Saikyou Yuusha Party wa Ai ga Shiritai - Ch. 17

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
2,462
If the manga can finally decide what it wants to be, that would be really great. So far every other panel (not even chapter) had a different flow. I can't see this surviving axe with this weird as fuck progress. You literally can not tell what the hell is going on due to tonal whiplash every 3 seconds.
it jumped the shark from their main joke too fast, when did MC gave up trying to be popular... sadly author made a good premise without knowing what to do with it... like a certain tall girl with chadder Nishinoya.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 12, 2020
Messages
9,119
Not sure how the author plans to roll this back into a romance after the reveal that the FMC is a child in an adult's body, and the MC thinks of her as such too.

Kind of burned the bridge for any believable romance to develop there.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 23, 2023
Messages
227
Seems there are more secrets that are in the background, Riyo is still speculated as a "Vessel" while I think Toifa has some manipulated memories in her. Also DAMN SHE IS BIG (you know who)
 
Supporter
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
679
Everyone is so confused about the fly we are just going to gloss over the elf getting arrested in their underwear for the previous chapter. :D
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 13, 2023
Messages
1,876
I don't get what just happened, but at this point the mage is the only human in the party <^<
 
Banned
Joined
Mar 23, 2020
Messages
1,064
Everyone is so confused about the fly we are just going to gloss over the elf getting arrested in their underwear for the previous chapter. :D
well ya know... she's packing more than what a female got and tried to enter a female's bath so of course they had to restrain her especially since she is known to be seductress...
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 10, 2023
Messages
677
Thanks for chap
Putting the secretive plot and " Up to your imagination " Part of the fly x toifa aside.

Priest is confusing lol, asks mc to worry on her(him) and then sighs when he pulls an ikemen line.


😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣A squatter, freaking manga has a squatter now🤣😂
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 10, 2023
Messages
677
Everyone is so confused about the fly we are just going to gloss over the elf getting arrested in their underwear for the previous chapter. :D
If you paid close attention 2 chaps ago(and the previous hero arc) , it's implied she had multiple sexual relationships with different people and seduced a lot of girls.

So her entering the female bath can be seen as definitely having some perverted intentions(she's not even hiding it when asked btw)
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 10, 2018
Messages
107
I was confused as everyone re: Toifa

But I'm thinking either related to secret backstory to be revealed or maybe when she became a giant from the potion? maybe the whole transformation was actually irreversible but healer did (sorry forgot the name) to restore toifa... but because it's not an injury, healing magic can't be used.

just wildly taking a stab at it

gotta agree, if the author sticked with the initial premise and romantic tension with sayu and the mage as they solve the issue with overpopulation of isekai heroes, it might actually be super good. i think the twists would work out better if it wasn't immediately after one another.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 10, 2018
Messages
107
i think that did more damage than healing tbh
LOL

coming back to this thread, i had a thought maybe toifa's been dead all along hence why healer needs to stay with the party. seems like no one has a reason to actually stay together except sayu to mage guy.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 30, 2018
Messages
3,601
I have no idea what's happening in the shadow on page 17. I'm going to assume fly stabbed Toifa's brain with his proboscis, which is twice as messed up now that I'm writing it. It would be time-reversible. He doesn't seem to be the main person causing humans to rampage.

Little Priest is going to have to carry the group here. He's holding the not-balloon... Pop it. Pop it now.
My assumption is that Fly is some flavor of traitor to the demon king and is doing plotting stuff. We saw Shayu's glowing mark after the ominous "she's not immune from the thing that's turning heroes" mention, and with Toifa looking up to Shayu as an idol that's probably gonna be used as some kind of trigger/control to force Shayu into "activating" against her will, or something.

Not sure how the author plans to roll this back into a romance after the reveal that the FMC is a child in an adult's body, and the MC thinks of her as such too.

Kind of burned the bridge for any believable romance to develop there.
I don't know why people are so focused on this, honestly. She's not a child in an adult's body, she's a homunculus that was made 5 years ago. She even states that not only physiologically, but psychologically, she's 20+.

If I made a clone of myself that walked, talked, and thought 100% like me, I don't think anyone would scream about "but that's a child!" when they can't even tell which one's me or the clone made 5 minutes ago. That's the situation this manga is in right now.

All that was stated was that she was cloned 5 years ago. Does the demon king go "oh no my 5 year old daughter!" as a joke? Yeah, and then it's immediately shot down by her. It's not even like this is an "oh look, it's a 9000 year old loli vampire" situation, because she's a 6 foot tall brick house. I think most people would be fine banging an android that was manufactured 5 years ago but was otherwise a "sentient adult AI", too.

I would agree if this was a Shield Hero Naofumi + Raphtalia situation, where she's legitimately a child in an adult body (and even explains that only the body grew up). But that's not the situation here.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top