Shinen no Majutsushi ~Hangyakusha to shite Yuuheisareta Ore wa Fushi no Karada to Saikyou no Chikara wo Teniire Boukensha to shite Nariagaru~

[jagfanbb]

TLDR: yes, its the usual trash

That's being generous

As a man of culture I must say that even trash is more enjoyable than this

The writing is ass and they don't show enough ass to make up for it

 

[Urdine]

The term 'trash' gets thrown around a lot on mangadex, iv enjoyed (to some degree) some manga that others have absolutely shit all over, this is not one of those manga.

The art is passable, but the writing , character design and plot are degrees of unfun cringe that I very quickly found myself skimming through pages in hopes of getting to something more interesting, it never happened. There is almost nothing of redeeming value in this one I am afraid, it really is deserving of the title Trashekai - because it will transport you to another manga instantly.

 

[Xoldin]

Wow, another manga where the MC is given literally everything without having to work for it.

 

[Baddtraxx]

hey this is actually pretty okay

 

[Hebo720]

Uhm can we talk about the title?

 

[Wyrm]

Uhm can we talk about the title?

Long titles that spoil the first few chapters are the norm with low-tier fantasy manga.
This is just a few more drops of uninspired hackery in a sea of cliches.

 

[Ekuzeiru]

bruh, no good

 

[Seifenbroten]

Not even Chat GPT could create a less mediocre story 🤡

 

[crispy-whiskers]

i read the first chapter. and i was FLABBERGASTED. theres another manga i unfortunately read, called Tensei Kizoku no Isekai Boukenroku which i initially thought was the most trash, generic isekai plot manga there was. i read it to make sure my taste is still good, so that if i catch an update and suddenly enjoy it, i can stop reading manga and stop the damage.

this manga tho... surpasses it in every single way. in fact, its so bad i cannot stand reading it. looks like i am to continue reading manga then.

 

[BozMagic]

I genuinely don't know how this is on the popular rotation, I had to drop this 3 times and pick it up 3 times in the span of like 2 weeks to even fully get through the first volume. But they just have the generic parts but skip the good parts about the usual generic shows, like:

• Training up the other people in the party
• Training arc to become strong
• Showing off
• Adventurers guild and quests
• World building (even a little bit would help)
• Any semblance of character development or having the side characters being more than a one dimensional trope

Yeah. It's worse than trash somehow.

 

[Eastos]

Reading the comments are much more entertaining than reading the actual manga 🤣

 

[Leviathan1132]

How tf did this hit the "popular new titles" banner on the home page? Its not good, like at all

im wondering the same

 

[berubetto]

How tf is this on the Popular carousel

Bribery?
Sign of the end of Mangakind?
... Typo?

 

[OisE]

That's garbage don't read it.

 

[Jergens]

once again baited by the animal eared girl on the cover art

 

[Gunex]

How tf did this hit the "popular new titles" banner on the home page? Its not good, like at all

Came here to say that as well. XD
Who bribed Mr John MangaDex to get this listed on there.

 

[Hicleric]

The thing with a popular titles list is...they tend to make said titles even more popular

Trash isekai (/pixiv one-pager) generates a certain number of clicks. People complain about the quality in the forum, causing the title to repeatedly show up in the comments list. Others see the complaints and click to see what the fuss is about. Number of engagements puts title in top ten. Exposure from top ten list pushes awareness of the title to those who missed it and didn't see it in the forum. Engagement rises, securing a position in the top ten list. Repeat ad nauseum.

Is a horrible positive feedback loop of negativity

 

[jagfanbb]

The term 'trash' gets thrown around a lot on mangadex, iv enjoyed (to some degree) some manga that others have absolutely shit all over, this is not one of those manga.

The art is passable, but the writing , character design and plot are degrees of unfun cringe that I very quickly found myself skimming through pages in hopes of getting to something more interesting, it never happened. There is almost nothing of redeeming value in this one I am afraid, it really is deserving of the title Trashekai - because it will transport you to another manga instantly.

so.... you agree it's trash then... 🤨

 

[1boring]

How tf did this hit the "popular new titles" banner on the home page? Its not good, like at all

Seriously. It's at #3 with a 5 rating. What is up with MD's popular threshold? Is it viewcounts or something. I usually have a high 'bad' tolerance but this is impressively boring and generic.

 

[definitionofinsanity]

Prove to me an AI didn't write the story to this.

No, no. It's so fucking generic that the burden of proof is on the mangaka/author/publisher, I don't care. I refuse to believe that this wasn't written by an AI until I see proof otherwise.