Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2019
- Messages
- 3,197
Fuck all the people rating 0 just cuz it's a manhua
The Saintess Has a Showdown
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
?
0 rating cuz manhua,
seriously ?
what kind of yuri, GL on this fucking shit ?
only edgy kid fight each other, no fucking romance, just bullshit shounen battle, this is definitely deserve 0 rate
it's tagged yuri because it featured lesbian sex you moron - do you even read this manhua?
edgy kid fight each other? what the fuck are you talking about?
no fucking romance in a manhua that has no romance tag no fucking way
bullshit shounen battle? this manhua has better story than 90% mangas/manhuas/manhwas out there and this deserve 0 rating?
get the fuck out if you just want to troll
it's just the english translation that's dead, the raw is still active at 2 ch/week
you can either mtl them with OCR + Google Translate using apps like Google Lens, read it on MTL aggregator, or just wait for someone to pick it up
also, there's this common opinion that the manhua doesn't explain the plot well especially in Rua's storyline but if you compare it to the original novel where they explaining it the manhua version is still better
Supporter
- Joined
- Sep 22, 2018
- Messages
- 1,591
Rather than saying it worse at explaining it's more like the novel explaining too much for its own good
the novel is the epitome of "tell, don't show" type of storytelling that give kinda amateurish feeling, it won't translate well to visual format even if they do the manhua won't get far as the it currently is. The reason why the manhua's story feels solid because they are making effort in rewriting the original story in "show, don't tell" fashion (of course with such a fast release schedule 2 chapters a week it is impossible to do that perfectly, especially when they have to make new plot with little time to optimize them)
And some plot doesn't urgently need to be explained actually - Rua's motivation in her storyline in around chapter 180s for example (not gonna say here what she did because spoiler). As the story goes further the plot later will self-explain as for why she had to do what she did. But if they explaining it the way the novel goes the end result will be way less dramatic and there's no bittersweet feeling like it does in the manhua version (actually Rua's storyline in the novel version is pretty anti-climatic and kinda meh, the author just use her storyline to hype the next arc).
Also, it will be boring if they need to explain the plot to readers. They do that in some of the new plots (especially in around chapter 300s) and it feels like the story kinda dragging too much.
Not sure if this thread the right place to ask it. This manhua is Chinese, not Japanese. And the Saintess in this manhua doesn't have the same meaning as Saintess in Japanese mangas.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- May 25, 2020
- Messages
- 290
You're right, I didn't realize it is a manhua. But the word is exactly the same in both languages, 聖女 / 圣女, which is apparently typically translated as "Saint" or "Holy maiden" in English. I'll probably have to dig a little deeper into this. As for her role in the context of the story, I can't really agree or disagree, since I just skimmed through it. But not like two "Japanese Saintesses" are the same either, so I don't quite get what you mean when you say refer to the meaning of Saintesses in mangas.
You'll get what I mean if you read the story.
troll >? troll your ass
idiot motherf***ker !
do I even read ? why would I even fucking read this ?
just 3 or 5 chapters and I already see this kind of shit going to ?
this shit had no fucking story but a fucking bullshit shounen battle? am I wrong ?
can you pointing out what chapter's scene that have sex ?
just a lame fuck story with system, with how Im fucking level up power by sitting with mediation.
yeah I did search the raw, why would you even need to milking this shit for more than 300 chapters to describe yuri.
and again, with more than 300 chapters, why would I even need to waste my time for some bullshit that focus more of fighting than bringing GL element ?
dont you fucking get it ? doesnt even matter for this kind of story cuz you can swap gender, male lead instead of female and still doesnt change the the goal of this show.
just a cheap fucking knock off shounen trash !
oH and why did I said "edgy kid", just to describe generation these day love violence with characters killing each other, and you're one of them for sure, idiot !
don't make shit up just because you managed to count the number of chapter
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Oct 8, 2023
- Messages
- 473
I hope this gets updated , kinda sad I won't be able to follow this manhua since the bilibili all got shutdown , unless someone picked this up
All English release currently only translated with MTL. Most decent one is released by Snow Machine Translation simply because it doesn't change the flavour and the tone of the dialogues, though the accuracy and consistency of the translation can't beat if you MTL it yourself with chatGPT or other AI. There's another one on Mangapark but that one somehow has its dialogues sounds very off and weird.
For the release schedule Snow Machine Translation group has the fastest release, with the lastest chapter on 376 released the same day as the Chinese raw.
For the release schedule Snow Machine Translation group has the fastest release, with the lastest chapter on 376 released the same day as the Chinese raw.
Similar threads
