Shinju no Nectar - Ch. 48 - The Worthy

Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Aug 27, 2018
Messages
388
@omegaxis1
It certainly wouldn't be the first time a Japanese series holds monarchy as The Best Thing Ever (as long as the "right" person is in charge, of course), where "the monarch should have all the power" is seen as the solution to all problems, or that fetishizes Ancien Regime empires and aristocracies over "ineffectual", "corrupt" and "not as cool" democracies.

That said, given its good use of historical tropes in previous chapters and Albion's obvious parallelisms with England, I believe this may be a commentary on how uprisings in the style of the French Revolution or 19th century revolutions didn't take root in the British Empire. As Britain, Albion may be monarchical, imperialistic and aristocratic, but it has liberties that Dhala seems to lack, and a parliament where people hostile to the current monarch can make a career. Even if certain politicians and many youngsters might have radical democratic sympathies, a revolt like the academy's was too artificial to be believable, which was Luka's point.
 
Joined
Jun 8, 2018
Messages
70
@omegaxis1 problem is not democracy vs monarchy, but power struggle in the middle of the war. Insurrection at these times only brings trouble to everyone in the country. And monarchy isn't always bad, it depends on how much power royalty have, how much power nobles have and it seems they have, is there a parlament or not, monarch is just like president if there is strong parlament in the country.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 2, 2019
Messages
4,230
@Misticsan Well, to be fair, it's not put as democracy itself is bad. Just that at the start, it might not be the best. Especially during a world war.

It often works better nowadays solely because many of the world's most powerful nations are democratic and can actually help other nations along.

@omegaxis1 I don't think the problem is actually wanting democracy, but HOW it's wanted. I mean, this is not the best moment to try and change your governmental regime.

Plus the actual people involved. An evil dude wanting democracy or an a good queen.

I don't think the author is trying to promote a political ideology in the story, rather, the good guy is just the prince for the plot point.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Jul 29, 2018
Messages
985
And this awful arc is over!
ALL HAIL THE NEW BIG TITTIES.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 28, 2020
Messages
2,544
> She was happy she was able to offer her meat buns for a suck... Nice one...

> To think the girl on the last pages, she uses her own meat buns to multiply the firing power and adjusted the firing scope of her three arrows.
Those technique, i only learned it now, and be gladly to share to anyone who seeks research reference purposes only...
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Aug 27, 2018
Messages
388
@deathmailrock @omegaxis1
True enough. For a time, I thought that Dhala and Albion were in a Cold War, officially at peace but fighting in practice through proxies like the Lemurian Company and puppet states. However, chapter 5 states that Albion declared war on Dhala due to the invasion of Adaar. Even if actual battles are limited to the colonies, a revolution could put Albion itself in danger.

Now I'm reminded of how the Spanish troops that were gathered to fight the rebels in their American colonies revolted against the king in 1820. The result was a more democratic, but short-lived revolutionary government and the loss of almost all of Spain's colonial empire. I bet Dhala would have liked something similar to happen to Albion.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 29, 2020
Messages
864
Those short wrap ups are a little upsetting. What about the ones pulling the strings and the repercussion? What about the students? Don't just throw us straight into the next nation....
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top