@macarroiz Glad I'm not the only one!
In all honesty, I'm reasonably certain that, along with other languages of the Far East, Japanese simply doesn't have the terminology for identifying types servants in Western setting without adding some adjectives (which is exactly what we have to do in order to translate some of their terms, it's how translation works). As such, when the author evidently uses traditional
Eastern organization and job divisions for servants, I can put up with it (and internally bemoan the author's carelessness). Thing is, while I'm not certain about
Falling in Love With the Villainess (never read that one myself), this one clearly uses
Western organization and job divisions for servants. In other words, the authors
are differentiating properly; the
translators are not — whomever is in charge of QC really aught to catch and correct that. Outside of Europe, a lot of people
don't bother, resulting in "footman" being replaced with "butler," and awkward terms like "personal butler" (personal manager of all servants— really?) and "head maid" (yeah, that's called a "housekeeper"). There are some complexities, such as the fact that butlers and housekeepers are already for a fairly large household (it is otherwise the job of the lady of the house, whomever that may be), the presence of a "first maid" or "first footman" (assistants to the housekeeper and butler respectively) for larger estates, and the position of "head butler," which is exclusive to estates so massive that multiple managers are needed (in England, there are only a handful of estates which have ever used the term, if that gives an idea). Non-native speakers aside, anyone who enjoys European historical settings (or general Western, including America, such as something set in the Gilded Age)
should not be carelessly propagating this kind of error, one caused by sheer laziness. After all, when in doubt or uninformed,
Look. It. Up: the internet makes it really quick and easy. If the information can easily be found,
as this one can, there really isn't an excuse. Sorry for the rant; as you can tell, it bothers me a lot.