Otome Game no Hametsu Flag shika nai Akuyaku Reijou ni Tensei shite shimatta...
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
- Joined
- Mar 13, 2018
- Messages
- 21
I want more chapters please make the translations faster <3 and also hoping you give this manga a proper ending unlike the LN version still waiting for update.
This is... pretty boring.
There's no tension.
The story started out with the protagonist wanting to avoid getting a bad end, but the problem is that she's already done it.
She managed to effortlessly change her relations with the entire cast, and that, without needing the slightest bit of character development.
The author could've just introduced a higher force who's actively trying to make the events from the story reflect what happens in the game.
Or he could've given Katarina a flaw that she would have to overcome in order to achieve her goal.
Anything that would've challenged the main character.
It's quite frustrating, the only thing preventing her to realize that it's nearly impossible for her right now to reach a dead end is her own denseness.
Additionally, the cast has neither interesting personalities, motivations(aside from the romance subplot), nor problems to overcome.
This look like a bad slice of life show.
I'll stick around to see if it gets better but I'm not optimist.
There's no tension.
The story started out with the protagonist wanting to avoid getting a bad end, but the problem is that she's already done it.
She managed to effortlessly change her relations with the entire cast, and that, without needing the slightest bit of character development.
The author could've just introduced a higher force who's actively trying to make the events from the story reflect what happens in the game.
Or he could've given Katarina a flaw that she would have to overcome in order to achieve her goal.
Anything that would've challenged the main character.
It's quite frustrating, the only thing preventing her to realize that it's nearly impossible for her right now to reach a dead end is her own denseness.
Additionally, the cast has neither interesting personalities, motivations(aside from the romance subplot), nor problems to overcome.
This look like a bad slice of life show.
I'll stick around to see if it gets better but I'm not optimist.
Active member
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2018
- Messages
- 153
Wait, isn't there another manga with almost the same premise, but it turned into chocolate?
Member
- Joined
- Apr 2, 2018
- Messages
- 492
ADORABLE.
@Asta
Dude... Look at the tags, what did you expect? it is just some goofy fun with a dense MC. And, although there are plot holes, the character development is present, you just don't like. Which is okay. It is not made for everyone, but having it not fall into your taste, doesn't mean it is bad. And vice-versa.
@Asta
Dude... Look at the tags, what did you expect? it is just some goofy fun with a dense MC. And, although there are plot holes, the character development is present, you just don't like. Which is okay. It is not made for everyone, but having it not fall into your taste, doesn't mean it is bad. And vice-versa.
Contributor
- Joined
- Jan 22, 2018
- Messages
- 2,458
Really calling her a black hole isn't just a statement about her attractiveness. But then again we really need the other pov chapters for the rest of the cast.
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2018
- Messages
- 3
Regarding Maria's mother, we get her point of view in the light novel. The translation of that can be read here: https://omegaharem.wordpress.com/2015/06/23/destruction-flag-otome-chapter-27/.
the TL;DR version of it is that since Maria was born with magic, something which is almost exclusive to nobles, murmurs arose in the village that her mother had been cheating on her husband with a noble. This escalated to the point where her husband would spend less and less time at home, effectively abandoning the family. As a result, the mother started to feel disdain towards Maria for having been born, even though she realizes that it's not something Maria could have prevented. Because of this conflict of emotions inside of her, she stopped looking her daughter in the eyes, fearing the possibility that Maria might hate her.
the TL;DR version of it is that since Maria was born with magic, something which is almost exclusive to nobles, murmurs arose in the village that her mother had been cheating on her husband with a noble. This escalated to the point where her husband would spend less and less time at home, effectively abandoning the family. As a result, the mother started to feel disdain towards Maria for having been born, even though she realizes that it's not something Maria could have prevented. Because of this conflict of emotions inside of her, she stopped looking her daughter in the eyes, fearing the possibility that Maria might hate her.
@MarceloYuri
"Dude... Look at the tags, what did you expect? "
Nothing. The tags are mostly irrelevant.
What do matter, however, is the author skill!.
Even a harem-isekai would be a pleasure to read if it were to be handled by the likes of Togashi.
I came to this manga with no expectations and I ended up sightly disappointed.
" And, although there are plot holes, the character development is present, you just don't like. Which is okay. "
Character development for Katarina ? Where ?
Even for the side characters, their problems are solved right after they're introduced which make it hard for the reader to be emotionally invested in what happens.
"It is not made for everyone, but having it not fall into your taste, doesn't mean it is bad. And vice-versa"
That's flat out wrong.
All of the thing I mentioned could be integrated in the story without changing the chill, slice of life aspect of the series.
My problem with this manga isn't what it's trying to do, but it's execution, which is why I said : "This look like a bad slice of life show."
It's fine if you disagree with me, but dismissing what I said by saying it's just not up my alley, even though I did point out the manga's shortcomings as my reason, is quite weird.
"Dude... Look at the tags, what did you expect? "
Nothing. The tags are mostly irrelevant.
What do matter, however, is the author skill!.
Even a harem-isekai would be a pleasure to read if it were to be handled by the likes of Togashi.
I came to this manga with no expectations and I ended up sightly disappointed.
" And, although there are plot holes, the character development is present, you just don't like. Which is okay. "
Character development for Katarina ? Where ?
Even for the side characters, their problems are solved right after they're introduced which make it hard for the reader to be emotionally invested in what happens.
"It is not made for everyone, but having it not fall into your taste, doesn't mean it is bad. And vice-versa"
That's flat out wrong.
All of the thing I mentioned could be integrated in the story without changing the chill, slice of life aspect of the series.
My problem with this manga isn't what it's trying to do, but it's execution, which is why I said : "This look like a bad slice of life show."
It's fine if you disagree with me, but dismissing what I said by saying it's just not up my alley, even though I did point out the manga's shortcomings as my reason, is quite weird.
Similar threads
