Tokidoki Bosotto Roshia-go de Dereru Tonari no Alya-san - Ch. 47 - If You’re an Otaku, It Should be Something You Yearn For (1)

[BobBob]

What is her plan? Also who's getting left out? Or will someone double up?

 

[excitionzero]

This shit is actually real
how in the fuck this even got a 9+ is baffling

 

[Volcanron]

The fact that multiple people have commented on how this is not in the anime just makes me sad. They really took a series with realistic and layered characters and just cut them in half.

 

[Exile]

The fact that multiple people have commented on how this is not in the anime just makes me sad. They really took a series with realistic and layered characters and just cut them in half.

Because when you adapt from one format to another there are things that are naturally lost, some "adaptations" end up being their own thing (Mai-HiME for example).

The problem with animation is you have a limited runtime, they just had 12 episodes and you need a end point so they adapted just the election arc, both Manga and LN naturally have their own break points but its different as they can extend, end points are also difference since a LN only needs to worry about its volume page count as a manga have not only volume end point but also each chapter.

People shouldnt fault the Anime because it had this whole arc to cover with only 12 episodes to do it, as much people think this "little moments" add due to their limited runtime they have to pick and chose ... of course there are bad adaptations but its very unlikely series can get a 1:1 adaptation with unlimited runtime and even in those cases you can end up with the anime "catching up" to the manga (as series take breaks) and then we have the dreaded "padding", Anime Originals that just exist so the Manga can get further ahead so they can adapt it.

 

[excitionzero]

this manga still ass though

 

[Volcanron]

Because when you adapt from one format to another there are things that are naturally lost, some "adaptations" end up being their own thing (Mai-HiME for example).

The problem with animation is you have a limited runtime, they just had 12 episodes and you need a end point so they adapted just the election arc, both Manga and LN naturally have their own break points but its different as they can extend, end points are also difference since a LN only needs to worry about its volume page count as a manga have not only volume end point but also each chapter.

People shouldnt fault the Anime because it had this whole arc to cover with only 12 episodes to do it, as much people think this "little moments" add due to their limited runtime they have to pick and chose ... of course there are bad adaptations but its very unlikely series can get a 1:1 adaptation with unlimited runtime and even in those cases you can end up with the anime "catching up" to the manga (as series take breaks) and then we have the dreaded "padding", Anime Originals that just exist so the Manga can get further ahead so they can adapt it.

You know normally I would agree with this, but we recently have had a slew of anime that have not only adapted on the source material perfectly, but even elevated it beyond anything else with new additions. Frieren, The Apothecary Diaries, Bocchi The Rock!, Eminence In Shadow, and 100 Girlfriends are all shining examples. Not to mention the plethora of other shows that simply adapt everything properly and don't cut. So yeah, forgive me for hoping that the anime would continue the trend of all these great adaptations and not seemingly chop the characters in half.

 

[Lex79]

Looking forward for some embarrassing feeding next chapter.

 

[excitionzero]

The fact that this anime is getting a season 2 is seriously bullshit man
How in the fuck did this even got an anime in the first place?
Overrated as fuck that’s what it is

 

[excitionzero]

Calling me dumb doesn’t change what I said
go fuck yourself on that front

 

[wallsg]

You know normally I would agree with this, but we recently have had a slew of anime that have not only adapted on the source material perfectly, but even elevated it beyond anything else with new additions. Frieren, The Apothecary Diaries, Bocchi The Rock!, Eminence In Shadow, and 100 Girlfriends are all shining examples. Not to mention the plethora of other shows that simply adapt everything properly and don't cut. So yeah, forgive me for hoping that the anime would continue the trend of all these great adaptations and not seemingly chop the characters in half.

And then you have anime like Horimiya that most enjoyed that cut so much that they were able to make a full additional season out of the cut content.

There is no right answer.

 

[Carn109]

Russian roulette
Also based Yuki