Sengoku Komachi Kuroutan - Ch. 104 - Heavy Drinker

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 5, 2019
Messages
169
That... is actually an interesting idea, one that I don't think was ever said, but despite having read a lot of the comment sections on this manga... I can't say I know everything people have said.
Sorry if I sounded pretentious with my choice of words, I just wanted to know if someone else found more clues if that was the case. Until now all the transported people that came from the present era to the Segoku jidai are Shizuko, her uncle, and the oldman.

All of them were transported while they were in the proximity to Shizuko´s grandfather lands (no idea wath could mean aside from convenience for the story), and also in the case of uncle, he is the only that went from the past to the future and also the one wich got amnesia after travel in time (and only traveling to the future), so for me this is foreshadowing to Nobunaga´s traveling to the future at the end of the story.

But this is pretty mich all I got to support my theory, after Shizuko started to participate in war related affairs I didnt found nothing relevant, I though in some moment her sister memories as a fan of war history and weapons would become more relevant but nothing at all. Im kinda specting some type of mini reveal of her sister at some point traveled to the past for a short time, returned and that was ingnited her interest in war history. But honestly Im kinda forcing my own writing preferences with this last idea so dont take it too seriously
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 15, 2019
Messages
1,561
People get fucking water poisoning from 3 gallons of water: THEY WERE JUST GETTING STARTED AT 3.8 GALLONS OF SAKE?!?!?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
2,991
Sorry if I sounded pretentious with my choice of words, I just wanted to know if someone else found more clues if that was the case. Until now all the transported people that came from the present era to the Segoku jidai are Shizuko, her uncle, and the oldman.

All of them were transported while they were in the proximity to Shizuko´s grandfather lands (no idea wath could mean aside from convenience for the story), and also in the case of uncle, he is the only that went from the past to the future and also the one wich got amnesia after travel in time (and only traveling to the future), so for me this is foreshadowing to Nobunaga´s traveling to the future at the end of the story.

But this is pretty mich all I got to support my theory, after Shizuko started to participate in war related affairs I didnt found nothing relevant, I though in some moment her sister memories as a fan of war history and weapons would become more relevant but nothing at all. Im kinda specting some type of mini reveal of her sister at some point traveled to the past for a short time, returned and that was ingnited her interest in war history. But honestly Im kinda forcing my own writing preferences with this last idea so dont take it too seriously
Itd be a convenient explanation for why her grandfather was multi-disciplined and had a wide range of friends and acquaintances in various fields.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
May 1, 2019
Messages
108
Ingesting a vast amount of alcohol in a short time can actually be fatal. There's a term for it: alcohol poisoning. Don't copy this fiction irl
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 21, 2018
Messages
1,058
Were spies looked down on and undervalued, in these times? Bushido didn't exist, as a code, until after the Sengoku period. It's an anachronism to project more modern notions of "samurai honor" into those times. Generals like Takeda Shingen were familiar with the writings of Sun Tzu, who wrote an entire chapter on the use of spies.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 6, 2018
Messages
1,687
Were spies looked down on and undervalued, in these times? Bushido didn't exist, as a code, until after the Sengoku period. It's an anachronism to project more modern notions of "samurai honor" into those times. Generals like Takeda Shingen were familiar with the writings of Sun Tzu, who wrote an entire chapter on the use of spies.

Not really since a lot of Samurai had spy networks (The Tokugawa with the Iga Hattori and the Hojo with the Koga Fuuma) and were led by Samurai leaders.

I think it's moreso that the vast majority of these spies were commoners and sengoku society was very hierachical so the compensation was probably skewed. I'm only speaking from conjecture though.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 21, 2020
Messages
333
Shizuko prevents Kenshin's death and recruits Masayuki and his spies. I wonder if Sasuke is also among the spies
probably not
  • he is not a real historical figure, so the chance of him existing here is low
  • even if he exists, he would still just be a kid somewhere, consider his lord Yukimura is still a toddler (assuming that's him at page 12)
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 18, 2018
Messages
1,635
Mitsuo's children will have to carry a heavy legacy. And another one seems to be on the way given how his wife is reacting to his new title.
 
Active member
Joined
Jan 16, 2023
Messages
26
It would be funny if Kenshin actually drop dead sooner than history due to severe withdrawal syndrome.

Seriously, if you are actually alcoholic, do not quit cold turkey lol. Consult doctors.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 18, 2018
Messages
85
Were spies looked down on and undervalued, in these times? Bushido didn't exist, as a code, until after the Sengoku period. It's an anachronism to project more modern notions of "samurai honor" into those times. Generals like Takeda Shingen were familiar with the writings of Sun Tzu, who wrote an entire chapter on the use of spies.
Yep, I have a friend who used to be a real clubber in her twenties - I used to joke about how often she appeared in club scene photos every month.

She didn’t stop drinking after breaking her leg, drunkenly slamming a car door on it, but she did stop after spending two days in hospital from alcohol poisoning.

She’s now a regional manager in a multinational.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 25, 2018
Messages
587
Now that she got the Sanada joining her, it won't be long until the Sanada Yukimura serving under her as well.

Speaking of which, I wonder if his older brother Nobuyuki will marry Tadakatsu's daughter in this lifetime. Historically he was supposed to serve under the Tokugawa to preserve the Sanada bloodline. Also, what was that retainer thinking really, taking him the hostage back. It's no wonder why they were being pursued by both sides.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 31, 2018
Messages
5,493
Sorry if I sounded pretentious with my choice of words, I just wanted to know if someone else found more clues if that was the case. Until now all the transported people that came from the present era to the Segoku jidai are Shizuko, her uncle, and the oldman.

All of them were transported while they were in the proximity to Shizuko´s grandfather lands (no idea wath could mean aside from convenience for the story), and also in the case of uncle, he is the only that went from the past to the future and also the one wich got amnesia after travel in time (and only traveling to the future), so for me this is foreshadowing to Nobunaga´s traveling to the future at the end of the story.

But this is pretty mich all I got to support my theory, after Shizuko started to participate in war related affairs I didnt found nothing relevant, I though in some moment her sister memories as a fan of war history and weapons would become more relevant but nothing at all. Im kinda specting some type of mini reveal of her sister at some point traveled to the past for a short time, returned and that was ingnited her interest in war history. But honestly Im kinda forcing my own writing preferences with this last idea so dont take it too seriously
Wait wait wait... I didn't mean anything bad about your comment, I really think it is an interesting idea and was just giving my answer about whether anyone mentioned it or not.

Please, I was not trying to imply anything else, I am sorry if my comment transmitted that idea.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 5, 2019
Messages
169
Wait wait wait... I didn't mean anything bad about your comment, I really think it is an interesting idea and was just giving my answer about whether anyone mentioned it or not.

Please, I was not trying to imply anything else, I am sorry if my comment transmitted that idea.
Dont worry, I just not always undertand the tone of others people texts so I try to be precise with my lenguage wich I struggle with because Im ESL. Thanks for saying my theory was interesting
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 25, 2018
Messages
587
Btw, you mistranslated Kenshin's title. He is known as the Dragon of Echigo. You are confusing him with Takeda, who is known as the Tiger of Kai.
 
Power Uploader
Joined
Jan 13, 2019
Messages
274
Btw, you mistranslated Kenshin's title. He is known as the Dragon of Echigo. You are confusing him with Takeda, who is known as the Tiger of Kai.
1786183682911.png

I double check it but in the raw it said 越後の虎と (Tiger of Echigo).
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top