel like I shouldn't need to say something that obvious, but some of y'all are weird AF.

 

[Chaos47]

Hey buddy, idk how to tell you this, but NO she doesn't deserve to be raped or sex trafficked. I feel like I shouldn't need to say something that obvious, but some of y'all are weird AF.

So WHAT would in your humble opinion warrant such fate for her? I love it when people act like sex crimes are the worst possible outcome for anyone. It even seems society looks at it as a crime worse than murder itself. It's insane. Physical, mental, and traumatizing abuse. That's what she dealt. It'd only be fair if she suffers the same level of pain she inflicted. What Im getting at here is that the author, with his endless wisdom, chose to depict our main bad guy as a defenseless young girl in trouble to get out of the obligation to write a proper comeupance or redemption arc for her. It's working. Many readers are already seeing her as a defacto victim instead of the devil we've been following since chapter one. Gotta hand it to the writter, he seems to know how to eotionally manipulate his audience. I can't even call him a talentless hack anymore, good job.

 

[Shevar]

🍿

 

[Sunji27]

I don't like where this is going but it's her fault for sharing that video about MC








Thank you for the TL

 

[Chaos47]

So - usually "justice" would involve some sort of recompense for the person who was wronged or hurt.
What about this happening to Hanabi, provides restitution for Souma? What about her being raped by this delinquent, and then potentially trafficked into prostitution to pay back some exorbitant sum as blackmail, offers a sense of justice to Souma?

That is why this is being condemned, at least in my mind. If Hanabi is going to see consequences for what she did to Souma, then it should be Souma who sets the acts or penalties that he deems appropriate to feel Hanabi has undergone the necessary trials to be forgiven, or at least see the scales balanced for himself.

Your idea of justice is plain wrong. Recompense for the victim? Justice for Soma? What are you talking about? Does a victim of murder GAIN anything from whatever justice is done to their killer? Justice is nothing but the "cause" to an "effect" dealt by society or an individual. It has nothing to do with victim recompense. Also, a victim doesn't even chose what kind of justice is served unless they go out of their way to implement THEIR own justice. It's a complicated subject that has little to do with this actual story and the people writing it.

 

[DaBlackMamba]

So WHAT would in your humble opinion warrant such fate for her? I love it when people act like sex crimes are the worst possible outcome for anyone. It even seems society looks at it as a crime worse than murder itself. It's insane. Physical, mental, and traumatizing abuse. That's what she dealt. It'd only be fair if she suffers the same level of pain she inflicted. What Im getting at here is that the author, with his endless wisdom, chose to depict our main bad guy as a defenseless young girl in trouble to get out of the obligation to write a proper comeupance or redemption arc for her. It's working. Many readers are already seeing her as a defacto victim instead of the devil we've been following since chapter one. Gotta hand it to the writter, he seems to know how to eotionally manipulate his audience. I can't even call him a talentless hack anymore, good job.

Sex crimes ARE the worst possible outcome, not including outright murder. The only thing insane here is your mindset, what kind of person thinks a teenager deserves to be raped?

Yes she is currently a victim, just because she's a bad person doesn't mean she can't be a victim. Like I feel like I'm talking to a crazy person right now.

 

[Chaos47]

Sex crimes ARE the worst possible outcome, not including outright murder. The only thing insane here is your mindset, what kind of person thinks a teenager deserves to be raped?

Yes she is currently a victim, just because she's a bad person doesn't mean she can't be a victim. Like I feel like I'm talking to a crazy person right now.

Okay, I disagree. There are things far worse than sex crimes. And being a teenager does not make someone imune to justice or bad experiences. I would not say she deserves it, because at the end, WHO can claim to have that right? But I'm not going to pretend that the author didn't write this character as an idoot whose actions led them to their current situation. Wether or not she deserves it, she got herself into this position through a series of dumb decisions. I'm an abvocate of cause and effect, you can't complain of getting burned if you stick your hand in the fire.

 

[UdenEmpati]

Okay, I disagree. There are things far worse than sex crimes. And being a teenager does not make someone imune to justice or bad experiences. I would not say she deserves it, because at the end, WHO can claim to have that right? But I'm not going to pretend that the author didn't write this character as an idoot whose actions led them to their current situation. Wether or not she deserves it, she got herself into this position through a series of dumb decisions. I'm an abvocate of cause and effect, you can't complain of getting burned if you stick your hand in the fire.

then you're entitled to your opinion, I guess.

It's wild to justify rape and trafficking of a minor as "consequences of actions taken", but I guess you're correct that this is what the author's doing. Doesn't mean the people here calling it bullshit are wrong, but I guess that's where diverge on the topic, so.

Can't say I'm in line with you and your train of thought here, but as I can simply walk away and stop paying attention to his conversation after I hint "post reply", I'll just leave you to whatever it is you think you're defending and leave you to the consequences your decision invites.

 

[SomeBoredGuy]

it's deserved, but unrelated
like if she got ran over by a car

Being blackmailed into sex is never deserved homie

 

[Jampolo]

Kirigaya is a sad, pathetic loser, and it shows

 

[habla]

Being blackmailed into sex is never deserved homie

shouldn't have filmed herself sexually humiliating a child broski

 

[Chaos47]

I could probably just skipped this part and instead have some legal ramifications without that mercy BS and done a minor timeskip where they finish school and enter college have some new people he could help get out of their situation instead

Okay, I get it, you are a better writter than the author. But if we did it your way, where would we go to find another dumpster fire of shitty writing?

In all honesty, I agree though, there were many other ways this could've been written that didn't involved surprise blackmail as a plot device. A well placed time skip would've done wonders while moving the story forward. Oh well.

 

[Wonderlands]

i'm dropping 😀

 

[gggadget]

Okay well that video was more than I thought...

So it's a child exploitation video that the blond fuckboy is threatening to... distribute?? In order to get another minor to exploit herself?

Jail
Fucking jail
Now
No trial no nothing
Right away

 

[http_son1]

This shit shouldve ended at chapter 30, because wtf...

 

[TeadyBear123]

Girl has been a scumbag since elementary school wtf, I can’t even feel bad if she gets gangbanged like it’s honestly just deserved at this point