The Saga of Tanya the Evil - Vol. 14 Ch. 38 - Trial by Fire IV

[Kaiser92]

Yeah, whataboutism in how you compared an unprompted and unwarranted declaration of war to just getting beaten up. Glad you manned up and noticed your own mistake there.

Strawman as well

 

[Raquya]

Strawman as well

"Hey that guy beat me up, I'm justified when I murdered him, mutilated his corpse, strung him up for the whole town to see, burned down his whole neighborhood and then nuked the whole planet so that no one can ever hurt me again."

Do you have short term memory loss as well?

 

[Kaiser92]

"Hey that guy beat me up, I'm justified when I murdered him, mutilated his corpse, strung him up for the whole town to see, burned down his whole neighborhood and then nuked the whole planet so that no one can ever hurt me again."

Do you have short term memory loss as well?

And where did i say anything abt "an unprompted and unwarranted declaration of war" huh? Bro you should learn to read better.

 

[Raquya]

And where did i say anything abt "an unprompted and unwarranted declaration of war" huh? Bro you should learn to read better.

What do you think lead to the situation you were crying about in the first place?

Are you actually incapable of understanding or considering what happens beyond first order consequences?

 

[Kaiser92]

What do you think lead to the situation you were crying about in the first place?

Are you actually incapable of understanding or considering what happens beyond first order consequences?

Whatever you guys said @WhimsiCat, @KitsuVonKraft, shit is still WRONG, stop trying to justify mass murder.

Learn to read bro

 

[Raquya]

Learn to read bro

And therein lies my point. The "mass murder" youre crying about is the second order consequence of declaring war on your neighbor whos now trying to end it as safely for them as possible.

What youre doing here is the equivalent of victim blaming someone for defending themselves from their abuser.

 

[Kaiser92]

And therein lies my point. The "mass murder" youre crying about is the second order consequence of declaring war on your neighbor whos now trying to end it as safely for them as possible.

What youre doing here is the equivalent of victim blaming someone for defending themselves from their abuser.

By mass murdering they are "trying to end it as safely for them as possible."
Yeah right, I got a bridge to sell ya, interested?

 

[Raquya]

By mass murdering they are "trying to end it as safely for them as possible."
Yeah right, I got a bridge to sell ya, interested?

What do you think war is...

 

[Kaiser92]

What do you think war is...

You think war is for mass murdering of civilian and noncombatant?

 

[Raquya]

You think war is for mass murdering of civilian and noncombatant?

For? No, but does it happen during war? Yes.

Like the french partisans killing all the PoWs and Empire civilians just because they got angry that Tanya ordered them to lay down their arms.

Even the Brit spy realized the Empire werent in the wrong here 🤦‍♂️

 

[Kaiser92]

For? No, but does it happen during war? Yes.

Like the french partisans killing all the PoWs and Empire civilians just because they got angry that Tanya ordered them to lay down their arms.

Even the Brit spy realized the Empire werent in the wrong here 🤦‍♂️

Ok imma let you in a secret:
The spy is the author expy and not in any way knows abt actual law lol
The writing here is exaggerated for comedic effect.
Please don't just mistake this manga for real life.

The french partisans are also in the wrong bro, but the law is quite clear, you can't just mass murder the whole city especially when they are running away like that bruh.

Tanya is talking out of her ass abt the rules of war.
Remember, she's a salaryman and only know them from book and cultural osmosis, not actual lawyer.
The whole "we did it by the letter of the law" spiel is bs.
Her interpretation would not fly in real trial and she only escape being bring to court bcs she hid her crime.

Thanks for the laugh, I can't believe there's actual ppl who think Tanya is the good guy after 30+ chapters

 

[Raquya]

Ok imma let you in a secret:
The spy is the author expy and not in any way knows abt actual law lol
The writing here is exaggerated for comedic effect.
Please don't just mistake this manga for real life.

The french partisans are also in the wrong bro, but the law is quite clear, you can't just mass murder the whole city especially when they are running away like that bruh.

Tanya is talking out of her ass abt the rules of war.
Remember, she's a salaryman and only know them from book and cultural osmosis, not actual lawyer.
The whole "we did it by the letter of the law" spiel is bs.
Her interpretation would not fly in real trial and she only escape being bring to court bcs she hid her crime.

Thanks for the laugh, I can't believe there's actual ppl who think Tanya is the good guy after 30+ chapters

You cant just invade your neighboring country just because youre jealous of them either yet here we are in the story.

Do you think all the civilians and soldiers alike who died because of their aggression deserved it either?

And who said anything about Tanya being good or not? Im talking about how the french and other countries explicitly started all this and then people like you cry for them now just because theyre losing. You seem incapable of understanding the nuance of that for some reason. Are you a liberal by any chance?

 

[Kaiser92]

You cant just invade your neighboring country just because youre jealous of them either yet here we are in the story.

Do you think all the civilians and soldiers alike who died because of their aggression deserved it either?

And who said anything about Tanya being good or not? Im talking about how the french and other countries explicitly started all this and then people like you cry for them now just because theyre losing. You seem incapable of understanding the nuance of that for some reason. Are you a liberal by any chance?

You can't just execute civilian just by designating "enemy combatant" bro.
You sound quite hang up on the invading part, was your country got curb stomped in the past that it left such deep trauma?
Do you think all the civilians and soldiers alike who died because of Tanya's aggression deserved it?
Stop crying abt being branded war criminal, if you don't want to do the time, don't do the crime bro.
You seem incapable of understanding the nuance of that for some reason. Are you a conservative by any chance?

 

[Raquya]

You can't just execute civilian just by designating "enemy combatant" bro.
You sound quite hang up on the invading part, was your country got curb stomped in the past that it left such deep trauma?
Do you think all the civilians and soldiers alike who died because of Tanya's aggression deserved it?
Stop crying abt being branded war criminal, if you don't want to do the time, don't do the crime bro.
You seem incapable of understanding the nuance of that for some reason. Are you a conservative by any chance?

There would be no war crimes or criminals if there was no war in the first place. Why are you so blaise on the other countries invading the Empire and put blame only on what the Empire are doing to defend themselves?

There would be no civilians dying in the first place if there was no war. Why are you so hung up on the war crimes yet have no care for the fact the war was started by the losers in the first place 🤦‍♂️

"You can't just execute civilian just by designating "enemy combatant" bro." You can, very easily too in war times. The current aversion to it is only because of modern sensibilities, something they didnt have yet back in the WW1 era.

And yes I am. I see you still havent answered my question either. Afraid?

 

[Kaiser92]

There would be no war crimes or criminals if there was no war in the first place. Why are you so blaise on the other countries invading the Empire and put blame only on what the Empire are doing to defend themselves?

There would be no civilians dying in the first place if there was no war. Why are you so hung up on the war crimes yet have no care for the fact the war was started by the losers in the first place 🤦‍♂️

"You can't just execute civilian just by designating "enemy combatant" bro." You can, very easily too in war times. The current aversion to it is only because of modern sensibilities, something they didnt have yet back in the WW1 era.

And yes I am. I see you still havent answered my question either. Afraid?

Bro I think you are projecting too hard. I haven't said a word abt the Empire this entire time bro, go back and check, go on.
Bro I was talking explicitly abt Tanya and co bro. What the frick are you prattling on abt bro?

You can, very easily too in war times.

Bro that's not how law work bro
That was how Japan justified spreading plaques on the Chinese in WW2 bro.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731

It routinely conducted tests on people who were dehumanized and internally referred to as "logs". Victims were further dehumanized by being confined in facilities referred to as "log cabins".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaimingjie_germ_weapon_attack

Modern sensibilities

I'm not liberal bro, do you need to check my genital as well?
Bro this shit ain't WW1, remember the pseudo-V2, Pz IV etc?
Bro you are defending the Empire really hard there, trigger much?
Bro all the countries in WW2 did a lot of horrific fuck up shit bro, that doesn't make "a little mass murder" justifiable bro.
Bro you coping ok? Trouble at home?

 

[Raquya]

Bro I think you are projecting too hard. I haven't said a word abt the Empire this entire time bro, go back and check, go on.
Bro I was talking explicitly abt Tanya and co bro. What the frick are you prattling on abt bro?

Yeah exactly you havent said anything about who was actually responsible for the war yet have no problems assigning blame to the ones just defending themselves 🤦‍♂️

What exactly do you think will happen if a clandestine force manages to entrench themselves within the populace of a vital logistics hub? You realize that even america with all their advanced tech and weapons over the afghans could never root them out completely? How do you think a country almost a century behind in tech will fare?

This is literally WW1. Just because they have slightly advanced tech from our WW2 times doesnt mean they get to skip it. The series takes place in the 1920-30s 🤦‍♂️

It was an entire plot point that the idea of a world war was a wild idea for even the top brass when Tanya explained it. Did you actually read the manga or did you just look at the pictures and skip all the text?

 

[Raquya]

Bro this shit ain't WW1, remember the pseudo-V2, Pz IV etc?

Wait you think this is world war 2 just because they have stuff from ww2? Being this stupid actually makes so much sense now.

Also yeah youre pretty much a liberal by the way you think and look at things or more accurately, are unable to understand what you see. Eg this entire discussion.

 

[Kaiser92]

Yeah exactly you havent said anything about who was actually responsible for the war yet have no problems assigning blame to the ones just defending themselves 🤦‍♂️

Bro cry more, keep defending war crime
I don't give a shit abt who started this war, it's Being X all the way down.
All the countries in this manga is fucked up, just like the real world, but taken to 11.
Bro where's the mandatory "Israel has the right to defend itself"/"Why haven't you condemned Hamas"?
Unlike you illiterate peasant I actually read the frikking NOVELS and the author commentary

What exactly do you think will happen if a clandestine force manages to entrench themselves within the populace of a vital logistics hub?

Try not to commit war crime, else the enemy do the same to you and yours.

This is literally WW1.

Lmao
Carlos mixed and matched both wars bro

they have slightly advanced tech

Lmao, "slightly"
Middle school lvl of science education

Wait you think this is world war 2 just because they have stuff from ww2? Being this stupid actually makes so much sense now.

Wait you think this is world war 1 just because they have stuff from ww1? Being this stupid actually makes so much sense now.

Also yeah youre pretty much a liberal by the way you think and look at things or more accurately, are unable to understand what you see.

Haha typical school kid understanding of politics Have they teach you about the Southern Strategy in school yet? Or do you just watch PragerU?

 

[Raquya]

Bro cry more, keep defending war crime
I don't give a shit abt who started this war, it's Being X all the way down.
All the countries in this manga is fucked up, just like the real world, but taken to 11.
Bro where's the mandatory "Israel has the right to defend itself"/"Why haven't you condemned Hamas"?
Unlike you illiterate peasant I actually read the frikking NOVELS and the author commentary


Try not to commit war crime, else the enemy do the same to you and yours.


Lmao
Carlos mixed and matched both wars bro


Lmao, "slightly"
Middle school lvl of science education


Wait you think this is world war 1 just because they have stuff from ww1? Being this stupid actually makes so much sense now.

Haha typical school kid understanding of politics Have they teach you about the Southern Strategy in school yet? Or do you just watch PragerU?

Its world war 1 because its the first world war in this world 🤦‍♂️. Do you think the numbers after the words were just put there for fun?

And the other countries already started this by escalating to a war in the first place. Why is it so hard for you to understand this? There would be no "war crimes" if there was no war in the first place 🤦‍♂️.

 

[Kaiser92]

Its world war 1 because its the first world war in this world 🤦‍♂️. Do you think the numbers after the words were just put there for fun?

The current aversion to it is only because of modern sensibilities, something they didnt have yet back in the WW1 era.

This is literally WW1. Just because they have slightly advanced tech from our WW2 times doesnt mean they get to skip it.

Bro keep on moving goal post

You realize that even america with all their advanced tech and weapons over the afghans could never root them out completely?

Yes they can, they just chose not to, bcs of the implications: WAR CRIME

And the other countries already started this by escalating to a war in the first place. Why is it so hard for you to understand this?

So? Still war crime. Why is it so hard for you to understand this?

There would be no "war crimes" if there was no war in the first place 🤦‍♂️.

There would have been no sin if human doesn't exist lmao
MF think the World War would not happened if the Empire is left alone