It's kinda sad in its own way though. At this point in the story at least, the appraisal makes the world disturbingly and irrevocably deterministic. I am not a huge fan of pure shounen notions of "just BeLiEvE in yourself, and you can do AnYtHiNg", but here we have this 5-star SSR insanely skilled individual that should (and would) be recruited at any costs, and here are hundreds of 1-star mobs that will never get a chance.
Their respectable futures are literally decided the moment our hero gazes at them and deems them unworthy.
Well, I still won't deny the possibility we'll see some kind of subversion, so it's fine, I guess.